Red fluorescent cAMP indicator with increased affinity and expanded dynamic range

Yusaku Ohta, Toshiaki Furuta, Takeharu Nagai, Kazuki HorikawaScientific 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new red fluorescent indicator for cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP), named R-FlincA. This indicator boasts significantly higher affinity and a broader dynamic range than previous tools, enabling the detection of subtle cAMP signals previously missed, which is crucial for understanding various biological processes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) is a vital second messenger involved in numerous cellular functions, from synaptic plasticity to insulin secretion. Accurately tracking cAMP dynamics within living cells is essential for understanding these processes. However, existing fluorescent indicators often suffer from limitations: they may have insufficient sensitivity to detect low cAMP concentrations (sub-micromolar), or their dynamic range (the difference between the maximum and minimum signal) is too narrow to capture the full spectrum of cAMP fluctuations. This gap makes it difficult to observe subtle, spontaneous cAMP signaling events that occur in physiological conditions. The paper aims to address this by developing a more sensitive and versatile cAMP indicator.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the design of R-FlincA. Instead of the typical approach of inserting a sensor into a fluorescent protein, the researchers took a different route: they inserted a circularly permuted red fluorescent protein (cp146mApple) into the cAMP-binding motif of the PKA regulatory subunit Iα (RIα). This strategy was inspired by successful calcium indicators. They screened various insertion points within the RIα cAMP-binding domain and identified a specific insertion that yielded the desired properties.

Key techniques employed include:

  • Molecular Cloning and Protein Engineering: Designing and constructing the R-FlincA construct by inserting cp146mApple into the RIα cAMP-binding motif.
  • Cell-Based Assays: Transfecting 293T cells with the indicator constructs to assess fluorescence changes upon stimulation with Forskolin (FSK), a known cAMP elevator.
  • Spectroscopy: Characterizing the excitation and emission spectra of the purified R-FlincA protein.
  • In Vitro Binding Assays: Determining the dissociation constant (Kd) for cAMP and cGMP, as well as the Hill coefficient, to quantify affinity and cooperativity.
  • Confocal Microscopy: Performing live-cell imaging in Dictyostelium discoideum and MIN6 pancreatic beta cells to visualize cAMP dynamics.
  • Multi-channel Imaging: Combining R-FlincA with other fluorescent indicators (e.g., for Ca2+ and ATP) to perform simultaneous imaging of multiple signaling pathways.
  • Photo-uncaging: Using caged cAMP compounds to precisely control extracellular cAMP levels and assess indicator sensitivity.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention the use of large, pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it focuses on the creation and characterization of a novel biological sensor. The "datasets" in this context are the experimental results obtained from:

  • 293T cell cultures: Used for initial screening and validation of the R-FlincA indicator.
  • Dictyostelium discoideum cells: Employed to demonstrate the indicator's sensitivity in detecting spontaneous cAMP signaling and its utility in environmental imaging.
  • MIN6 pancreatic beta cells: Used to showcase multi-channel imaging capabilities for studying glucose-induced insulin secretion.

The paper introduces R-FlincA as a new tool, and its performance is benchmarked against existing cAMP indicators like Flamindo2 and Pink-FL.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Novel Design Strategy: The successful insertion of a fluorescent protein into the cAMP-binding domain of a protein sensor, rather than the other way around, proved to be a fruitful approach for improving cAMP indicator performance. This challenges conventional design paradigms.
  • High Affinity is Key for Low-Concentration Detection: The significantly increased affinity (Kd = 0.3 µM) of R-FlincA is the primary driver for its ability to detect subtle, sub-micromolar cAMP signals that were previously undetectable.
  • Expanded Dynamic Range Unlocks New Applications: The impressive 860% dynamic range allows R-FlincA to capture a wider spectrum of cAMP fluctuations, from basal levels to strong stimulations, making it more versatile.
  • Red Fluorescent Indicator Advantages: The red emission of R-FlincA is particularly valuable for multi-channel imaging, allowing it to be combined with blue and green fluorescent probes without significant spectral overlap, facilitating the study of complex signaling networks.
  • Combinatorial Imaging Power: R-FlincA's utility is amplified when used in conjunction with other indicators, enabling simultaneous monitoring of cAMP alongside other crucial messengers like Ca2+ and ATP, providing a more holistic view of cellular responses.

Key Results

  • R-FlincA Development: A novel red fluorescent cAMP indicator, R-FlincA, was successfully engineered.
  • Increased Affinity: R-FlincA exhibits a high affinity for cAMP with a Kd of 0.3 µM (at pH 7.2), approximately 11-fold higher than Flamindo2 (Kd = 3.2 µM).
  • Expanded Dynamic Range: The indicator demonstrates a dynamic range of 860% at pH 7.2, significantly exceeding existing indicators.
  • Enhanced Sensitivity: In D. discoideum cells, R-FlincA could detect faint, spontaneous cAMP pulses that were invisible to the Flamindo2 indicator. At higher stimulation levels, R-FlincA showed a 4-fold larger signal change compared to Flamindo2.
  • Improved Brightness: In-cell brightness of R-FlincA was found to be 3.5-fold higher than Pink-FL upon FSK stimulation.
  • Multi-channel Imaging Success: R-FlincA was successfully used in triple-function imaging (cAMP, Ca2+, ATP) in MIN6 pancreatic beta cells, revealing heterogeneous activation patterns of these second messengers.
  • Environmental cAMP Imaging: The indicator was also used to simultaneously monitor intracellular and extracellular cAMP dynamics in D. discoideum populations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • pH Sensitivity: Like other mApple-based indicators, R-FlincA exhibits pH sensitivity. While its dynamic range is still substantial within a physiologically relevant pH range (pH 5.5–7.5), users need to be mindful of this and consider parallel control experiments.
  • Molecular Brightness: While in-cell brightness is improved, the absolute molecular brightness of R-FlincA is noted as being lower than some other fluorescent proteins (e.g., ~1/4 of mCherry). This might limit applications requiring imaging in very small subcellular compartments like dendritic spines or cilia.
  • cGMP Interference: Although R-FlincA shows good selectivity for cAMP over cGMP, at high cGMP concentrations (~7 µM), it can partially bind cGMP, leading to reduced brightness. This needs consideration when studying systems with significant cGMP fluctuations.

The authors suggest that R-FlincA is a promising tool for accelerating cAMP research. Future work could focus on further improving molecular brightness and exploring its application in vivo, where its red fluorescence and improved signal-to-noise ratio could be advantageous. The potential for combinatorial imaging with photo-manipulation is also highlighted as a key avenue for future exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

cAMP is one of the most important second messengers in biological processes. Cellular dynamics of cAMP have been investigated using a series of fluorescent indicators; however, their sensitivity was sub-optimal for detecting cAMP dynamics at a low concentration range, due to a low ligand affinity and/or poor dynamic range. Seeking an indicator with improved detection sensitivity, we performed insertion screening of circularly permuted mApple, a red fluorescent protein, into the cAMP-binding motif of PKA regulatory subunit Iα and developed an improved cAMP indicator named R-FlincA (Red Fluorescent indicator for cAMP). Its increased affinity (K<sub>d</sub> = 0.3 μM) and expanded dynamic range (860% at pH 7.2) allowed the detection of subtle changes in the cellular cAMP dynamics at sub-μM concentrations, which could not be easily observed with existing indicators. Increased detection sensitivity also strengthened the advantages of using R-FlincA as a red fluorescent indicator, as it permits a series of applications, including multi-channel/function imaging of multiple second messengers and combinatorial imaging with photo-manipulation. These results strongly suggest that R-FlincA is a promising tool that accelerates cAMP research by revealing unobserved cAMP dynamics at a low concentration range.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ohta2018red,
  author = {Yusaku Ohta and Toshiaki Furuta and Takeharu Nagai and Kazuki Horikawa},
  title = {{Red fluorescent cAMP indicator with increased affinity and expanded dynamic range}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-20251-1},
}
Figure