Recurrent copy number alterations in young women with breast cancer

Chen Chi, Leigh C. Murphy, Pingzhao HuOncotarget 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies specific recurrent copy number alterations (CNAs) in young women with breast cancer, finding 38 such regions encompassing 39 genes. These CNAs are linked to patient survival, with mutations in ASB13 and SGCZ showing a particularly poor prognosis, suggesting potential for genomic-guided treatment strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Breast cancer in young women is a distinct clinical entity, often presenting with more aggressive tumors and a higher risk of recurrence and death compared to older women. While clinical differences are noted, the underlying molecular mechanisms driving this aggressive behavior in younger patients remain less understood. Specifically, the role of somatic genetic alterations, such as copy number alterations (CNAs), in the pathogenesis and prognosis of breast cancer in this age group needs further investigation. Identifying these specific genomic changes could lead to better risk assessment and personalized treatment approaches.

Methods

The researchers employed a novel interval graph-based algorithm to identify recurrent CNAs. This algorithm represents individual patient CNAs as vertices in a graph, connecting them if their genomic intervals overlap. Maximal cliques within this graph then represent regions of CNA that are shared across multiple patients, indicating recurrent alterations. They applied this algorithm to two large datasets (Discovery and Validation) of young women with breast cancer. Following the identification of recurrent CNAs, they performed gene annotation to identify genes located within these regions. Further analyses included logistic regression to assess the association between CNA status and gene expression (eQTL analysis) and Cox proportional hazard models to evaluate the link between gene expression and disease-specific survival. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was used to assess the impact of specific gene mutations on survival outcomes.

Datasets

The study utilized two datasets from the Molecular Taxonomy of Breast Cancer International Consortium (METABRIC):

  • Discovery Set: 130 young women with breast cancer.
  • Validation Set: 125 young women with breast cancer.

These datasets provided comprehensive clinical features, whole gene expression profiles, SNP data, and somatic DNA copy-number profiling data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Young Women's Breast Cancer Has Unique Genomic Signatures: The study successfully identified recurrent CNAs specifically in young women, suggesting that this demographic may have distinct genetic drivers for their disease.
  • CNAs are More Than Just Background Noise: The research highlights that these genomic alterations are not random but are significantly associated with patient outcomes, particularly survival.
  • Specific Genes as Prognostic Markers: The identification of ASB13 and SGCZ as genes whose mutation status strongly correlates with survival is a crucial finding. The observation that combined mutations in both genes lead to a worse outcome is particularly striking.
  • Gene Expression Links CNA to Survival: The study demonstrates that CNA status can influence gene expression levels, and these expression changes, in turn, can predict survival. This provides a mechanistic link between genomic alterations and clinical outcomes.
  • Potential for Targeted Therapies: By pinpointing specific CNAs and genes associated with poor prognosis, the research lays the groundwork for developing targeted therapies or diagnostic tools for this patient group.

Key Results

  • 38 validated recurrent CNAs were identified, encompassing 39 protein-encoding genes.
  • CAPN2, CDC73, and ASB13 were the most frequent CNA gain regions.
  • SGCZ was the most frequent CNA loss region.
  • 9 out of 39 genes showed significant associations between their mutation status and breast cancer-specific survival.
  • The expression levels of ASB13 and SGCZ were significantly associated with survival outcome.
  • Patients with CNA mutations in both ASB13 and SGCZ had a worse survival outcome compared to those without these mutations.
  • Mutated CNA status in ASB13 was associated with higher gene expression, which predicted poorer survival.
  • PTEN loss was associated with significantly shorter median survival time (~4 years) compared to patients without this loss (~15 years).
  • SGCZ loss was associated with a significantly shorter median survival time (~6 years) compared to patients without this loss (~15 years).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Non-coding Regions: The study acknowledges that a significant portion of identified CNAs are in non-coding regions (76%) and suggests that further characterization of these regions and their role in regulating gene expression (in cis or trans) is warranted.
  • Sample Size for Specific Genes: While the study identified significant associations for several genes, the sample sizes for some specific gene analyses (e.g., NFIL3, JAK2) were relatively small, which could limit the generalizability of those specific findings.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose that their findings could facilitate the development of screening methods for breast cancer biomarker discovery, especially in young women, and contribute to a more accurate human cancer genome sequence reference. They also emphasize the need to further characterize non-coding CNA regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Breast cancer diagnosis in young women has emerged as an independent prognostic factor with higher recurrence risk and death than their older counterparts. We aim to find recurrent somatic copy number alteration (CNA) regions identified from breast cancer microarray data and associate the CNA status of the genes harbored in the regions to the survival of young women with breast cancer. By using the interval graph-based algorithm we developed, and the CNA data consisting of a Discovery set with 130 young women and a Validation set with 125 young women, we identified 38 validated recurrent CNAs containing 39 protein encoding genes. CNA gain regions encompassing genes <i>CAPN2</i>, <i>CDC73</i> and <i>ASB13</i> are the top 3 with the highest occurring frequencies in both the Discovery and Validation dataset, while gene <i>SGCZ</i> ranked top for the recurrent CNA loss regions. The mutation status of 9 of the 39 genes shows significant associations with breast cancer specific survival. Interestingly, the expression level of 2 of the 9 genes, <i>ASB13</i> and <i>SGCZ</i>, shows significant association with survival outcome. Patients with CNA mutations in both of these genes had a worse survival outcome when compared to patients without the gene mutations. The mutated CNA status in gene <i>ASB13</i> was associated with a higher gene expression, which predicted patient survival outcome. Together, identification of the CNA events with prognostic significance in young women with breast cancer may be used in genomic-guided treatment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chi2018recurrent,
  author = {Chen Chi and Leigh C. Murphy and Pingzhao Hu},
  title = {{Recurrent copy number alterations in young women with breast cancer}},
  booktitle = {Oncotarget},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.18632/oncotarget.24336},
}
Figure