TL;DR
This study investigated the feasibility of recruiting patients hospitalized with a Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) exacerbation into a digital self-management study. The findings indicate that recruiting patients in this acute phase is challenging, with a low recruitment rate and a high dropout rate, suggesting the hospital setting during an exacerbation is not ideal for initiating such interventions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Patients with COPD frequently experience acute exacerbations, leading to hospitalizations and high readmission rates, which incur significant healthcare costs. The authors previously demonstrated the effectiveness of a digital self-management support tool in the community. They hypothesized that intervening with patients during hospitalization for an exacerbation might be an optimal time to offer this support, potentially preventing future readmissions. However, the challenge lies in the feasibility of recruiting these acutely ill patients into such studies and understanding their adherence and dropout rates in this context.
Methods
The study recruited patients aged 40 or older with a diagnosis of COPD who were hospitalized for an acute exacerbation. Participants were provided with a tablet computer loaded with the EDGE mHealth application, a Bluetooth-linked pulse oximeter, and a wrist-worn physical activity monitor. The intervention aimed to support self-management by enabling monitoring of vital signs, COPD symptoms, mood, and physical activity, alongside access to educational resources. Recruitment was conducted by the clinical research team, who identified potential participants through clinical teams. Data on recruitment, screening, eligibility, and reasons for non-participation or withdrawal were systematically recorded.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Timing is Crucial: The acute hospital setting during a COPD exacerbation appears to be a suboptimal environment for initiating digital self-management interventions. The burden of illness and coping with acute symptoms significantly impacts patients' capacity to engage with new technologies.
- Recruitment Challenges: A substantial number of patients needed to be screened to recruit a relatively small sample, highlighting significant barriers to recruitment in this population and setting.
- High Attrition: The study observed a high rate of participant withdrawal, particularly within the first four weeks post-discharge, suggesting that even after leaving the hospital, the demands of self-management combined with recovery from illness are challenging.
- Intervention vs. Implementation: The authors suggest that the intervention itself (EDGE tool) is likely robust, as demonstrated in previous community-based studies. Therefore, the observed difficulties are more likely attributable to the implementation process and the timing of introduction rather than limitations of the digital tool itself.
Key Results
- 281 patients were identified, and 126 were approached.
- 26 patients (37.1% of those approached) were recruited.
- 14 out of 26 recruited participants (53.8%) withdrew from the study.
- 11 out of these 14 withdrawing participants (78.6%) withdrew within four weeks of discharge.
- The main reasons for ineligibility were patients lacking capacity (50.9%) and for non-participation, it was "too much going on" (52.3%).
- Withdrawal reasons included not wanting to use the support tool, feeling unwell, or finding it too much to manage alongside other life demands.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that recruiting patients with COPD during hospitalization for an acute exacerbation is challenging, with a low recruitment rate and high dropout. They suggest that future interventions should carefully consider the timing of introduction, balancing the benefits of early support with the patient's acute illness burden. It is possible that interventions focusing on non-intrusive monitoring by healthcare staff might be more acceptable in this setting, whereas those requiring active patient engagement in self-measurement or learning might be better introduced once the patient has recovered from the acute phase. Further research could explore alternative recruitment strategies or different points in the patient pathway for intervention delivery.
Summary updated