Recovering the Free-Field Acoustic Characteristics of a Vibrating Structure from Bounded Noisy Underwater Environments

Wei Lin, Sheng Li2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to accurately determine the free-field acoustic characteristics of a vibrating structure submerged in a noisy underwater environment. By combining the Boundary Element Method (BEM) with a vibro-acoustic coupling approach, the method effectively separates the structure's intrinsic radiation from the ambient noise and boundary reflections, a crucial step for accurate target identification and control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Characterizing the intrinsic acoustic properties of a structure is vital for applications like target identification and control. Ideally, this is done in a "free field" – an environment free from reflections and external noise. However, achieving a true free field, especially underwater, is practically impossible. Underwater environments are inherently noisy due to ambient noise and reflections from boundaries. These disturbances significantly alter the structure's vibration and the sound it radiates, making it difficult to isolate its true free-field acoustic signature. Existing "free-field recovery" (FFR) techniques often fail to account for the strong fluid-structure interaction in water, which means the structure's vibration in a noisy environment differs from its vibration in a free field. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that can recover the free-field acoustic characteristics even in the presence of these complex underwater disturbances.

Methods

The core of the proposed method lies in a sophisticated approach to separate different acoustic components. It begins by measuring the total sound pressure on a surface surrounding the structure. This total pressure is then decomposed into three parts:

  1. Incoming Sound Pressure ($p^i(r)$): This represents the noise and reflections from the environment.
  2. Rigid Body Scattered Sound Pressure ($p^{sr}(r)$): This is the sound scattered by the structure as if it were infinitely rigid.
  3. Elastically Radiated Sound Pressure ($p^{se}(r)$): This is the sound radiated due to the structure's elastic vibration, which is influenced by the incoming sound field.

The method uses the Boundary Element Method (BEM) to calculate the incoming and rigid body scattered sound fields. A key innovation is the integration of a vibro-acoustic coupling method (specifically, combining BEM with Finite Element Method - FEM) to accurately calculate the elastically radiated sound pressure. This coupling is crucial because, unlike in air, the fluid-structure interaction in water is strong and cannot be ignored. By solving this coupled problem, the method accounts for how the surrounding water affects the structure's vibration and subsequent sound radiation.

Finally, the free-field sound pressure ($p^f(r)$) is recovered by subtracting the incoming and rigid body scattered components from the total measured sound pressure. The paper emphasizes that the goal is to recover the sound field radiated by the structure, not necessarily its surface vibration, thus avoiding the need for near-field acoustic holography (NAH).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations rather than experimental data from specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fluid-Structure Interaction is Paramount Underwater: The paper strongly highlights that the significant interaction between a vibrating structure and water fundamentally changes the structure's vibrational behavior compared to a free field. This difference is much more pronounced than in air.
  • Beyond Simple Noise Cancellation: Traditional FFR methods often focus on removing ambient noise. This paper's novelty lies in its ability to account for how that noise also influences the structure's vibration itself, which then affects its radiated sound.
  • Decomposition is Key: The successful recovery hinges on a robust decomposition of the total sound field into its constituent parts: incoming noise, rigid-body scattering, and elastic radiation.
  • Vibro-Acoustic Coupling for Accurate Elastic Radiation: The integration of vibro-acoustic coupling is essential for accurately modeling the elastically radiated sound, especially in water where this component is significant.
  • Robustness to Noise: The proposed method demonstrates good robustness, accurately recovering free-field characteristics even with significant noise (low SNR).

Key Results

  • Successful Free-Field Recovery: Numerical simulations show that the proposed method can accurately recover the free-field acoustic characteristics of a vibrating structure in a bounded noisy underwater environment.
  • Distinction Between V1 and V2 Fields: The study clearly shows that the "V1 free sound field" (structure vibrating solely due to external force) and the "V2 free sound field" (structure vibrating in a noisy environment) are significantly different in water due to fluid-structure interaction.
  • Superiority over Conventional Methods: The proposed method significantly outperforms conventional double-layer BEM in recovering the V1 free sound field in noisy underwater conditions. While conventional methods can recover the V2 field, they struggle to isolate the true V1 field when fluid-structure interaction is strong.
  • Low Errors: Mean quadratic errors for the proposed method's recovered sound field are significantly lower (e.g., less than 40% for V1 free sound field in water) compared to total sound fields (over 100%).
  • Robustness Demonstrated: Relative errors in recovered sound pressure remain low (under 11%) even for signal-to-noise ratios as low as -29.5 dB.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Known Structural Properties: The current method requires the structural properties (mass, damping, stiffness) to be known in advance.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest incorporating methods that can construct structural impedance from pressure measurements to overcome the need for pre-known properties. This would further reduce the reliance on prior information and potentially simplify the process. They also mention future work on reducing calculation complexity.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{lin2021recovering,
  author = {Wei Lin and Sheng Li},
  title = {{Recovering the Free-Field Acoustic Characteristics of a Vibrating Structure from Bounded Noisy Underwater Environments}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21165521},
}

Loading related content...

Figure