Reconstruction of interactions in the ProtoDUNE-SP detector with Pandora

A. Abed Abud, B. Abi, R. Acciarri, M. A. Acero, M. R. Adames, G. Adamov, Mark Adamowski, D. L. Adams, M. Adinolfi, C. Adriano, Antoni Aduszkiewicz, J. Aguilar, Zahid Ahmad, J. Ahmed, B. Aimard, F. Akbar, B. Ali-Mohammadzadeh, K. K. Allison, S. Alonso Monsalve, M. Alrashed, C. Alt, T. Alexander, R. Alvarez, P. Amedo, John Anderson, C. Andreopoulos, M. Andreotti, M.p. Andrews, F. Andrianala, S. Andringa, Н. Анфимов, Artur M. Ankowski, M. Antoniassi, M. Antonova, A. Antoshkin, Stefan Antusch, Alfredo Aranda, L. Arellano, L. O. Arnold, M. A. Arroyave, J. Asaadi, L. Asquith, A. Aurisano, V. Aushev, D. Autiero, V. Ayala Lara, M. Ayala-Torres, F. Azfar, H.o. Back, J. J. Back, C. Backhouse, I. Bagaturia, L. Bagby, N. Balashov, S. Balasubramanian, Pierre Baldi, B. Baller, B. Bambah, F. Barão, Gabriela Barenboim, Gareth J. Barker, Wayne Barkhouse, C. Barnes, G. Barr, J. Barranco Monarca, A. L. F. de Barros, N. Barros, J. Barrow, A. Basharina-Freshville, A. Bashyal, V. Basque, C. Batchelor, James Battat, Francesca De Battisti, F. Bay, M. C. Q. Bazetto, J. L. Bazo Alba, J. F. Beacom, E. Bechetoille, B. Behera, E. Belchior Batista Das Chagas, L. Bellantoni, G. Bellettini, Vincenzo Bellini, O. Beltramello, N. Benekos, C. Benitez Montiel, F. Neves, J. Berger, S. Berkman, P. Bernardini, R. M. Berner, A. Bersani, S. Bertolucci, M. Betancourt, A. Betancur Rodríguez, A. J. Bevan, Y. Bezawada, Anibal BezerraThe European Physical Journal C 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details how the Pandora software framework was adapted to reconstruct particle interactions in the ProtoDUNE-SP liquid argon time projection chamber. It highlights the challenges of complex events with background noise and demonstrates that Pandora achieves high reconstruction and identification efficiencies for test-beam particles, crucial for future neutrino experiments like DUNE.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reconstructing particle interactions in large liquid argon time projection chambers (LArTPCs) like ProtoDUNE-SP is a significant challenge. These detectors are exposed to a high flux of cosmic rays and other background particles, making it difficult to isolate and accurately reconstruct the desired neutrino or test-beam particle signals. For future neutrino experiments such as DUNE, precise reconstruction of particle trajectories and interactions is essential for accurate measurements of fundamental physics processes, like neutrino cross-sections. This paper addresses the need for a robust and efficient reconstruction software that can handle the complexity of these detectors and their data.

Methods

The core of the paper focuses on the Pandora Software Development Kit (SDK) and its application to ProtoDUNE-SP. Pandora employs a multi-algorithm, pattern-recognition approach to reconstruct particle events. Key aspects of their method include:

  • Hierarchical Reconstruction: Pandora builds a hierarchy of reconstructed particles, starting from individual hits and progressively grouping them into clusters, then particles, and finally complex interaction hierarchies.
  • Multi-View Reconstruction: It utilizes three 2D views (u, v, w wire planes) from the LArTPC to reconstruct particle trajectories in 3D.
  • Algorithm Chains: Two main algorithm chains were developed and adapted:
  • PandoraCosmic: Optimized for reconstructing cosmic-ray muons, which are abundant and can traverse the detector. This chain includes a "stitching" algorithm to handle ambiguities arising from multiple drift volumes and space charge effects.
  • PandoraTestBeam: Specifically designed for reconstructing test-beam particles, focusing on identifying interaction vertices and the resulting particle showers.
  • Consolidated Reconstruction: A novel approach that combines the outputs of PandoraCosmic and PandoraTestBeam, using a machine learning classifier (BDT) to select the most appropriate reconstruction for each event slice.
  • Space Charge Effect (SCE) Mitigation: The reconstruction accounts for distortions caused by the accumulation of positive ions from cosmic-ray muons, which can affect electric fields and particle trajectories.

Datasets

  • Simulated Data:
    • GEANT4 simulations of the beamline and particle interactions.
  • CORSIKA simulations for cosmic rays.
  • Data-driven simulation of space charge effects.
  • Specialized simulation samples to study systematic uncertainties:
  • SCE-off sample (no space charge simulation).
  • Reduced beam halo sample (15% reduction).
  • Experimental Data:
    • Data collected from the ProtoDUNE-SP detector at CERN during August-December 2018, using a charged particle test beam.
  • Data was collected at specific beam momenta: 1, 2, 3, 6, and 7 GeV/c.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pandora's Adaptability: The Pandora framework, originally developed for other experiments, proved highly adaptable to the unique challenges of LArTPCs like ProtoDUNE-SP, particularly its multi-drift-volume geometry.
  • The "Stitching" Algorithm: The ability to "stitch" reconstructed tracks across different drift volumes is crucial for accurately determining the timing of cosmic-ray muons and mitigating ambiguities.
  • Consolidated Reconstruction for Clarity: Combining outputs from specialized chains (Cosmic vs. Test-Beam) via a BDT is an effective strategy to achieve a clear and unambiguous event reconstruction, especially in complex scenarios.
  • Space Charge is a Real Factor: The paper emphasizes the impact of space charge effects on reconstruction accuracy and details how their reconstruction accounts for these distortions.
  • Simulation vs. Data Agreement: The close agreement between simulated and experimental data efficiencies (within 5%) validates both the simulation's accuracy and Pandora's performance.

Key Results

  • High Reconstruction Efficiency: Simulated reconstruction and identification efficiency for triggered test-beam particles exceeds 80% for most particle types and momenta.
  • Specific Efficiencies:
    • 1 GeV/c charged pions: 86.1 ± 0.6%
    • 1 GeV/c protons: 84.1 ± 0.6%
  • Cosmic Ray Tagging: Approximately 62.4% of cosmic-ray muon candidates were successfully tagged using the defined criteria.
  • Test-Beam Data Agreement: Measured efficiencies for test-beam data are within 5% of simulated predictions.
  • Position Resolution: For 1 GeV/c particles, the 3D end-point position was reconstructed within 2 cm of the true value for 68% of events.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper notes that it's not trivial to extrapolate ProtoDUNE-SP performance to the DUNE far detector due to ProtoDUNE-SP's higher detector occupancy.
  • Some discrepancies between data and simulation are observed, potentially due to:
  • Underestimation of space charge effects in simulation.
  • Differences in the ratio of muons to pions between data and simulation.
  • The presence of a malfunctioning electron diverter affecting beam particle tracks.
  • The analysis of charged kaons and muons was limited due to data collection constraints.
  • Future Work:
    • Development of new algorithms and incorporation of deep-learning techniques for improved vertex finding, event slicing, and hit classification.
  • These advancements will be tested on ProtoDUNE-SP simulation and data, and will be crucial for the DUNE far detector.
  • A similar upgraded detector, ProtoDUNE-HD, is under construction and will provide further testing grounds.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The Pandora Software Development Kit and algorithm libraries provide pattern-recognition logic essential to the reconstruction of particle interactions in liquid argon time projection chamber detectors. Pandora is the primary event reconstruction software used at ProtoDUNE-SP, a prototype for the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment far detector. ProtoDUNE-SP, located at CERN, is exposed to a charged-particle test beam. This paper gives an overview of the Pandora reconstruction algorithms and how they have been tailored for use at ProtoDUNE-SP. In complex events with numerous cosmic-ray and beam background particles, the simulated reconstruction and identification efficiency for triggered test-beam particles is above 80% for the majority of particle type and beam momentum combinations. Specifically, simulated 1 GeV/ c charged pions and protons are correctly reconstructed and identified with efficiencies of 86.1 $$\pm 0.6$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:mrow> <mml:mo>±</mml:mo> <mml:mn>0.6</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> </mml:math> % and 84.1 $$\pm 0.6$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:mrow> <mml:mo>±</mml:mo> <mml:mn>0.6</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> </mml:math> %, respectively. The efficiencies measured for test-beam data are shown to be within 5% of those predicted by the simulation.
BibTeX
@article{abud2023reconstruction,
  author = {A. Abed Abud and B. Abi and R. Acciarri and M. A. Acero and M. R. Adames and G. Adamov and Mark Adamowski and D. L. Adams and M. Adinolfi and C. Adriano and Antoni Aduszkiewicz and J. Aguilar and Zahid Ahmad and J. Ahmed and B. Aimard and F. Akbar and B. Ali-Mohammadzadeh and K. K. Allison and S. Alonso Monsalve and M. Alrashed and C. Alt and T. Alexander and R. Alvarez and P. Amedo and John Anderson and C. Andreopoulos and M. Andreotti and M.P. Andrews and F. Andrianala and S. Andringa and Н. Анфимов and Artur M. Ankowski and M. Antoniassi and M. Antonova and A. Antoshkin and Stefan Antusch and Alfredo Aranda and L. Arellano and L. O. Arnold and M. A. Arroyave and J. Asaadi and L. Asquith and A. Aurisano and V. Aushev and D. Autiero and V. Ayala Lara and M. Ayala-Torres and F. Azfar and H.O. Back and H.O. Back and J. J. Back and C. Backhouse and I. Bagaturia and L. Bagby and N. Balashov and S. Balasubramanian and Pierre Baldi and B. Baller and B. Bambah and F. Barão and Gabriela Barenboim and Gareth J. Barker and Wayne Barkhouse and C. Barnes and G. Barr and J. Barranco Monarca and A. L. F. de Barros and N. Barros and J. Barrow and A. Basharina-Freshville and A. Bashyal and V. Basque and C. Batchelor and James Battat and Francesca De Battisti and F. Bay and M. C. Q. Bazetto and J. L. Bazo Alba and J. F. Beacom and E. Bechetoille and B. Behera and E. Belchior Batista Das Chagas and L. Bellantoni and G. Bellettini and Vincenzo Bellini and O. Beltramello and N. Benekos and C. Benitez Montiel and F. Neves and J. Berger and S. Berkman and P. Bernardini and R. M. Berner and A. Bersani and S. Bertolucci and M. Betancourt and A. Betancur Rodríguez and A. J. Bevan and Y. Bezawada and Anibal Bezerra},
  title = {{Reconstruction of interactions in the ProtoDUNE-SP detector with Pandora}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-023-11733-2},
}
Figure