Reconstructing the regulatory programs underlying the phenotypic plasticity of neural cancers

Sven Nelander, Ida Larsson, Felix Held, Gergana Popova, Alper Koç, Soumi Kundu, Rebecka JörnstenResearch Square 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

The authors introduce scRegClust, a fast and flexible algorithm that reconstructs gene regulatory programs from single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) data. By simultaneously clustering genes and identifying their regulators (including both transcription factors and kinases), the tool uncovered specific genetic targets that, when inhibited, make brain cancer cells significantly more vulnerable to standard chemotherapy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nervous system cancers like glioblastoma are notoriously difficult to treat because of phenotypic plasticity—the ability of tumor cells to shift between different "states" (e.g., mimicking stem cells, progenitor cells, or injury-response cells). These states allow tumors to evade treatment and drive recurrence.

While we can identify these states using scRNA-seq, we often don't know how they are controlled. Existing computational methods for building Gene Regulatory Networks (GRNs) are often computationally expensive, require multiple types of data (like ATAC-seq), or focus exclusively on transcription factors (TFs). This leaves out kinases, which are among the most "druggable" targets in medicine. The authors sought a method that could handle millions of cells quickly while identifying diverse classes of regulators.

Methods

The authors developed scRegClust (single-cell Regulatory-driven Clustering), which uses a two-step alternating optimization strategy:

  1. Regulatory Program Reconstruction (Step 1): Using a technique called cooperative-Lasso (coop-Lasso), the model identifies a sparse set of regulators (TFs or kinases) that predict the expression of a gene module. It enforces "sign-coherence," meaning a regulator must act consistently (either as an activator or a repressor) across the module.
  2. Target Gene Allocation (Step 2): Genes are reassigned to modules based on which regulatory program best explains their expression.

To make this computationally feasible for massive datasets, they employed the Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers (ADMM), an optimization framework that allows the algorithm to converge much faster than traditional methods.

Datasets

The study utilized an impressive array of data:

  • Benchmarking: Publicly available Peripheral Blood Mononuclear Cell (PBMC) data to compare against the gold-standard tool, SCENIC+.
  • Discovery & Validation: scRNA-seq from the U3065MG glioblastoma cell line.
  • Large-scale Integration: A massive collection of 13 datasets covering adult glioblastoma (GBM), childhood medulloblastoma (MB), neuroblastoma (NB), and healthy developing brain/adrenal tissues, totaling over 1 million cells.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regulatory-Driven Clustering > Correlation: The paper demonstrates that clustering genes based on their shared regulators is far more accurate than clustering them based on simple expression correlation, especially when module sizes are unequal.
  • Kinases as Regulators: Unlike many previous tools, scRegClust treats kinases as potential regulators. This allowed the authors to identify PDGFRA and DDR1 as key drivers of a therapy-resistant, OPC-like state in glioblastoma.
  • The "Meta-Module" Concept: By analyzing 13 datasets at once, they found "meta-modules"—regulatory programs that are conserved across different types of cancer and normal development. For example, they identified a mesenchymal-like state regulated by SPI1 and IRF8 that appears to be triggered by interactions with immune cells (microglia).
  • Priming for Sensitivity: The model suggested that the resistant "State 5" in glioblastoma is maintained by specific kinases. Depleting this state before giving chemotherapy could be a winning strategy.

Key Results

  • Speed: scRegClust was 3x faster than SCENIC+ while achieving comparable results using only scRNA-seq data (whereas SCENIC+ requires both RNA and ATAC-seq).
  • Experimental Validation: Using CRISPR/Cas9, the authors knocked down DDR1 and SOX6 in glioblastoma cells. As predicted, these cells became significantly more sensitive to Temozolomide (TMZ), the standard-of-care chemotherapy.
  • Drug Synergy: They found that pre-treating cells with Dasatinib (a tyrosine kinase inhibitor) for 72 hours "depleted" the resistant cell population, making the subsequent combination of Dasatinib and TMZ highly synergistic.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Modality: While the tool works excellently on scRNA-seq alone, the authors acknowledge that incorporating "prior knowledge" from other modalities (like ATAC-seq or ChIP-seq) could further refine the networks.
  • Linear Assumptions: The current model uses a sign-constrained linear model. Future versions could explore non-additive contributions (where two regulators work together in a non-linear way) or feedback loops.
  • Implementation: The tool is currently available as an R package, which is standard for bioinformatics but may require further optimization for integration into broader machine learning pipelines.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Nervous system cancers contain a large spectrum of transcriptional cell states, reflecting processes active during normal development, injury response and growth. However, we lack a good understanding of these states' regulation and pharmacological importance. Here, we describe the integrated reconstruction of such cellular regulatory programs and their therapeutic targets from extensive collections of single-cell RNA sequencing data (scRNA-seq) from both tumors and developing tissues. Our method, termed single-cell Regulatory-driven Clustering (<italic>scRegClust</italic>), splits target genes into modules and predicts essential kinases and transcription factors in little computational time thanks to a new efficient optimization strategy. Using this method, we analyze scRNA-seq data from both adult and childhood brain cancers to identify transcription factors and kinases that regulate distinct tumor cell states. In adult glioblastoma, our model predicts that blocking the activity of <italic>PDGFRA</italic>, <italic>DDR1</italic>, <italic>ERBB3 </italic>or <italic>SOX6</italic>, or increasing <italic>YBX1</italic>-activity, would potentiate temozolomide treatment. We further perform an integrative study of scRNA-seq data from both cancer and the developing brain to uncover the regulation of emerging meta-modules. We find a meta-module regulated by the transcription factors <italic>SPI1 </italic>and <italic>IRF8 </italic>and link it to an immune-mediated mesenchymal-like state. Our algorithm is available as an easy-to-use R package and companion visualization tool that help uncover the regulatory programs underlying cell plasticity in cancer and other diseases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nelander2024reconstructing,
  author = {Sven Nelander and Ida Larsson and Felix Held and Gergana Popova and Alper Koç and Soumi Kundu and Rebecka Jörnsten},
  title = {{Reconstructing the regulatory programs underlying the phenotypic plasticity of neural cancers}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3658321/v1},
}
Figure