Reconstructing Roma History from Genome-Wide Data

Priya Moorjani, Nick Patterson, Po‐Ru Loh, Mark Lipson, Péter Kisfali, Béla Melegh, Michael Bonin, Ľudevít Kádaši, Olaf Rieß, Bonnie Berger, David ReichPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract: The Roma people, living throughout Europe and West Asia, are a diverse population linked by the Romani language and culture. Previous linguistic and genetic studies have suggested that the Roma migrated into Europe from South Asia about 1,000-1,500 years ago. Genetic inferences about Roma history have mostly focused on the Y chromosome and mitochondrial DNA. To explore what additional information can be learned from genome-wide data, we analyzed data from six Roma groups that we genotyped at hundreds of thousands of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). We estimate that the Roma harbor about 80% West Eurasian ancestry—derived from a combination of European and South Asian sources—and that the date of admixture of South Asian and European ancestry was about 850 years before present. We provide evidence for Eastern Europe being a major source of European ancestry, and North-west India being a major source of the South Asian ancestry in the Roma. By computing allele sharing as a measure of linkage disequilibrium, we estimate that the migration of Roma out of the Indian subcontinent was accompanied by a severe founder event, which appears to have been followed by a major demographic expansion after the arrival in Europe.

Introduction

The Roma (or Romani) people constitute a diverse population of 10–15 million across Europe and the Americas. Lacking a written history or unified genealogy, their origins have long been a subject of debate among linguists and historians. While previous genetic studies suggested a South Asian origin, they primarily focused on uniparental markers—the Y chromosome and mitochondrial DNA—which only represent a single lineage of an individual's ancestry. This study addresses the need for a whole-genome perspective to understand the complex admixture, timing of migrations, and demographic shifts that uniparental markers cannot fully capture.

Methods and Datasets

The research team analyzed autosomal Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) data from 27 Roma samples across six groups (Hungary, Romania, Spain, and Slovakia), genotyped at approximately 726,000 SNPs. These were compared against global reference sets including HapMap Phase 3, the Human Genome Diversity Panel (HGDP), and specialized datasets from the "India Project" and POPRES to pinpoint regional sources.

To analyze this data, the team employed several statistical tools:

  • PCA and ADMIXTURE: Clustering techniques to visualize global relationships.
  • $F_4$ Ratio Estimation: Quantifying ancestry proportions from divergent source populations.
  • Modified ROLLOFF: Estimating the date of admixture by analyzing the decay of Linkage Disequilibrium (LD), specifically adapted to account for biases caused by population bottlenecks.
  • Identity-by-Descent (IBD) Sharing: Measuring long shared DNA segments to identify specific regional sources in India and Europe.

Key Insights and Ideas

Principal Components and ADMIXTURE analysis showing the global genetic positioning of Roma populations relative to African, European, East Asian, and South Asian groups.

Analysis reveals that Roma fall on the same genetic "cline" as mainland Indians—a mix of Ancestral North Indian and Ancestral South Indian—but are shifted significantly toward the European cluster. Their ~80% "West Eurasian" ancestry is a composite: part originates from the initial "Ancestral North Indian" (ANI) source, while the remainder comes from gene flow after leaving India, primarily from Eastern European populations.

Furthermore, the Roma show exceptionally high levels of autozygosity (long stretches of identical DNA inherited from both parents). This indicates a severe population bottleneck, or "founder event," during their migration, where a small number of ancestors gave rise to the current population.

Key Results

Detailed ADMIXTURE analysis comparing Roma individuals to European (CEU) and diverse South Asian populations, illustrating the specific ancestry components.
  • Ancestry Proportions: Roma possess approximately 77.5% ± 1.8% West Eurasian-related ancestry.
  • Admixture Date: Admixture between South Asian and European sources occurred roughly 29 ± 2 generations ago (approx. 800–900 years before present). This aligns with historical records of the Roma's arrival in the Balkans during the 11th–12th century.
  • Geographic Sources: The highest IBD sharing was found with groups from Northwest India (e.g., Punjabi and Kashmiri Pandit). The primary source of European gene flow was identified as Eastern Europe, even for Roma currently residing in Spain.
  • Demographics: The migration out of India was accompanied by a severe founder event roughly 27 generations ago, followed by a major demographic expansion upon reaching Europe.

Discussion and Limitations

While the study provides a high-resolution map of Roma history, the authors acknowledge that the sample size (27) may limit the detection of subtle differences between sub-ethnic groups. Additionally, while a primary admixture pulse ~850 years ago is evident, a "two-pulse" model also fits the data, suggesting ongoing lower-level gene flow.

Beyond historical reconstruction, the high levels of autozygosity identified suggest that homozygosity mapping could be a powerful tool for future research into recessive disease-causing mutations prevalent in Roma populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Roma people, living throughout Europe and West Asia, are a diverse population linked by the Romani language and culture. Previous linguistic and genetic studies have suggested that the Roma migrated into Europe from South Asia about 1,000-1,500 years ago. Genetic inferences about Roma history have mostly focused on the Y chromosome and mitochondrial DNA. To explore what additional information can be learned from genome-wide data, we analyzed data from six Roma groups that we genotyped at hundreds of thousands of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). We estimate that the Roma harbor about 80% West Eurasian ancestry-derived from a combination of European and South Asian sources-and that the date of admixture of South Asian and European ancestry was about 850 years before present. We provide evidence for Eastern Europe being a major source of European ancestry, and North-west India being a major source of the South Asian ancestry in the Roma. By computing allele sharing as a measure of linkage disequilibrium, we estimate that the migration of Roma out of the Indian subcontinent was accompanied by a severe founder event, which appears to have been followed by a major demographic expansion after the arrival in Europe.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{moorjani2013reconstructing,
  author = {Priya Moorjani and Nick Patterson and Po‐Ru Loh and Mark Lipson and Péter Kisfali and Béla Melegh and Michael Bonin and Ľudevít Kádaši and Olaf Rieß and Bonnie Berger and David Reich and Béla Melegh and Béla Melegh and Béla Melegh},
  title = {{Reconstructing Roma History from Genome-Wide Data}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0058633},
}
Figure