Reconstructing a Flavodoxin Oxidoreductase with Early Amino Acids

Mingfeng Lu, Hong‐Fang Ji, Tingxuan Li, Shou‐Kai Kang, Yuejie Zhang, Juefei Zheng, Tian Tian, Xi-Shuai Jia, Xing-Ming Lin, Hongyu ZhangInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reconstructs a primitive flavodoxin using only "early" amino acids, demonstrating that such a protein can still perform essential electron transfer activity. This work provides experimental evidence for the hypothesis that early life relied on organic cofactors and simple protein structures for vital redox reactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The origin of life is a fundamental question in biology, and a key aspect is understanding how early life forms performed essential biochemical processes like electron transfer. Oxidoreductases, enzymes crucial for these processes, typically rely on cofactors (like FMN) and specific amino acids for their function. While it's hypothesized that primitive proteins used organic cofactors more than metal ions and were built from a limited set of "early" amino acids (those readily synthesized in early Earth conditions), this idea has lacked direct experimental validation. Specifically, the question of whether a protein composed solely of these early amino acids, along with an organic cofactor, could actually perform electron transfer activity remained unanswered.

Methods

The researchers employed a rational design approach to create a modified flavodoxin. They started with the known structure of Megasphaera elsdenii flavodoxin. Then, they systematically replaced "late" amino acids (those not easily synthesized in early Earth simulations like Miller's spark discharge experiments: C, F, M, T, W, Y) with "early" amino acids (A, L, V) at specific positions identified as important for cofactor binding. This involved using molecular modeling software (InsightII) for the design.

Following the design, the gene for this mutant flavodoxin was synthesized and expressed in Escherichia coli. The protein was then purified using standard techniques like SDS-PAGE, Western blotting, and affinity chromatography.

To evaluate the functional and structural properties of the reconstructed protein, several spectroscopic techniques were used:

  • Far-UV Circular Dichroism (CD) spectroscopy: To assess the secondary structure and stability of the protein, particularly its response to urea denaturation.
  • UV-Visible Spectroscopy: To examine the electronic properties of the flavodoxin, especially its reduced forms.
  • Fluorescence Spectroscopy: Using a probe (bis-ANS) to investigate the hydrophobic environment and protein folding.
  • Anaerobic Titration: To determine the redox potentials of the mutant flavodoxin.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing protein structure databases (PDB code: 2FZ5 for Megasphaera elsdenii flavodoxin) and standard biochemical reagents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Early" Amino Acids Can Support Redox Activity: The most significant finding is that a protein constructed exclusively from early amino acids can still bind an organic cofactor (FMN) and effectively carry out electron transfer. This directly supports the hypothesis about the nature of primitive redox proteins.
  • Structural Similarity Despite Amino Acid Substitution: The mutant flavodoxin retained a 3D structure largely similar to the wild-type, indicating that replacing late amino acids with early ones doesn't necessarily lead to complete structural collapse.
  • Compromised Stability: While structurally similar, the mutant flavodoxin showed lower stability, particularly in its semiquinone and hydroquinone forms, compared to the wild-type. This suggests that the "late" amino acids might play a role in fine-tuning the stability of different redox states.
  • Redox Potential Shift: The double electron reduction potential (Em,7(fld)) of the mutant was significantly more negative (-360 mV) than the wild-type (-244 mV). This indicates a different electron transfer capability, potentially adapted for different early metabolic conditions.
  • Weakened Cofactor Binding: The binding affinity of the mutant for FMN was weaker than the wild-type, likely due to the absence of aromatic amino acids that are crucial for stabilizing the FMN-binding site in native flavodoxins.

Key Results

  • The reconstructed flavodoxin mutant exhibited structural characteristics similar to the wild-type protein.
  • The mutant's semiquinone and hydroquinone forms were less stable than those of the wild-type.
  • The double electron reduction potential (Em,7(fld)) of the mutant flavodoxin reached -360 mV, demonstrating effective electron transfer activity.
  • The dissociation constant (Kdox) for the oxidized FMN-binding was 2.92 µM, and for the hydroquinone form (Kd,hq) was 43.604 mM, indicating weaker binding compared to the wild-type.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Stability: The reduced stability of the semiquinone and hydroquinone forms is a limitation, suggesting that while functional, the mutant might not have been as robust as later evolved proteins.
  • Cofactor Binding Affinity: The weaker binding of FMN highlights the trade-offs in using only early amino acids and suggests that the evolution of more stable and efficient proteins involved incorporating later amino acids.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further studies could explore the role of specific "early" amino acids in more detail and investigate how the incorporation of "late" amino acids contributed to the evolution of more complex and stable redox proteins. The findings also provide hints for designing novel redox proteins with specific functionalities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Primitive proteins are proposed to have utilized organic cofactors more frequently than transition metals in redox reactions. Thus, an experimental validation on whether a protein constituted solely by early amino acids and an organic cofactor can perform electron transfer activity is an urgent challenge. In this paper, by substituting "late amino acids (C, F, M, T, W, and Y)" with "early amino acids (A, L, and V)" in a flavodoxin, we constructed a flavodoxin mutant and evaluated its characteristic properties. The major results showed that: (1) The flavodoxin mutant has structural characteristics similar to wild-type protein; (2) Although the semiquinone and hydroquinone flavodoxin mutants possess lower stability than the corresponding form of wild-type flavodoxin, the redox potential of double electron reduction Em,7 (fld) reached -360 mV, indicating that the flavodoxin mutant constituted solely by early amino acids can exert effective electron transfer activity.
BibTeX
@article{lu2013reconstructing,
  author = {Mingfeng Lu and Hong‐Fang Ji and Tingxuan Li and Shou‐Kai Kang and Yuejie Zhang and Juefei Zheng and Tian Tian and Xi-Shuai Jia and Xing-Ming Lin and Hongyu Zhang},
  title = {{Reconstructing a Flavodoxin Oxidoreductase with Early Amino Acids}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms140612843},
}
Figure