Reconsideration of second-harmonic generation from isotropic liquid interface: Broken Kleinman symmetry of neat air/water interface from dipolar contribution

Wen-kai Zhang, Desheng Zheng, Yanyan Xu, Hongtao Bian, Yuan Guo, Hongfei WangThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2005 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

It has been generally accepted that there are significant quadrupolar and bulk contributions to the second-harmonic generation (SHG) reflected from the neat air/water interface, as well as common liquid interfaces. Because there has been no general methodology to determine the quadrupolar and bulk contributions to the SHG signal from a liquid interface, this conclusion was reached based on the following two experimental phenomena: the breaking of the macroscopic Kleinman symmetry and the significant temperature dependence of the SHG signal from the neat air/water interface. However, because the sum frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy (SFG-VS) measurement of the neat air/water interface observed no apparent temperature dependence, the temperature dependence in the SHG measurement has been reexamined and proven to be an experimental artifact. Here we present a complete microscopic analysis of the susceptibility tensors of the air/water interface, and show that dipolar contribution alone can be used to address the issue of the breaking of the macroscopic Kleinman symmetry at the neat air/water interface. Using this analysis, the orientation of the water molecules at the interface can be obtained, and it is consistent with the measurement from SFG-VS. Therefore, the key rationales to conclude significantly quadrupolar and bulk contributions to the SHG signal of the neat air/water interface can no longer be considered as valid as before. This new understanding of the air/water interface can shed light on our understanding of the nonlinear optical responses from other molecular interfaces as well.

Introduction

Second Harmonic Generation (SHG) is a powerful nonlinear optical technique used to study surfaces and interfaces. Because SHG is theoretically forbidden in centrosymmetric bulk materials like liquid water, it should, in principle, only probe the thin layer of molecules at the surface where symmetry is broken. However, the "neat" (pure) air/water interface has long been a subject of debate. Early experiments showed two major discrepancies that didn't fit a simple surface-only model: a significant temperature dependence of the SHG signal and the breaking of Kleinman symmetry (where certain optical properties, $\chi_{xzx}$ and $\chi_{zxx}$, should be equal but were found to differ significantly).

These observations led to a consensus that SHG signals from liquid interfaces include substantial "quadrupolar" contributions from the bulk liquid, complicating its use as a purely surface-sensitive probe. This study re-examines these assumptions, proposing that the dipolar surface contribution alone, when modeled correctly, is sufficient to explain the experimental data.

Methodology

The researchers employed high-precision experimental measurements coupled with a rigorous microscopic theoretical analysis. They used a femtosecond Ti:Sapphire laser (800 nm) to perform SHG measurements at a 70° incident angle. A key innovation was the use of 360° automatic scans of the input polarization angle, which allowed for the elimination of experimental offsets and achieved higher accuracy for weak signals compared to traditional 90° range studies.

SHG intensity as a function of input polarization angle $\theta$ for the air/water interface.

On the theoretical side, the authors moved beyond oversimplified rod-like molecular models. They treated water molecules with $C_{2v}$ symmetry and derived the relationship between microscopic molecular polarizability ($\beta$) and macroscopic surface susceptibility ($\chi$) using Euler transformation matrices. They also investigated potential experimental artifacts, specifically looking for environmental factors like water condensation that might have skewed previous temperature-dependence data.

Results and Discussion

The study's findings challenge the long-held "bulk contribution" theory. First, the authors identified that the massive temperature dependence reported in earlier decades was likely an artifact of water vapor condensing on the internal surfaces of experimental cells. When condensation was prevented, the temperature dependence vanished, aligning SHG results with Sum Frequency Generation (SFG) data.

Second, the "broken" Kleinman symmetry was shown to be a natural consequence of water's $C_{2v}$ molecular structure and electronic transitions in the deep UV. Even at 800 nm, there is enough dispersion to break the symmetry without needing to invoke bulk interference. By applying their $C_{2v}$ dipolar model, the authors could quantitatively explain the experimental susceptibility ratios.

Comparison of susceptibility ratios and orientational parameters for the air/water interface across different studies.

As shown in the comparative analysis, the authors measured the ratio $\chi_{zxx}/\chi_{xzx}$ to be 0.30 ± 0.03, a value more precise than previous reports. Using this data, they calculated the orientation of water molecules at the interface, finding a dipole vector angle of approximately 40.3° ± 0.4° from the surface normal. This result is remarkably consistent with SFG-VS measurements, providing a unified physical picture of the air/water interface.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that the dipolar contribution is sufficient to explain the SHG response of the neat air/water interface, effectively debunking the necessity of significant quadrupolar or bulk contributions. By correcting for experimental artifacts and employing a more accurate molecular symmetry model, the study restores SHG's status as a clean, surface-specific probe for this system. Future work may extend this microscopic $C_{2v}$ analysis to other complex molecular interfaces, such as liquid/liquid boundaries, to further refine our understanding of nonlinear optical responses at surfaces.

Summary updated

Abstract

It has been generally accepted that there are significant quadrupolar and bulk contributions to the second-harmonic generation (SHG) reflected from the neat air/water interface, as well as common liquid interfaces. Because there has been no general methodology to determine the quadrupolar and bulk contributions to the SHG signal from a liquid interface, this conclusion was reached based on the following two experimental phenomena: the breaking of the macroscopic Kleinman symmetry and the significant temperature dependence of the SHG signal from the neat air/water interface. However, because the sum frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy (SFG-VS) measurement of the neat air/water interface observed no apparent temperature dependence, the temperature dependence in the SHG measurement has been reexamined and proven to be an experimental artifact. Here we present a complete microscopic analysis of the susceptibility tensors of the air/water interface, and show that dipolar contribution alone can be used to address the issue of the breaking of the macroscopic Kleinman symmetry at the neat air/water interface. Using this analysis, the orientation of the water molecules at the interface can be obtained, and it is consistent with the measurement from SFG-VS. Therefore, the key rationales to conclude significantly quadrupolar and bulk contributions to the SHG signal of the neat air/water interface can no longer be considered as valid as before. This new understanding of the air/water interface can shed light on our understanding of the nonlinear optical responses from other molecular interfaces as well.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2005reconsideration,
  author = {Wen-kai Zhang and Desheng Zheng and Yanyan Xu and Hongtao Bian and Yuan Guo and Hongfei Wang},
  title = {{Reconsideration of second-harmonic generation from isotropic liquid interface: Broken Kleinman symmetry of neat air/water interface from dipolar contribution}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1063/1.2136875},
}
Figure