RECONFIGURABLE MODULAR BAR STRUCTURE

Marios C. Phocas, Maria Matheou, Andreas Mueller, Eftychios G. ChristoforouZenodo 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel reconfigurable modular bar structure that can adapt its shape in real-time, offering enhanced flexibility for temporary architectural applications. The system utilizes an "effective 4-bar" mechanism and cable-driven actuation, enabling shape changes with minimal actuators and weight, validated through prototype testing and finite element analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional buildings are static, offering limited adaptability to changing environmental conditions, functional needs, or loading scenarios. While concepts like modularity and reconfigurability have been explored to address this, existing solutions often involve complex mechanisms, heavy actuators, and energy-intensive operations. This paper tackles the challenge of creating a reconfigurable spatial structure that is lightweight, energy-efficient, and adaptable, specifically for temporary or dynamic architectural applications. The goal is to achieve significant shape transformations with a simplified actuation system and a modular design that facilitates assembly and disassembly.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is a modular spatial structure composed of parallel planar 9-bar linkages. Each linkage is a system of hinge-connected beams. The key innovation lies in the reconfiguration approach, which employs an "effective 4-bar" (E4B) mechanism. This is achieved by selectively locking joints within the 9-bar linkage, effectively reducing its degrees of freedom to one for a specific transformation step.

Actuation is managed by a cable-driven system with only two linear actuators located at the supports of each planar linkage. These actuators tension or release cables that are routed through pulleys on the struts, controlling the movement of the joints. This strategy minimizes the weight and complexity of the main structure by avoiding actuators directly attached to it.

Motion planning for the reconfigurations considers mechanical design constraints and kinematic characteristics, ensuring that joints remain unlocked appropriately and that no part of the structure moves below the horizontal ground level. The paper also details the fabrication of a 1:5 scale prototype to test the mechanical design, control system, and reconfiguration approach. Finally, a nonlinear Finite-Element Analysis (FEA) was performed to understand the structure's load-bearing behavior during transformations under various loading conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a self-created prototype and simulated FEA models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Effective 4-Bar (E4B) Mechanism for Reconfiguration: The clever use of selective joint locking to create a single-degree-of-freedom "effective 4-bar" mechanism is a key insight. This simplifies the control problem significantly compared to managing all degrees of freedom of a 9-bar linkage.
  • Remote Actuation for Weight and Complexity Reduction: Placing the linear actuators at the supports, rather than on the main structure, is a crucial design choice. This drastically reduces the self-weight and energy consumption during reconfigurations, making the system more practical for architectural applications.
  • Modularity for Scalability and Reusability: The inherent modularity of the planar linkages allows for easy assembly, disassembly, and potential expansion in the longitudinal direction, making the structure versatile and sustainable.
  • Cable-Driven Actuation as a Secondary System: The cables not only act as primary actuation means but also contribute to the structural integrity of the system once a configuration is achieved, acting as secondary strengthening components.
  • FEA for Understanding Nonlinear Behavior: The FEA analysis provides valuable insights into how the structure behaves under load during its various configurations, highlighting potential areas of concern and informing material selection and member sizing.

Key Results

  • Successful Prototype Fabrication and Testing: A 1:5 scale prototype of the 9-bar linkage system was successfully fabricated and tested, demonstrating the feasibility of the E4B reconfiguration method and cable-driven actuation.
  • FEA Reveals Load-Bearing Behavior: The FEA simulations indicated that the members remain within their elastic region under self-weight. However, excessive deformations can occur under vertical loads, suggesting the need for careful material selection (lightweight yet stiff) and potentially increased member cross-sections.
  • Deformation Analysis: The study quantified maximum horizontal and vertical deformations under various load cases (self-weight, vertical load, wind load) for both unlocked and locked joint configurations, providing critical data for design considerations. For instance, maximum horizontal deformation reached 37 cm under vertical load with unlocked joints.
  • Dynamic Characteristics: The fundamental period of the structure varied significantly with reconfiguration steps, highlighting the dynamic nature of the system. The initial configuration had a period of 0.39s, while step 1 showed a period of 0.68s.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation of FEA: The authors acknowledge that the experimental study of the prototype did not fully validate the FEA model. While FEA provides a global understanding, the exact deformation values require further experimental verification.
  • Material Properties and Stiffness: The FEA results suggest that while lightweight materials are desirable, they may necessitate increased stiffness in member sections to manage deformations. A balance between lightweight design, high stiffness, and strengthening measures is crucial.
  • Friction in Locking Mechanisms: Practical limitations were observed regarding friction in the joint locking mechanisms, which can oppose the release of locked joints, especially under the structure's self-weight.
  • Cable Pretension and Elasticity: The need for cable pretension to ensure smooth transitions and prevent slack was identified. Cable elasticity and friction in the pulley system also play a significant role in force distribution.
  • Automated Sequence Optimization: Further research is planned for developing automated processes to select optimized reconfiguration sequences, considering motion and actuation constraints based on criteria like joint torques and system deformations. This would enhance the system's intelligence and efficiency.

Summary updated

Abstract

Structural modularity and reconfiguration allow for enhanced flexibility and adaptability to changing functional, environmental or loading conditions, contributing thus to a sustainable built up environment. The current paper refers to a temporary spatial structure of planar modular bar linkages positioned in parallel and interconnected. The linkages consist of hinge-connected beams and a secondary system of struts and continuous cables with adjustable length. Identical and synchronous reconfigurations of the planar systems provide respective shapes of the spatial structure. In achieving the transformations, the effective 4-bar approach is implemented via cable- driven actuation, necessitating only two linear actuators on the planar systems supports. Following a brief description of the reconfiguration approach and related motion planning principles, a presentation of the fabrication and assembly of a small-scale prototype model and its experimental testing leads to a discussion on related mechanical design and reconfiguration approach issues. By extent, a Finite-Element Analysis of the spatial structure conducted for a specific transformation sequence followed from an initial to a target configuration provides further insight in the system’s nonlinear load-bearing behavior.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{phocas2019reconfigurable,
  author = {Marios C. Phocas and Maria Matheou and Andreas Mueller and Eftychios G. Christoforou},
  title = {{RECONFIGURABLE MODULAR BAR STRUCTURE}},
  booktitle = {Zenodo},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.5281/zenodo.3574241},
}
Figure