Reconfigurable Laser-Stimulated Lock-In Thermography for Surface Micro-Crack Detection

Lu Ding, Sergey Gorelik, Pei Wang, Anton Valentinovich Sadovoy, Qiang Zhu, Andrew Chun Yong Ngo, Jinghua Teng2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a "reconfigurable" laser-stimulated lock-in thermography (LLT) system that uses a spatial light modulator (SLM) to dynamically change the laser illumination pattern. This allows for faster, more flexible, and more precise detection and sizing of surface micro-cracks in metal alloys, overcoming limitations of previous LLT methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting and accurately sizing surface micro-cracks is critical for the safety and reliability of components in industries like aerospace and manufacturing. While various non-destructive testing (NDT) methods exist, many have drawbacks: some are invasive, others are limited to specific material types, and some require direct contact. Laser-stimulated lock-in thermography (LLT) offers a promising non-contact, non-destructive approach. However, traditional LLT methods, especially those using a single laser spot, can be slow for inspecting large areas, and methods using fixed diffractive optical elements (DOEs) lack flexibility. This paper addresses the need for a faster, more adaptable, and precise LLT system capable of both rapid large-area scanning and detailed crack analysis.

Methods

The core innovation is the use of a spatial light modulator (SLM) to dynamically control the laser beam's illumination pattern. Unlike fixed diffractive optical elements (DOEs), the SLM allows for real-time switching between different configurations:

  • Multi-spot illumination: This significantly speeds up large-area inspection by heating multiple points simultaneously. The number and arrangement of spots can be adjusted.
  • Multi-line illumination: Similar to multi-spot, this can cover linear areas efficiently.
  • Single-spot illumination: This is used for detailed, high-resolution analysis of individual cracks.
  • Single-line illumination: Another option for focused inspection.

The system uses a modulated laser to heat the sample surface, and an infrared camera captures the resulting thermal wave propagation. A lock-in detection technique is employed to extract weak thermal signals from background noise, enhancing accuracy and signal-to-noise ratio. The paper also details a signal processing algorithm involving the 2D Laplacian of the amplitude image, combined with amplitude threshold filters, to effectively highlight and size cracks.

Datasets

The paper evaluates the system on two types of metallic samples:

  1. Sample A: A porous nickel superalloy metal plate fabricated using additive manufacturing. This sample features numerous surface pores and cracks, requiring large-area inspection.
  2. Sample B: Ti-6Al-4V (Ti64) alloy metal blocks with pre-characterized thermal fatigue surface cracks. These samples were used for detailed crack sizing analysis. The paper provides a table (Table 1) listing the specific crack IDs, their coordinates, lengths (0.8 mm to 3.4 mm), and openings (0.9 µm to 10 µm).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reconfigurability is key: The SLM's ability to dynamically change illumination patterns is the central advantage, offering flexibility that fixed optics cannot match. This allows for a two-stage inspection process: rapid overview with multi-spot/line, followed by detailed analysis with single-spot.
  • Speed-up potential: Multi-spot illumination can reduce inspection time by a factor of N² (where N is the number of spots), making large-area scanning much more efficient.
  • Crack sizing correlation: An empirical parameter, 'b', derived from the Laplacian of the amplitude image and related to the thermal diffusion length, shows a linear dependence with crack length. This suggests a potential for calibrating crack depth estimation.
  • Thermal diffusion length matters: The modulation frequency directly influences the thermal diffusion length, which in turn dictates the inspection area and the depth at which defects can be detected. Lower frequencies allow for deeper penetration and larger areas but require longer acquisition times.

Key Results

  • The reconfigurable LLT system successfully detected and characterized micro-cracks and pores on both sample types.
  • Multi-spot LLT demonstrated a significant speed advantage for large-area inspection compared to single-spot LLT, covering a larger area with comparable or better defect visibility.
  • The minimum resolved size of micro-holes was approximately 50 µm, limited by the camera lens magnification.
  • For Ti64 alloy fatigue cracks, an empirical parameter 'b' was found to correlate linearly with crack length, offering a pathway for crack sizing calibration.
  • The system provides three-dimensional crack information, enhancing the understanding of defect geometry.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Resolution Limit: The minimum resolved size of micro-holes is limited by the magnification of the camera lens (around 50 µm).
  • Calibration: While an empirical parameter 'b' shows promise for crack sizing, further calibration using direct experimental measurements (e.g., other crack opening methods) is required to determine exact crack depth values.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the tunability of the SLM allows the system to adapt to various materials, implying broader applicability. Further investigation into the precise calibration of crack depth using the developed parameter is also implied. The paper also notes that the system is applicable to detecting surface or sub-surface defects in a wide range of materials beyond metals.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{ding2023reconfigurable,
  author = {Lu Ding and Sergey Gorelik and Pei Wang and Anton Valentinovich Sadovoy and Qiang Zhu and Andrew Chun Yong Ngo and Jinghua Teng},
  title = {{Reconfigurable Laser-Stimulated Lock-In Thermography for Surface Micro-Crack Detection}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23084090},
}
Figure