Recharging Difficulty With Pulse Generator After Deep Brain Stimulation: A Case Series of Five Patients

Hongyang Li, Daoqing Su, Yijie Lai, X. Hermione Xu, Chencheng Zhang, Bomin Sun, Dianyou Li, Yixin PanFrontiers in Neuroscience 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is a well-established treatment for movement disorders. While rechargeable implanted pulse generators (r-IPGs) offer significant benefits, they introduce a rare hardware complication: charging difficulty. Objective: This study reports five cases of postoperative r-IPG charging difficulty and explores predisposing factors and treatment strategies. Methods: A retrospective review of 1,226 DBS patients identified five individuals (0.4%) with charging issues. Results: Causes included device flipping, incorrect orientation, and excessive subcutaneous fat. All cases were resolved via reoperation, including anchoring the r-IPG to muscle/fascia or repositioning it in a shallower layer. Conclusion: This study identifies novel hardware complications and provides effective surgical solutions to ensure device longevity.

Introduction

Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) is a standard-of-care surgical intervention for movement disorders like Parkinson’s disease and Tourette syndrome. Historically, patients required frequent surgeries to replace primary (non-rechargeable) batteries. The advent of rechargeable IPGs (r-IPGs) in the 2000s promised to reduce these surgical risks and long-term costs.

However, r-IPGs rely on transcutaneous inductive coupling—essentially wireless charging through the skin. If the alignment between the external recharger and the internal pulse generator is disrupted, the device cannot charge, rendering the therapy useless once the battery drains. This paper investigates why this happens and how to fix it, filling a gap in clinical literature regarding this specific hardware failure.

Methods

The authors conducted a retrospective review of a massive DBS patient database at Ruijin Hospital, Shanghai, covering nearly a ten-year period (January 2012 to January 2021).

  • Study Population: 1,226 patients implanted with r-IPGs.
  • Approach: Researchers identified five specific cases where patients experienced postoperative charging difficulties.
  • Analysis: Medical records, X-ray imaging, and intraoperative findings during revision surgeries were scrutinized to categorize the root causes of the charging failures.

Key Insights and Failure Modes

The researchers identified three distinct "failure modes" for r-IPG charging:

  • The "Twiddler" and Weight Loss Effect: In two cases, the device flipped upside down inside the pocket. One patient admitted to "twiddling" (intentionally manipulating) the device due to itchiness. In another, significant weight loss caused the surgical pocket to become too loose, allowing the device to rotate spontaneously.
  • Orientation Errors: In two cases, the device was implanted with the wrong side facing outward from the start. Because the charging coil is directional, having the "model number" side facing inward instead of outward prevented a successful wireless link.
  • The Adipose Barrier: In the final case, a patient’s weight gain resulted in a subcutaneous fat layer approximately 2 cm thick. This physical distance exceeded the effective range of the inductive charger, even though the device was oriented correctly.
Figure 1: Plain chest X-rays of cases 1 and 2 showing the upside-down implanted pulse generators (IPGs). The red arrows indicate the r-IPG was upside down, which prevented successful wireless charging.

Results and Surgical Resolution

Charging difficulty is rare, occurring in only 0.4% of the studied population. Patients typically presented with reduced charging efficiency and prolonged charging times, while internal lead impedance remained normal.

All five cases were successfully resolved through revision surgery:

  • Anchoring: For cases involving device flipping, surgeons anchored the r-IPG to the pectoralis fascia using silk sutures and reduced the pocket size.
  • Re-orientation: For orientation errors, the device was simply flipped to the correct side.
  • Depth Adjustment: For the patient with excessive adipose tissue, a shallower subcutaneous pocket (1 cm deep) was created to bring the device closer to the skin surface.

No recurrences of charging difficulty were reported following these specific interventions.

Discussion and Future Work

The primary limitation of this study is the small sample size ($n=5$), which is expected given the rarity of the complication. However, the findings suggest that future hardware designs could mitigate these issues—for example, by developing IPGs that can be charged from either side or by increasing the transmission range of the inductive coupling.

For current clinical practice, the authors recommend a "double-anchoring" surgical technique to the pectoralis fascia as a preventative standard to ensure device stability regardless of weight fluctuations or patient manipulation.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is a well-established treatment for a variety of movement disorders. Rechargeable cell technology was introduced to pulse generator more than 10 years ago and brought great benefits to patients. However, with the widespread use of rechargeable implanted pulse generators (r-IPGs), a new hardware complication, when charging the r-IPG has been difficult, was encountered. <b>Objective:</b> The aims of this study were to report five cases confronted with r-IPG charging difficulty postoperatively and to explore the predisposing factors and treatment strategies for this rare complication. <b>Methods:</b> We retrospectively reviewed our DBS patient database for those who were implanted with r-IPGs. From 2012, we identified a total of 1,226 patients, with five of them experiencing charging difficulties after surgery. Detailed patient profiles and clinical procedures were scrutinized and reviewed. <b>Results:</b> All the charging problems were resolved by reoperation. Cases 1 and 2 required their r-IPGs to be anchored to the muscle and fascia. Cases 3 and 4 had their r-IPGs inserted in the wrong orientation at the initial surgery, which was resolved by turning around the r-IPGs at the revision surgery. Case 5, in which we propose that the thick subcutaneous fat layer blocked the connection between the r-IPG and the recharger, required a second operation to reposition the r-IPG in a shallow layer underneath the skin. For all cases, the charging problems were resolved without reoccurrences to date. <b>Conclusion:</b> Our case series indicates a novel hardware complication of DBS surgery, which had been rarely reported before. In this preliminary study, we describe several underlying causes of this complication and treatment methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021recharging,
  author = {Hongyang Li and Daoqing Su and Yijie Lai and X. Hermione Xu and Chencheng Zhang and Bomin Sun and Dianyou Li and Yixin Pan},
  title = {{Recharging Difficulty With Pulse Generator After Deep Brain Stimulation: A Case Series of Five Patients}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2021.705483},
}
Figure