Recent Results on No-Free-Lunch Theorems for Optimization

Christian Igel, Marc ToussaintarXiv 2003 · OpenReview

Abstract: The sharpened No-Free-Lunch-theorem (NFL-theorem) states that the performance of all optimization algorithms averaged over any finite set F of functions is equal if and only if F is closed under permutation (c.u.p.) and each target function in F is equally likely. In this paper, we first summarize some consequences of this theorem, which have been proven recently: The average number of evaluations needed to find a desirable (e.g., optimal) solution can be calculated; the number of subsets c.u.p. can be neglected compared to the overall number of possible subsets; and problem classes relevant in practice are not likely to be c.u.p. Second, as the main result, the NFL-theorem is extended. Necessary and sufficient conditions for NFL-results to hold are given for arbitrary, non-uniform distributions of target functions. This yields the most general NFL-theorem for optimization presented so far.

Introduction

Published in 2003, this research provides a rigorous mathematical reality check on the No-Free-Lunch (NFL) theorem for optimization. While the original NFL theorem suggests that all optimization algorithms perform equally when averaged over all possible functions, this paper explores the conditions under which this scenario actually occurs. The authors demonstrate that the "No-Free-Lunch" scenario is a mathematical rarity that almost never applies to the structured problems encountered in practical engineering.

The Optimization Framework

The paper models optimization as an iterative process involving a non-repeating black-box search algorithm $a$ and a target function $f$ mapping a search space $\mathcal{X}$ to a set of values $\mathcal{Y}$. The algorithm generates a sequence of samples, and its performance is assessed by a measure $c$ based on the values found.

The standard black-box optimization framework: an algorithm $a$ queries a target function $f$ to produce a sequence of values $Y$, which is then evaluated by a performance measure $c$.

Practitioners often observe that specific algorithms outperform others on certain tasks. This paper addresses the gap between this practical intuition and the original NFL theory by examining the "sharpened" NFL theorem, which focuses on specific subsets of functions rather than the entire function space.

The Rarity of No-Free-Lunch

A critical prerequisite for the NFL theorem to hold is that the set of functions must be "closed under permutation" (c.u.p.). A set is c.u.p. if swapping the labels of the points in the search space does not change the overall set of functions.

The authors' combinatorial analysis reveals that the fraction of function subsets satisfying this condition is vanishingly small. As the search space size $|\mathcal{X}|$ grows, the probability that a randomly chosen subset of problems will be c.u.p. drops toward zero at a double-exponential rate.

The fraction of function subsets that are closed under permutation (c.u.p.)—a requirement for the NFL theorem—decreases double-exponentially as the search space size $|\mathcal{X}|$ increases.

Extending the Theorem: Non-Uniform Distributions

One of the paper's primary contributions is the "Non-Uniform Sharpened NFL-theorem." Previous versions of the theorem assumed that every function within a set was equally likely to occur. The authors derive the necessary and sufficient conditions for NFL results to hold under arbitrary, non-uniform probability distributions.

They establish what can be called the "Histogram Rule": for all algorithms to perform equally, the probability distribution must be uniform across "basis classes." Essentially, if two functions share the same "histogram" of output values, they must be assigned the exact same probability. If a practitioner believes a "smooth" function is more likely than a "noisy" one containing the same values, the NFL condition is immediately broken.

Why Structure Kills NFL

Most real-world problems possess inherent structure, such as neighborhoods, steepness constraints, or a limited number of local minima. The authors formally prove that these structures are not invariant under permutation. Consequently, any problem class defined by these common features is automatically exempt from the No-Free-Lunch theorem.

For cases where the NFL condition does hold, the authors provide an elegant formula for the average number of evaluations $E$ needed to find an optimal solution: $$E = \frac{|\mathcal{X}|+1}{n+1}$$ where $|\mathcal{X}|$ is the size of the search space and $n$ is the number of optimal solutions.

Conclusion

By proving that the conditions for the NFL theorem are highly restrictive and practically non-existent for structured problems, the authors conclude that "Free Lunches"—the ability to find a superior algorithm for a specific domain—are almost always possible. The challenge for future research lies not in questioning whether a better algorithm exists, but in formally characterizing problem structures to identify and exploit those superior algorithms.

Summary updated

Abstract

The sharpened No-Free-Lunch-theorem (NFL-theorem) states that the performance of all optimization algorithms averaged over any finite set F of functions is equal if and only if F is closed under permutation (c.u.p.) and each target function in F is equally likely. In this paper, we first summarize some consequences of this theorem, which have been proven recently: The average number of evaluations needed to find a desirable (e.g., optimal) solution can be calculated; the number of subsets c.u.p. can be neglected compared to the overall number of possible subsets; and problem classes relevant in practice are not likely to be c.u.p. Second, as the main result, the NFL-theorem is extended. Necessary and sufficient conditions for NFL-results to hold are given for arbitrary, non-uniform distributions of target functions. This yields the most general NFL-theorem for optimization presented so far.
BibTeX
@misc{igel2003recent,
  author = {Christian Igel and Marc Toussaint},
  title = {{Recent Results on No-Free-Lunch Theorems for Optimization}},
  year = {2003},
  eprint = {cs/0303032},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/cs/0303032},
}
Figure