Recent advances in innovative strategies for plant disease resistance breeding

Dekun Wang, Rong Yang, Mengting Liu, Haolong Li, Haitao Li, Wenya Yuan, Haitao ZhangFrontiers in Plant Science 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This review highlights recent breakthroughs in plant disease resistance breeding, moving beyond traditional methods to focus on innovative molecular strategies. It details how gene editing of susceptibility genes, promoter editing, and engineering of resistance gene products, particularly NLR receptors, are revolutionizing our ability to protect crops from devastating pathogens.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Crop production faces a constant and significant threat from plant diseases, leading to substantial yield losses worldwide. Understanding the intricate mechanisms of plant-pathogen interactions is crucial for developing effective resistance strategies. While traditional breeding methods have been valuable, they often fall short against evolving pathogens. This paper addresses the need for advanced, molecular-level approaches to enhance plant immunity and create more resilient crops.

Methods

The paper reviews several key strategies for improving crop resistance:

  • Domain Swapping and Gene Shuffling: These established techniques involve creating chimeric genes or shuffling existing ones to identify critical functional domains within resistance (R) genes. They are particularly useful for understanding the specificity of NLR and RLK genes.
  • Random Mutation: This method uses random mutagenesis to generate variations in R genes, aiming to broaden their recognition spectrum against pathogen effectors.
  • Gene Editing of Susceptibility (S) Genes: This is a major focus, utilizing technologies like CRISPR/Cas9 to precisely modify host genes that pathogens exploit for infection. Editing genes like Mlo and DMR6 has shown significant promise in conferring resistance.
  • Promoter Editing: This strategy involves modifying the regulatory regions (promoters) of S genes or R genes. It's particularly effective against pathogens like Xanthomonas that use Transcription Activator-Like Effectors (TALEs) to hijack host gene expression. By editing the TALE binding sites (EBEs) in S gene promoters, their activation can be attenuated.
  • Engineering of R Gene Products: This cutting-edge approach leverages detailed structural and mechanistic knowledge of R gene products, especially Nucleotide-Binding and Leucine-Rich Repeat (NLR) receptors. Techniques include swapping functional domains, introducing nanobodies, and structure-guided mutations to create novel receptors with altered or expanded recognition capabilities.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review of existing research and strategies, not a report on a specific experimental dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shifting from R genes to S genes: While R genes have been the traditional focus, targeting and editing host susceptibility (S) genes is emerging as a powerful and often more durable strategy for resistance.
  • Promoter editing as a nuanced approach: Editing promoters offers a way to fine-tune gene expression and mimic natural resistance mechanisms without completely knocking out essential genes, potentially avoiding negative pleiotropic effects.
  • NLR engineering is entering a new era: Advances in structural biology are enabling the rational design and engineering of NLR receptors, moving beyond simple domain swaps to creating novel immune sensors with tailored specificities.
  • "Pikobodies" as artificial immunity: The fusion of NLRs with nanobodies represents a significant step towards creating artificial immune receptor systems that could offer broad-spectrum and adaptable resistance.
  • AI and synthetic biology as future drivers: The integration of AI for protein structure prediction and design, alongside synthetic biology tools, holds immense potential for accelerating the discovery and engineering of new resistance strategies.

Key Results

The paper summarizes findings from numerous studies across various crops:

  • Mlo and DMR6 editing: Gene editing of Mlo has conferred durable, broad-spectrum resistance to powdery mildew in wheat and cucumber. Similarly, DMR6 editing has enhanced resistance to downy mildew, bacterial spot, and other diseases in various crops.
  • Promoter editing for Xanthomonas resistance: Editing TALE binding sites in promoters of S genes like CsLOB1 and MeSWEET10a has significantly reduced susceptibility to Xanthomonas species in citrus and cassava, respectively. Similar strategies in rice have shown broad-spectrum resistance to bacterial blight.
  • NLR engineering success: Engineered NLRs, such as modified RGA5 and Pikp-1 variants, have demonstrated altered or expanded effector recognition profiles, conferring resistance to specific pathogen strains in model systems like tobacco and rice. For example, RGA5HMA2 successfully shifted recognition from AVR-Pia to AVR-Pib.
  • "Pikobody" system: The fusion of NLRs with nanobodies has created "Pikobodies" that confer resistance to potato virus X variants in transgenic tobacco, showcasing a novel approach to artificial immunity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pleiotropic effects of S gene editing: While effective, knocking out S genes can sometimes lead to unexpected developmental impairments. Future work will focus on selecting alternative S genes or screening for ideal phenotypes to mitigate these effects.
  • Limited applicability of promoter editing: The effectiveness of promoter editing is dependent on the clear identification of pathogen-responsive cis-elements, which are not always known, limiting its broad applicability.
  • NLR engineering in crops: While promising, many NLR engineering efforts have been demonstrated in model systems (e.g., tobacco) and require further optimization for practical application in crop production.
  • Effector-targeted Pikobodies: Currently, no effector-targeted Pikobodies have been engineered, highlighting a need for further development in this area.
  • Ecological considerations: Future breeding strategies must consider the complex plant microbiome and the co-evolutionary dynamics between plants and pathogens.
  • Public perception of GMOs: The paper acknowledges the need for improved communication and transparent policies regarding genetically modified organisms (GMOs) to foster public acceptance.
  • AI and machine learning: The authors foresee AI playing a crucial role in identifying essential genes, optimizing CRISPR targets, and facilitating the de novo design of plant immune receptors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Plant disease poses a great threat to crop production. The mechanisms underlying plant-pathogen interactions are critical research topics worldwide. In recent years, significant breakthrough studies have been reported, broadening our understanding of plant immunity. Based on these findings, many strategies have been developed to improve plant defense against various diseases. Here, we summarize these strategies and their applications in studies aimed at promoting crop resistance. Besides domain swapping, gene shuffling, and random mutation, three additional strategies have been developed in the last decade. The first strategy is gene editing of host <i>susceptibility</i> (<i>S</i>) genes to prevent pathogen infection. Editing of <i>Mlo</i> and <i>DMR6</i> gene in many species are good examples of this approach. The second strategy is editing the promoters of host <i>S</i> genes or <i>resistance</i> (<i>R</i>) genes. This strategy is widely used to counteract <i>Xanthomonas</i>, such as modifying the promoters of <i>LOB1</i> and <i>SWEET</i> genes in several crops to enhance resistance. The third strategy is designing <i>R</i> gene products, especially nucleotide-binding and leucine-rich repeat (NLR) receptors. This approach is based on the growing knowledge of the structural features and mechanisms of NLRs, which have seen significant advances recently. To date, all NLR-engineering attempts have focused on rice paired NLRs, such as Pikp-1/Pikp-2 (allelic to Pikm-1/Pikm-2) and RGA4/RGA5. The bioengineering of these NLRs provides a promising method to combat diverse pathogens. Detailed studies in many crops are also discussed in this review, organized around these strategies. In summary, with progresses in understanding plant immune mechanism, many innovative molecular strategies are available to mitigate the threat of plant pathogens in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2025recent,
  author = {Dekun Wang and Rong Yang and Mengting Liu and Haolong Li and Haitao Li and Wenya Yuan and Haitao Zhang},
  title = {{Recent advances in innovative strategies for plant disease resistance breeding}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2025.1586375},
}
Figure