Realization of Two-dimensional Discrete Time Crystals with Anisotropic Heisenberg Coupling

Eric D. Switzer, Niall F. Robertson, Nathan Keenan, Ángel Luis Pérez Rodríguez, Andrea D’Urbano, Bibek Pokharel, Talat S. Rahman, Oles Shtanko, Sergiy Zhuk, Nicolás LorentearXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully realized a two-dimensional Discrete Time Crystal (DTC) using a 144-qubit IBM quantum processor. By moving beyond simple 1D Ising models to complex, nature-like anisotropic Heisenberg interactions, the team demonstrated that these exotic phases of matter can be stabilized in higher dimensions, revealing a rich phase diagram that includes "scar-like" quantum behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A Discrete Time Crystal (DTC) is a strange phase of matter that breaks time-translation symmetry: you "kick" the system periodically, but it responds at a different frequency (usually half the frequency of the kick). To keep this oscillation from decaying into thermal "mush," the system needs Many-Body Localization (MBL)—a mechanism where disorder prevents energy from spreading.

Until now, most experimental DTCs were restricted to one-dimensional chains and simple "Ising-like" interactions (where spins only care about their neighbors' up/down orientation). However, real-world materials are often 2D or 3D and involve "Heisenberg" interactions (where spins can flip and swap). There has been significant theoretical debate over whether MBL—and thus a stable DTC—can even exist in 2D, as higher dimensions make it much easier for thermalization to destroy quantum coherence.

Methods

The authors combined cutting-edge hardware with sophisticated classical simulation techniques:

  • Quantum Hardware: They used the 156-qubit IBM "Heron r2" processor (ibm_fez), specifically a 144-qubit subset arranged in a "heavy-hexagonal" lattice.
  • The Model: They implemented a Floquet (periodically driven) system governed by anisotropic Heisenberg (XXZ) interactions. This involves three layers of two-qubit gates followed by a global "kick" (an X-gate rotation).
  • Classical Simulation: To verify the quantum results, they used Matrix Product States (MPS) and 2D Tensor Network States (2dTNS). Because exact 2D simulation is computationally impossible at this scale, they employed Belief Propagation (BP) to approximate the system's state.
  • Noise Mitigation: A major contribution is their "physics-inspired" renormalization technique. They ran the same circuits on smaller, classically simulable subsystems (2x2 and 3x3 hexagons) to learn the noise profile, then used those parameters to "clean" the data from the full 144-qubit experiment.

Datasets

This study does not use traditional external datasets. Instead, it generates and analyzes:

  • Experimental Data: Raw bitstrings and expectation values from the ibm_fez quantum processor across various points in the phase diagram (varying the "kick" angle $\phi$ and the spin-flip coupling $\epsilon$).
  • Simulation Benchmarks: Data from MPS and 2dTNS simulations used to validate the hardware and the error mitigation strategy.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 2D Stability: The experiment provides strong evidence that 2D systems can resist thermalization long enough to exhibit time-crystalline behavior, even with complex Heisenberg interactions that typically promote "melting."
  • The "Aha" Moment on Initialization: The researchers found that the DTC's stability depends heavily on the initial state. A Néel state (alternating spins) decays quickly, but a fully polarized state (all spins up) is remarkably robust.
  • Quantum Many-Body Scars: The stability of the polarized state suggests a connection to "quantum scars"—special states that refuse to thermalize even when the rest of the system is chaotic. This suggests a new mechanism for stabilizing DTCs that doesn't rely solely on MBL.
  • Phase Mapping: The team successfully mapped a 2D phase diagram showing three distinct regimes: Ergodic (thermalizing/boring), Spin-Glass (frozen disorder), and DTC (the time crystal).

Key Results

  • Subharmonic Response: The system showed clear period-doubling oscillations (oscillating every two kicks) that persisted for the duration of the experiment (up to 50 Floquet cycles).
  • Order Parameters: The DTC order parameter ($\Delta_{DTC}$) approached unity in the time-crystalline regime, while the MBL order parameter ($\Delta_{MBL}$) confirmed the system remained localized.
  • Entanglement Growth: Using Quantum Fisher Information (QFI), they showed that entanglement grows very slowly in the DTC phase compared to the rapid growth seen in the ergodic (thermal) phase, a hallmark of localization.
  • Scaling: By comparing 2x2, 3x3, and 3x7 lattice geometries, they demonstrated that the time-crystalline signal actually becomes more stable as the system size increases.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Finite Time: While the oscillations are "persistent," they are still subject to hardware noise (depolarization and amplitude damping). The "infinite-time" stability of 2D MBL remains a theoretical challenge that current hardware cannot fully resolve.
  • Classical Approximation: The 2D tensor network methods used (Belief Propagation) are approximate. While they match the hardware well, they may miss subtle long-range correlations.
  • Continuous Time Limit: The authors suggest future work should explore the "Trotter limit"—moving from discrete gate steps to a continuous-time drive—to see if the DTC phase survives.
  • Scar Investigation: The discovery of scar-like behavior in the Heisenberg DTC opens a new door for research into how symmetry and initialization can be used to protect quantum information from heat.

Summary updated

Abstract

A discrete time crystal (DTC) is the paradigmatic example of a phase of matter that occurs exclusively in systems out of equilibrium. This phenomenon is characterized by the spontaneous symmetry breaking of discrete time-translation and provides a rich playground to study a fundamental question in statistical physics: what mechanism allows for driven quantum systems to exhibit emergent behavior that deviates from their counterparts with time-independent evolution? Unlike equilibrium phases, DTCs exhibit macroscopic manifestations of coherent quantum dynamics, challenging the conventional narrative that thermodynamic behavior universally erases quantum signatures. However, due to the difficulty of simulating these systems with either classical or quantum computers, previous studies have been limited to a set of models with Ising-like couplings -- and mostly only in one dimension -- thus precluding our understanding of the existence (or not) of DTCs in models with interactions that closely align with what occurs in nature. In this work, by combining the latest generation of IBM quantum processors with state-of-the-art tensor network methods, we are able to demonstrate the existence of a DTC in a two-dimensional system governed by anisotropic Heisenberg interactions. Our comprehensive analysis reveals a rich phase diagram encompassing spin-glass, ergodic, and time-crystalline phases, highlighting the tunability of these phases through multiple control parameters. Crucially, our results emphasize the interplay of initialization, interaction anisotropy, and driving protocols in stabilizing the DTC phase. By extending the study of Floquet matter beyond simplified models, we lay the groundwork for exploring how driven systems bridge the gap between quantum coherence and emergent non-equilibrium thermodynamics.
BibTeX
@misc{switzer2025realization,
  author = {Eric D. Switzer and Niall F. Robertson and Nathan Keenan and Ángel Luis Pérez Rodríguez and Andrea D’Urbano and Bibek Pokharel and Talat S. Rahman and Oles Shtanko and Sergiy Zhuk and Nicolás Lorente},
  title = {{Realization of Two-dimensional Discrete Time Crystals with Anisotropic Heisenberg Coupling}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2501.18036},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.18036},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure