Realization of Fast All-Microwave Controlled-Z Gates with a Tunable Coupler

Shaowei Li, Daojin Fan, Ming Gong, Yangsen Ye, Xiawei Chen, Yulin Wu, Huijie Guan, Huiqiu Deng, Hao Rong, He-Liang Huang, Chen Zha, Kai Yan, Shaojun Guo, Haoran Qian, Haibin Zhang, Fusheng Chen, Qingling Zhu, Youwei Zhao, Shiyu Wang, Chong Ying, Sirui Cao, Jiale Yu, Futian Liang, Yu Xu, Jin Lin, Cheng Guo, Lihua Sun, Na Li, Lianchen Han, Cheng-Zhi Peng, Xiaobo Zhu, Jian-Wei PanChinese 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The development of high-fidelity two-qubit quantum gates is essential for digital quantum computing. Here, we propose and realize an all-microwave parametric controlled-Z (CZ) gates by coupling strength modulation in a superconducting Transmon qubit system with tunable couplers. After optimizing the design of the tunable coupler together with the control pulse numerically, we experimentally realized a 100 ns CZ gate with high fidelity of 99.38% ± 0.34% and the control error being 0.1%. We note that our CZ gates are not affected by pulse distortion and do not need pulse correction, providing a solution for the real-time pulse generation in a dynamic quantum feedback circuit. With the expectation of utilizing our all-microwave control scheme to reduce the number of control lines through frequency multiplexing in the future, our scheme draws a blueprint for the high-integrable quantum hardware design.

Introduction

High-fidelity two-qubit gates, such as the Controlled-Z (CZ) gate, are fundamental building blocks for scalable quantum computing. In superconducting Transmon systems, these gates are typically implemented using either unipolar flux pulses or microwave-based schemes. While flux pulses offer high speed, they are susceptible to pulse distortion from wiring imperfections, necessitating complex calibration. Conversely, traditional microwave gates are cleaner but significantly slower, making them vulnerable to qubit decoherence. This work bridges this gap by demonstrating a fast, all-microwave CZ gate using a tunable coupler that remains immune to low-frequency distortions.

Hardware and Methods

The experimental setup consists of two Transmon qubits connected by a tunable coupler with an asymmetric SQUID loop. This design allows for a wide tuning range of the coupling strength $g$, including a critical "zero-coupling" point where residual interactions are minimized to prevent crosstalk during idle periods.

Circuit schematic and coupling strength tuning. (a) Two Transmon qubits coupled via a tunable coupler. (b) Coupling strength $g/2\pi$ as a function of external flux, highlighting the zero-coupling point.

The gate is driven by applying a net-zero microwave pulse to the coupler's flux line. This pulse parametrically modulates the coupling strength at a specific frequency. To achieve optimal performance, the pulse envelope was numerically optimized using the Nelder-Mead algorithm over 200 iterations to minimize gate errors within a 100 ns window.

Gate Mechanism and Performance

The CZ gate operation relies on driving the system into a regime where the $|11\rangle$ state (both qubits excited) resonates with the $|20\rangle$ state (two excitations on one qubit). This interaction induces the necessary conditional phase shift for the logic operation.

CZ gate mechanism and performance analysis. (a) Energy level diagram showing the $|11\rangle \leftrightarrow |20\rangle$ resonance. (b-c) Time-domain microwave pulse and its frequency spectrum. (d) Simulated gate error vs. frequency detuning.

The realized 100 ns CZ gate achieved an experimental fidelity of 99.38% ± 0.34%, as measured by Cross-Entropy Benchmarking (XEB). An error budget analysis revealed that the dominant source of error is qubit decoherence (0.46% - 0.48%), while control errors were remarkably low at 0.10%. Leakage errors accounted for approximately 0.20%.

Discussion and Conclusion

The all-microwave control scheme provides inherent immunity to the low-frequency pulse distortions that typically plague flux-pulsed gates, eliminating the need for complex pulse correction. Furthermore, the frequency-selective nature of this microwave drive offers a path toward high-density integration. By assigning unique frequencies to different couplers, multiple gates could potentially be controlled via a single physical line through frequency multiplexing. While current fidelities are limited by natural qubit decoherence and readout fluctuations, this approach provides a robust and scalable blueprint for next-generation superconducting quantum hardware.

Summary updated

Abstract

The development of high-fidelity two-qubit quantum gates is essential for digital quantum computing. Here, we propose and realize an all-microwave parametric controlled-Z (CZ) gates by coupling strength modulation in a superconducting Transmon qubit system with tunable couplers. After optimizing the design of the tunable coupler together with the control pulse numerically, we experimentally realized a 100 ns CZ gate with high fidelity of 99.38% ± 0.34% and the control error being 0.1%. We note that our CZ gates are not affected by pulse distortion and do not need pulse correction, providing a solution for the real-time pulse generation in a dynamic quantum feedback circuit. With the expectation of utilizing our all-microwave control scheme to reduce the number of control lines through frequency multiplexing in the future, our scheme draws a blueprint for the high-integrable quantum hardware design.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022realization,
  author = {Shaowei Li and Daojin Fan and Ming Gong and Yangsen Ye and Xiawei Chen and Yulin Wu and Huijie Guan and Huiqiu Deng and Hao Rong and He-Liang Huang and Chen Zha and Kai Yan and Shaojun Guo and Haoran Qian and Haibin Zhang and Fusheng Chen and Qingling Zhu and Youwei Zhao and Shiyu Wang and Chong Ying and Sirui Cao and Jiale Yu and Futian Liang and Yu Xu and Jin Lin and Cheng Guo and Lihua Sun and Na Li and Lianchen Han and Cheng-Zhi Peng and Xiaobo Zhu and Jian-Wei Pan},
  title = {{Realization of Fast All-Microwave Controlled-Z Gates with a Tunable Coupler}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1088/0256-307x/39/3/030302},
}
Figure