Real-Time Structural Monitoring of the Multi-Point Hoisting of a Long-Span Converter Station Steel Structure

Zhu Yunfeng, Yi Gao, Qinghe Zeng, Jin Liao, Zhen Liu, Cuiying ZhouSensors 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel real-time structural monitoring system designed for the complex multi-point hoisting of long-span converter station steel structures. By integrating automatic monitoring, manual measurements, and numerical simulations, the system provides immediate insights into structural behavior, enabling proactive risk management and ensuring safer construction practices for these critical infrastructure projects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction of long-span converter station steel structures, particularly during the hoisting phase, presents significant engineering challenges and risks. These structures are susceptible to bending deformation, fracture, and collapse, especially given their scale and the dynamic nature of hoisting. Historically, there's been a lack of established experience and standardized monitoring methods for such large-scale operations. Traditional monitoring techniques are often limited in scope, difficult to integrate with construction control, and prone to installation errors and complex data processing. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a comprehensive, real-time monitoring system that can effectively track structural changes, identify potential issues, and facilitate rapid decision-making to prevent engineering disasters.

Methods

The core of this research is the development and application of a real-time structural monitoring system. This system employs a multi-pronged approach:

  • Automatic Monitoring: This involves deploying sensors to capture real-time data on structural deflection and strain. Specifically, horizontal single-axis inclinometers were used for deflection monitoring, leveraging the principle of measuring the angle of inclination due to acceleration. Vibrating wire surface strain gauges were used to measure strain changes.
  • Manual Measurement: Traditional engineering instruments like level bars, tower rulers, and levels were used to conduct periodic measurements of deflection and strain at specific points. This served as a validation and supplementary data source.
  • Numerical Simulation: A finite element model of the converter station steel structure and its surrounding geological conditions was created. This model was used to simulate the hoisting process under various conditions, including different temperatures and wind loads, providing a theoretical baseline for comparison.

The data from these three sources are integrated into the real-time structural monitoring system. This system then processes the data to generate real-time, two- and three-dimensional visualizations of the structure's mechanical behavior, including deflection, stress, strain, wind force, and temperature. This allows for immediate analysis and decision-making.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected during the hoisting of the longest long-span converter station steel structure in the world, located in South China. This involved:

  • Real-time sensor data: Collected from inclinometers and strain gauges installed on the structure during the hoisting process.
  • Manual survey data: Collected periodically using traditional surveying instruments.
  • Numerical simulation data: Generated from a finite element model of the structure and its environment.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses real-world data from a specific, large-scale project for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Monitoring is Crucial: The paper strongly advocates for a combined approach of automatic monitoring, manual measurement, and numerical simulation. Each method has its strengths and weaknesses, and their integration provides a more robust and reliable understanding of structural behavior.
  • Real-time Visualization is Key for Safety: The development of a system that visualizes structural changes in real-time is paramount for immediate risk assessment and timely intervention. This moves beyond post-processing of data to proactive safety management.
  • Deflection is a Critical Indicator: The study highlights that the centerline deflection of the long-span structure under maximum load is the most critical area for monitoring, as it represents the highest risk of engineering disasters.
  • Hoisting Point Design is Paramount: For multi-point hoisting, the design of the hoisting points and the stress monitoring at these locations under maximum load are identified as the most important design aspects for future projects.
  • Efficiency Gains: The proposed real-time system significantly reduces data processing time (7 minutes vs. 9 days for routine monitoring), enabling faster decision-making and reducing project delays.

Key Results

  • The real-time structural monitoring system successfully integrated data from automatic monitoring, manual measurement, and numerical simulation, showing good agreement between the different methods.
  • The maximum deflection was consistently observed at the center of the long-span structure, with values reaching up to 175.8 mm during the third hoisting stage.
  • Maximum stress values were found at the ends of the structure, near the hoisting points, with values around 147.4 MPa in the first stage.
  • The system demonstrated its ability to monitor changes in deflection, stress, strain, temperature, and wind force in real-time during the 6-hour hoisting process.
  • The structure was found to be capable of withstanding super typhoons (Level 17) with a maximum deformation of 77.97 mm, well within the allowable limit of 180 mm.
  • The system's processing time for monitoring results was significantly reduced to 7 minutes, compared to 9 days for traditional methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Environmental Factors: While the study considered temperature and wind, the paper acknowledges that numerical simulations may not fully capture all field environment factors, potentially leading to errors.
  • Sensor Limitations: The paper mentions the complexity of instrument installation and potential for errors, suggesting that further refinement in installation procedures could be beneficial.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the real-time monitoring system can be expanded to monitor other parameters like bending moment and load by changing the monitoring instruments. They also propose its application to other large-span structures like gymnasiums, cinemas, and airports, providing further experience and guidance for future construction projects.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the process of using a long-span converter station steel structure, engineering disasters can easily occur. Structural monitoring is an important method to reduce hoisting risk. In previous engineering cases, the structural monitoring of long-span converter station steel structure hoisting is rare. Thus, no relevant hoisting experience can be referenced. Traditional monitoring methods have a small scope of application, making it difficult to coordinate monitoring and construction control. In the monitoring process, many problems arise, such as complicated installation processes, large-scale data processing, and large-scale installation errors. With a real-time structural monitoring system, the mechanical changes in the long-span converter station steel structure during the hoisting process can be monitored in real-time in order to achieve real-time warning of engineering disasters, timely identification of engineering issues, and allow for rapid decision-making, thus avoiding the occurrence of engineering disasters. Based on this concept, automatic monitoring and manual measurement of the mechanical changes in the longest long-span converter station steel structure in the world is carried out, and the monitoring results were compared with the corresponding numerical simulation results in order to develop a real-time structural monitoring system for the whole long-span converter station steel structure's multi-point lifting process. This approach collects the monitoring data and outputs the deflection, stress, strain, wind force, and temperature of the long-span converter station steel structure in real-time, enabling real-time monitoring to ensure the safety of the lifting process. This research offers a new method and basis for the structural monitoring of the multi-point hoisting of a long-span converter station steel structure.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yunfeng2021real,
  author = {Zhu Yunfeng and Yi Gao and Qinghe Zeng and Jin Liao and Zhen Liu and Cuiying Zhou},
  title = {{Real-Time Structural Monitoring of the Multi-Point Hoisting of a Long-Span Converter Station Steel Structure}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21144737},
}
Figure