Real-time observation of two distinctive non-thermalized hot electron dynamics at MXene/molecule interfaces

Qi Zhang, Wei Li, Ruixuan Zhao, Peizhe Tang, Jie Zhao, Guorong Wu, Xin Chen, Mingjun Hu, Kaijun Yuan, Jiebo Li, Xueming YangNature Communications 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully captured the "non-thermalized" behavior of hot electrons at MXene/molecule interfaces, identifying two distinct pathways—direct electron transfer and ultrafast heating—that occur in under 125 femtoseconds. This discovery challenges the conventional wisdom that electron transfer only happens after thermalization and opens new doors for designing high-efficiency photocatalysts and thermal management systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of plasmonic photocatalysis, light hits a material (usually a metal) and generates "hot electrons." These electrons are initially "non-thermalized," meaning they have high energy but haven't yet settled into a stable temperature distribution through scattering.

The grand challenge has been that this non-thermalized state is incredibly fleeting, typically lasting less than 125 femtoseconds (fs). Conventional wisdom suggested that interfacial electron transfer mostly happens after these electrons thermalize. However, if we could harness electrons while they are still in their "hot," non-thermalized state, we could potentially drive chemical reactions much more efficiently. Until now, capturing the real-time dynamics of both the electrons and the attached molecules during this blink-of-an-eye window has been nearly impossible.

Methods

The team utilized femtosecond time-resolved pump-probe spectroscopy.

  • The "Pump": A wavelength-switchable laser pulse excites the MXene ($Ti_3C_2T_x$) nanosheets, creating hot electron-hole pairs.
  • The "Probe": A super-continuous white light pulse monitors the response of both the MXene and the adsorbed molecules at various time delays.
  • Innovation: By subtracting the signal of the bare MXene from the MXene/molecule complex (Subtracted Transient Absorption, or STA), they isolated the specific molecular response to the hot electrons.

They complemented these experiments with First-principles Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to model charge density differences and the "Density of States" (DOS), providing a theoretical backbone for the observed physical pathways.

Datasets

As an experimental physical chemistry paper, it does not use large-scale training datasets. Instead, it relies on:

  • Experimental Spectra: Transient absorption data for MXene combined with various dye molecules: Methylene Blue (MB), Rhodamine 6G (R6G), Rhodamine B (RhB), Sulfarhodamine 101 (SR), and Crystal Violet (CV).
  • Characterization Data: TEM and steady-state absorption spectra to confirm the ~2 nm thickness and quality of the $Ti_3C_2T_x$ MXene nanosheets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two Distinct Pathways: The researchers identified two ways non-thermalized energy moves across the interface:
  • Pathway I: Non-thermalized Electron Transfer (NET). Electrons jump directly from the MXene to the molecule within 50 fs, bypassing the usual electron-electron scattering process.
  • Pathway II: Non-thermalized Electron-Induced Heat Transfer (NEIHT). Electrons scatter at the interface, instantly heating the adsorbed molecules within 125 fs.
  • The Energy Gap Rule: Whether the system chooses Pathway I or II depends on the energy gap ($\Delta E$) between the MXene and the molecule relative to the photon energy ($E_{hv}$). If $E_{hv} > \Delta E$, transfer dominates. If $E_{hv} < \Delta E$, heating dominates.
  • MXenes vs. Noble Metals: Unlike gold or silver, MXenes have strong interfacial interactions and a unique electronic structure that prevents hot electrons from losing energy to the bulk material too quickly, making these ultrafast pathways observable and potentially useful.
  • Ultrafast Heating: Pathway II represents a "new" heat transfer channel that is an order of magnitude faster than conventional phonon-mediated heat transfer, which usually takes several picoseconds.

Key Results

  • Speed: NET occurs within 50 fs, while NEIHT occurs within 125 fs.
  • Efficiency: In the MXene/MB system (where energies match), direct electron transfer is the dominant early-stage process.
  • Non-Decay Component (NDC): The researchers found a persistent signal in the R6G system that doesn't decay like typical electronic signals, confirming that the energy was converted into heat (vibrational energy) in the molecule.
  • DFT Validation: Calculations showed high adsorption energies ($\geq 3.7$ eV) and very short interfacial distances ($\sim 2$ Å), which facilitate the strong electronic coupling necessary for these "non-thermalized" events.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Surface Chemistry: The study primarily focused on oxygen-terminated MXenes. Since MXene properties change drastically with different surface groups (-F, -OH), future work could explore how these terminations tune the NET/NEIHT balance.
  • Material Scope: While $Ti_3C_2T_x$ is the most common MXene, there are dozens of others. Testing these pathways across different MXene chemistries could reveal even more efficient "hot" electron donors.
  • Practical Catalysis: The paper provides the fundamental "how," but the next step is applying these insights to design actual photocatalytic systems for hydrogen production or CO2 reduction that specifically exploit the <50 fs transfer window.

Summary updated

Abstract

The photoinduced non-thermalized hot electrons at an interface play a pivotal role in determining plasmonic driven chemical events. However, understanding non-thermalized electron dynamics, which precedes electron thermalization (~125 fs), remains a grand challenge. Herein, we simultaneously captured the dynamics of both molecules and non-thermalized electrons in the MXene/molecule complexes by femtosecond time-resolved spectroscopy. The real-time observation allows for distinguishing non-thermalized and thermalized electron responses. Differing from the thermalized electron/heat transfer, our results reveal two non-thermalized electron dynamical pathways: (i) the non-thermalized electrons directly transfer to attached molecules at an interface within 50 fs; (ii) the non-thermalized electrons scatter at the interface within 125 fs, inducing adsorbed molecules heating. These two distinctive pathways are dependent on the irradiating wavelength and the energy difference between MXene and adsorbed molecules. This research sheds light on the fundamental mechanism and opens opportunities in photocatalysis and interfacial heat transfer theory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024real,
  author = {Qi Zhang and Wei Li and Ruixuan Zhao and Peizhe Tang and Jie Zhao and Guorong Wu and Xin Chen and Mingjun Hu and Kaijun Yuan and Jiebo Li and Xueming Yang},
  title = {{Real-time observation of two distinctive non-thermalized hot electron dynamics at MXene/molecule interfaces}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-48842-9},
}
Figure