Abstract: The hydrophobic interaction drives nonpolar solutes to aggregate in aqueous solution, and hence plays a critical role in many fundamental processes in nature. An important property intrinsic to hydrophobic interaction is its cooperative nature, which is originated from the collective motions of water hydrogen bond networks surrounding hydrophobic solutes. This property is widely believed to enhance the formation of hydrophobic core in proteins. However, cooperativity in hydrophobic interactions has not been successfully characterized by experiments. Here, we quantify cooperativity in hydrophobic interactions by real-time monitoring the aggregation of hydrophobic solute (hexaphenylsilole, HPS) in a microfluidic mixer. We show that association of a HPS molecule to its aggregate in water occurs at sub-microsecond, and the free energy change is -5.8 to -13.6 kcal mol<sup>-1</sup>. Most strikingly, we discover that cooperativity constitutes up to 40% of this free energy. Our results provide quantitative evidence for the critical role of cooperativity in hydrophobic interactions.
Introduction
The hydrophobic effect is a fundamental force in nature, responsible for phenomena ranging from the separation of oil and water to the complex folding of proteins. While it is widely understood that nonpolar solutes aggregate in aqueous solutions to minimize their contact with water, the underlying mechanics—specifically the role of cooperativity—have long remained elusive to experimental quantification. Cooperativity refers to the idea that as hydrophobic molecules cluster, they disrupt the surrounding water's hydrogen-bond network in a way that facilitates the addition of subsequent molecules.
The Challenge of Hydrophobic Cooperativity
For decades, the "cooperative" nature of the hydrophobic effect has been a cornerstone of structural biology theory. It is believed to be the primary engine driving the formation of hydrophobic cores in proteins. However, capturing this process in real-time is exceptionally difficult. Hydrophobic aggregation occurs at nanometer scales and sub-microsecond timescales, making it nearly impossible to isolate and measure using traditional laboratory techniques. While computer simulations have provided strong support for the existence of cooperativity, experimental evidence has been lacking—until now.
Experimental Design
To overcome these challenges, researchers developed a novel experimental platform combining high-speed microfluidics with specialized light-emitting molecules.
The study utilized hexaphenylsilole (HPS), a highly hydrophobic molecule that exhibits Aggregation-Induced Emission (AIE). HPS is non-fluorescent when dissolved but glows brightly upon aggregation, serving as a real-time sensor for the clumping process. To trigger and monitor this aggregation, the team used a state-of-the-art microfluidic mixer capable of sub-microsecond resolution. By "sheathing" a tiny stream of HPS in water, they could observe the rapid transition from individual molecules to aggregates. The resulting fluorescence data were then fitted to a Classical Nucleation-Growth (CNT) model to extract thermodynamic and kinetic parameters.
Key Findings
The most significant discovery of this research is the quantification of the cooperative contribution to the hydrophobic effect. The researchers found that cooperativity is not merely a minor factor; it accounts for up to 40% of the total free energy driving aggregation.
The free energy change for an HPS molecule joining an aggregate in pure water was measured between -5.8 and -13.6 kcal/mol. Crucially, the strength of the cooperative effect (Qn) increases as the aggregate grows, reaching approximately 4.2 kcal/mol for a cluster of 50 molecules. This confirms that the collective behavior of water molecules is a massive driver of molecular assembly.
Furthermore, the study confirmed a theoretical "crossover point" in hydrophobic logic. For very small clusters, the energy is volume-dependent, but for larger aggregates (above ~1 nm), it becomes surface-area-dependent. The calculated hydrophobic free energy per unit of surface area (18.1 cal mol⁻¹Å⁻²) aligns closely with theoretical estimates for hydrocarbons.
Implications and Future Directions
The speed of these interactions is also noteworthy. The attachment of a single molecule to a cluster occurs within tens to hundreds of nanoseconds. This is significantly faster than the overall folding of a protein, which typically takes milliseconds, suggesting that "hydrophobic collapse" is the initial, lightning-fast step in protein assembly.
While this study provides a breakthrough in quantifying hydrophobic cooperativity, it also opens new avenues for research. HPS is a rigid molecule, whereas protein chains are flexible; future work must explore how the entropy of flexible chains affects these cooperative forces. Additionally, understanding how hydrophobic cooperativity interacts with other forces, such as hydrogen bonding in alpha-helices, and how these processes respond to temperature changes will be critical for a complete picture of biological self-assembly.
Summary updated