Real and Imagined Geography at City-Scale: Sentiment Analysis of Chicago's "One Book" Program

Ana Lucic, John ShanahanDH 2017

Does a book’s setting influence its popularity among local readers? This study investigates the "One Book One Chicago" (OBOC) program by combining library circulation data with sentiment analysis to determine if Chicago-centric narratives resonate differently across the city’s 79 library branches. The findings suggest that "reading local" is a measurable phenomenon influenced by both geography and the linguistic sentiment of the text.

The Problem of Place in Narrative Success

A long-standing debate in digital humanities concerns whether the specific setting of a story impacts its success. While some scholars theorize that certain spaces are predisposed to specific narrative outcomes, others suggest that while a general "city" setting matters, the specific city does not significantly impact a book's bestseller status. This research tests these theories at a granular, city-scale level using the Chicago Public Library’s (CPL) OBOC program to see if readers engage more with books featuring their own neighborhoods.

Methodology

The study employs a multi-disciplinary approach:

  1. Circulation Analysis: One year of circulation data for six OBOC titles was collected and normalized to "checkouts per 1,000 visitors" to account for varying library sizes.
  2. Statistical Testing: The Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used to determine the significance of circulation differences between Chicago-centric and non-Chicago-centric books.
  3. NLP Pipeline: Using NLTK for tokenization, Stanford NER for location identification, and Stanford sentiment analysis to score sentences on a 5-point scale.

The dataset includes anonymized records from 79 CPL branches. Chicago-centered books analyzed include The Adventures of Augie March, The Warmth of Other Suns, and The Third Coast. Non-Chicago books include The Book Thief, The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay, and Gold Boy, Emerald Girl.

Key Results and Insights

The Wilcoxon signed-rank test yielded a p-value < .01, indicating that the difference in circulation between local and non-local books is statistically significant. The circulation of Chicago-related books follows a positively skewed distribution, suggesting that local interest is concentrated and specific rather than uniform.

Difference in checkouts per 1000 visitors across 79 Chicago public library branches.

As shown in the figure above, while some branches saw negligible differences, others exhibited a strong "local preference" (positive difference) or a preference for non-local titles. This variance suggests that geography acts as a proxy for identity, where readers in specific neighborhoods engage differently with books set in their areas.

Furthermore, sentiment analysis of sentences containing the word "Chicago" revealed a remarkably consistent profile across different genres. Most mentions were neutral or negative, suggesting a consistent "linguistic register" for the city regardless of whether the book is a novel or a historical account.

Sentiment association of sentences containing the word 'Chicago' in three local titles.

The sentiment distribution shows that "Negative" and "Neutral" sentiments predominate, with very few "Very Positive" mentions. This consistency across diverse titles suggests that the way Chicago is written about follows a stable pattern in literary geography.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study currently faces limitations regarding keyword specificity, as it only looks for the word "Chicago" and misses specific neighborhood or street names. Future work will utilize Open Street Maps and GeoNames for more granular spatial sentiment analysis. Additionally, the researchers plan to expand the sample size and correlate circulation patterns with socioeconomic data from the American Community Survey to see if factors like income or education influence the "reading local" effect.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{lucic2017real,
  author = {Ana Lucic and John Shanahan},
  title = {{Real and Imagined Geography at City-Scale: Sentiment Analysis of Chicago's "One Book" Program}},
  booktitle = {DH},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure