Reading Game Sport from the Perspective of Sociology of Knowledge

Peng Shao, Han Yu, Zimu XuJournal of Environmental and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how digital reading, driven by media technology, is reshaping reading habits and social behavior. It argues that while digital reading offers convenience, it may not be conducive to the deep transmission and production of "sustainable knowledge," potentially increasing anxiety and superficial engagement. The authors propose that a balance between traditional and digital reading is crucial for fostering genuine knowledge acquisition and cultural inheritance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid evolution of media technology has dramatically altered how people read, moving from traditional paper-based methods to digital platforms. This shift has raised concerns about its impact on reading habits, social behavior, and, crucially, the acquisition and transmission of "sustainable knowledge." The paper addresses the gap in understanding how these technological changes influence readers' cognition, identity, and their ability to build and retain knowledge in a meaningful way. Specifically, it questions whether the current digital reading mode, characterized by its convenience and "front-stage" performance, is truly fostering deep learning or merely promoting media consumption, leading to increased reading anxiety and a superficial understanding of complex information.

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining a large-scale electronic questionnaire survey with in-depth interviews.

  • Questionnaire Survey: A survey was conducted with 1,003 readers, drawing on data from the National Reading Survey. The questionnaire was designed to capture various aspects of reading behavior, including reading time, content preferences, reading motivation, and the reading environment. It also specifically assessed reading anxiety, sustainable knowledge anxiety (related to technological change and social competition), and basic demographic information. The data was analyzed using SPSS 21.
  • In-depth Interviews: Three rounds of deep interviews were conducted with 22 readers who reported having established reading habits. These interviews aimed to gain a nuanced understanding of individual reading experiences, motivations, and behaviors across different contexts. Each interview lasted 1.5-2 hours, with a total of 66 interviews conducted. The transcripts were analyzed to extract key themes and insights.

The research framework is grounded in activity theory, examining the interplay between the "subject" (reader), "object" (reading content), and "community" (social context of reading), along with "tools" (media) and "rules" (reading principles).

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • 1,003 readers who participated in an electronic questionnaire survey.
  • 22 readers who underwent three rounds of in-depth interviews.
  • Data from the thirteenth to the seventeenth National Reading Survey results were also collected and analyzed.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing reading survey data and media research literature were leveraged.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Digital Reading as "Front-Stage" Performance: Digital reading is increasingly characterized by a performative aspect, where engagement might be more about appearing knowledgeable or up-to-date rather than deep comprehension.
  • Rise of Reading Anxiety: Both general reading anxiety and "sustainable knowledge anxiety" are on the rise, fueled by rapid technological change and social competition, leading to feelings of inadequacy and being left behind.
  • Digital Reading as Media Consumption: The current digital reading mode, while convenient, is seen as more akin to media consumption than a process conducive to the transmission and production of sustainable knowledge.
  • The "Global Brain" Vision: The authors envision a future where technology facilitates a "global brain," enabling infinite storage of human wisdom and better inheritance of sustainable knowledge.
  • Divergent Reading Functions: Reading can be categorized by media (traditional vs. digital), function (social, shared, sustainable knowledge, recreational), and style (fragmented, systematic, professional), each serving different reader needs.
  • Traditional Reading's Enduring Value: Traditional reading is associated with a "ritual sense" and "tactile sense," offering a focused, less distracting experience that is crucial for deep knowledge acquisition and cultural inheritance.
  • Social Dimension of Reading: Reading is not just for personal enrichment but also serves as a vital tool for social interaction and staying connected with societal changes.

Key Results

  • Gender and Age Differences: While male and female readers show similarities in traditional reading, males engage in digital reading more frequently and for longer durations. Younger age groups (20-29) spend less time reading overall and are more likely to read on paper.
  • Content Preferences: Current affairs news and entertainment information are the most preferred reading content, followed by life information.
  • Anxiety Correlation: Readers who spend less than 1 hour a day on digital reading, and those who spend more than 3 hours, exhibit higher levels of anxiety compared to those reading for 2-3 hours.
  • Media Choice: Readers consciously choose reading media (traditional or digital) based on their specific reading context and needs. Traditional reading is often linked to a "ritual sense," while digital reading offers accessibility and timeliness.
  • Social Disconnection Fear: A significant portion of readers (82%) feel they would "lose themselves" and feel empty if they stopped reading for a long time, with 36% mentioning "social disconnection."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Digital Reading: The paper highlights that digital reading, with its emphasis on convenience and curated content, can lead to a superficial understanding and potentially weaken independent thinking. It also raises concerns about how interest groups can construct readers' cognition and values through digital platforms, which can be detrimental to cultural inheritance.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that the wisdom of human symbiosis, facilitated by technological advancement, will lead to an era of the "global brain." This future aims to better inherit sustainable knowledge and revitalize its production, implying a need for continued research into how technology can best serve these goals. The paper also implicitly calls for a balanced approach to reading, integrating the strengths of both traditional and digital methods to foster a more robust and meaningful knowledge acquisition process.

Summary updated

Abstract

The evolution of media technology has not only changed readers' reading ways and reading habits but also tried to reshape their social behaviour. From the perspective of sociology of sustainable knowledge, this essay explores the impacts of technological change on reading through the framework of activity theory. It is found that digital reading is of increasing characteristics of "front stage" performance and reading anxiety in society, and sustainable knowledge anxiety began to spread. The research shows that the existing digital reading mode is actually the consumption of media, which is not conducive to the transmission and production of sustainable knowledge. Also, with the further development of technology, reading will open up a new chapter. The wisdom of human symbiosis will be infinitely stored and strive toward the era of global brain, which will help to better inherit sustainable knowledge and activate the vitality of sustainable knowledge production.
BibTeX
@article{shao2022reading,
  author = {Peng Shao and Han Yu and Zimu Xu},
  title = {{Reading Game Sport from the Perspective of Sociology of Knowledge}},
  journal = {Journal of Environmental and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1155/2022/3711900},
}
Figure