Reactive Power and Voltage Optimization of New-Energy Grid Based on the Improved Flower Pollination Algorithm

Hao He, Jia Li, Weizhe Zhao, Boyang Li, Yalong LiEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an improved Flower Pollination Algorithm (FPA) designed to optimize reactive power and voltage in power grids with a high penetration of new energy sources. By combining continuous and discrete optimization capabilities and incorporating a tournament selection mechanism, the proposed method effectively reduces network losses and improves voltage stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar power into the grid presents significant challenges for maintaining stable voltage levels and minimizing energy losses. These new energy sources often have intermittent outputs, leading to voltage fluctuations, increased network losses, and a reduced dynamic reactive power regulation margin. Traditional optimization methods struggle to handle the complex interplay of continuous and discrete variables involved in controlling reactive power from various sources (e.g., SVCs, new energy units, thermal power units) and discrete components (e.g., capacitor banks, transformer taps). This paper aims to address this by developing a robust optimization framework that can effectively manage these challenges.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of an Improved Continuous-Discrete Hybrid Flower Pollination Algorithm (FPA). Here's a breakdown of the key methodological contributions:

  • Optimization Model: A comprehensive optimization model is established with three objectives: minimizing voltage deviation, minimizing network loss, and maximizing the dynamic reactive power margin. This model considers the reactive power regulation capabilities of both Static Var Compensators (SVCs) and new energy units.
  • Hybrid FPA: The traditional FPA, which is primarily designed for continuous variables, is adapted to handle both continuous and discrete variables. This involves redefining concepts within the FPA framework and developing specific discrete change strategies for global and local pollination processes.
  • Tournament Selection Mechanism: To accelerate convergence and improve the algorithm's ability to find the global optimum, a tournament selection mechanism is integrated. This mechanism helps in selecting fitter individuals for the next generation, preventing premature convergence to local optima.
  • Power Flow Calculation: The Newton-Raphson algorithm is employed to calculate the steady-state power flow distribution of the power grid, which is essential for evaluating the objective functions and constraints.

Datasets

The proposed method is evaluated using the IEEE-39 bus system. This is a standard benchmark system in power systems research. The paper provides specific details on the topology, the access location and capacity of new energy units (wind power and PV), and the parameters of SVCs and capacitor banks within this system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Optimization: The paper demonstrates that a single, well-defined optimization model encompassing voltage deviation, network loss, and dynamic reactive power margin can effectively address the challenges posed by new energy integration.
  • Hybrid Algorithm Necessity: The inherent mix of continuous (e.g., reactive power output) and discrete (e.g., capacitor bank switching, transformer tap positions) variables in power system optimization necessitates hybrid algorithms. The proposed continuous-discrete hybrid FPA offers a viable solution.
  • Tournament Selection's Impact: The inclusion of a tournament selection mechanism significantly enhances the convergence speed and accuracy of the FPA, making it more efficient in finding optimal solutions and avoiding local optima.
  • FPA's Suitability: The study highlights that FPA, when appropriately modified, is a powerful tool for complex optimization problems in power systems, outperforming traditional methods like Genetic Algorithms (GA) in certain aspects.

Key Results

The improved continuous-discrete hybrid FPA was applied to the IEEE-39 bus system, yielding significant improvements:

  • Network Loss Reduction: Network loss was reduced from 143.402 MW (2.1%) to 120.934 MW (1.8%), a decrease of 22.468 MW.
  • Reactive Power Margin Increase: The dynamic reactive power margin of SVCs increased substantially from 285.2146 MVar to 588.4398 MVar, more than doubling the capacity to handle voltage fluctuations.
  • Voltage Stability: The optimization successfully brought most bus voltages within the acceptable operating limits (0.94 p.u. to 1.1 p.u.), which were exceeded in the initial state.
  • Comparison with GA: The improved FPA demonstrated superior performance compared to a classical Genetic Algorithm (GA), achieving a better optimal fitness value (2.3333 vs. 3.1683) and avoiding local optimization issues that plagued GA. The improved FPA converged faster, reaching its optimal solution in fewer iterations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper acknowledges that it primarily focuses on the global reactive power optimization at the system level.
  • It does not delve into the internal characteristics or detailed models of individual reactive power compensation equipment and new energy generating units.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest further research into the internal models and voltage control at the equipment level. This would involve a more granular approach to optimization, considering the specific operational characteristics of each component.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to solve the reactive power and voltage control problem caused by the high proportion of new energy connected to the power grid, this paper takes the minimum voltage deviation, minimum network loss and maximum dynamic reactive power margin of the whole system as the comprehensive optimization objectives and establishes a reactive power and voltage optimization model by considering the reactive power regulation ability of SVC (Static Var Compensator) and new energy units. In view of the continuous and discrete variables in the model, the traditional continuous FPA (Flower Pollination Algorithm) is discretized to form an improved continuous-discrete hybrid FPA, and the tournament selection mechanism is adopted to speed up the convergence. Through the example analysis of the IEEE-39 bus system, the feasibility of the proposed reactive power and voltage optimal control method in the new energy grid is verified. Compared with GA (Genetic Algorithm), the results show that the improved FPA has high optimization accuracy, which is suitable for solving the reactive power and voltage optimization problem of the new energy grid.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2022reactive,
  author = {Hao He and Jia Li and Weizhe Zhao and Boyang Li and Yalong Li},
  title = {{Reactive Power and Voltage Optimization of New-Energy Grid Based on the Improved Flower Pollination Algorithm}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15103653},
}
Figure