Re-Evaluation of the Impacts of Dietary Preferences on Macroinvertebrate Trophic Sources: An Analysis of Seaweed Bed Habitats Using the Integration of Stable Isotope and Observational Data

Xijie Zhou, Yumeng Liu, Kai Wang, Jing Zhao, Zhao Xu, Shouyu ZhangSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new dietary process-based stable isotope mixing model (D-SIMM) that accounts for species-specific dietary preferences and the possibility of zero contribution from certain food sources. By integrating lab-based observations with traditional stable isotope analysis, D-SIMM provides a more ecologically realistic and robust estimation of trophic contributions in complex food webs, particularly in seaweed bed habitats.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding food web structures and energy flow is crucial for ecological research and conservation. Stable isotope mixing models (SIMMs) are widely used to estimate the contribution of different food sources to consumers. However, traditional SIMMs, based on the Dirichlet distribution, assume that all potential food sources contribute to a consumer's diet (i.e., no "zero contribution" scenario). This assumption can lead to biased estimations, especially when consumers exhibit strong dietary preferences or avoid certain food sources. The paper addresses this gap by developing and validating a new model, D-SIMM, that explicitly incorporates species-specific dietary preferences and allows for the exclusion of non-contributing food sources, thereby improving the accuracy and ecological relevance of trophic analyses.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Lab-based Diet Selection and Discrimination Experiments:
    • Diet Selection: Macroinvertebrates (sea urchins, gastropods, mussels) were housed in controlled feeding tanks with single potential food sources (macroalgae, phytoplankton, sediment organic matter, etc.). Mortality rates were used to classify food sources as "favorable" (low mortality), "neutral" (moderate mortality), or "unavailable" (high mortality), effectively identifying species-specific dietary preferences and potential zero-contribution sources.
  2. Discrimination Factors: Lab experiments were conducted to determine species-specific "discrimination factors" (also known as trophic enrichment factors or fractionation values), which represent the isotopic shift between a consumer and its diet. This is crucial because these factors can vary between species and their food sources.
  3. Dietary Process-Based Stable Isotope Mixing Model (D-SIMM):
    • This novel model integrates the results from the lab-based diet selection and discrimination experiments with traditional stable isotope mixing models (specifically, the MixSIAR Bayesian framework).
  4. D-SIMM allows for the inclusion of species-specific discrimination factors and, critically, the exclusion of food sources identified as "unavailable" in the diet selection experiments (i.e., setting their contribution to zero).
  5. The model uses Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) simulations to estimate posterior probability distributions of trophic contributions.

Datasets

The study utilized field samples collected from the Gouqi Island seaweed bed (GISB) in the East China Sea.

  • Potential Food Sources: Macroalgae (MAC), sedimentary organic matter (SOM), suspended particulate organic matter (SPOM), and benthic particulate organic matter (BPOM) were sampled seasonally from May 2013 to May 2015.
  • Consumers: Three representative macroinvertebrate species were collected: sea urchin (Anthocidaris crassispina), gastropod (Turbo cornutus), and mussel (Septifer virgatus).
  • Stable Isotope Data: Carbon (δ¹³C) and nitrogen (δ¹⁵N) stable isotope ratios were measured for all sampled food sources and consumer tissues.
  • Dietary Observation Data: Lab-based experiments provided qualitative data on species-specific food preferences and availability.

This study did not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather integrated existing sampling and analytical techniques with novel experimental data to inform a new modeling framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dietary Preferences Matter: The study strongly emphasizes that ignoring species-specific dietary preferences leads to significant overestimation of trophic niche space and source diversity. Consumers are not simply generalists; their choices actively shape the food web structure.
  • Zero Contribution is Real: The traditional SIMM assumption that all potential sources contribute is flawed. D-SIMM's ability to incorporate "zero contribution" scenarios is a critical advancement for realistic food web modeling.
  • Species-Specific Discrimination: Trophic enrichment factors are not universal. They vary significantly between consumer species and their specific diets, necessitating lab-based determination for accurate modeling.
  • Seaweed Beds as Foundational Ecosystems: The research highlights the crucial role of macroalgae (MAC) and their detritus in supporting the primary consumers (gastropods, sea urchins, mussels) in seaweed bed habitats, underscoring their importance for ecosystem health and sustainable resource management.

Key Results

  • Significant Differences between SIMM and D-SIMM: The study found substantial differences in trophic contribution estimations between the traditional SIMM and the new D-SIMM. These differences were evident in measures of isotopic niche width (TA, SEA, SEAC) and the estimated proportions of dietary sources.
  • D-SIMM is More Precise: The Deviance Information Criterion (DIC) values indicated that D-SIMM provided a more precise and ecologically robust model for diet proportion estimation compared to SIMM.
  • Dominant Trophic Pathways:
    • For gastropods and sea urchins, macroalgae (MAC) and sedimentary organic matter (SOMA) were the primary dietary sources, collectively accounting for over 90% of their diet.
  • For mussels, benthic particulate organic matter (BPOM) was the main dietary source, followed by SOMA.
  • Macroalgae as Basal Resource: The high coverage of MAC in seaweed beds and its significant contribution to SOM, combined with the direct consumption of MAC by consumers, strongly suggests that MAC and its detritus form the basal trophic resources for the studied macroinvertebrates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Stable Isotope Turnover Time: The authors acknowledge the limitation of not having species-specific stable isotope turnover time information. They used muscle and gonad tissues to represent a long period, assuming observed values were representative of average annual interactions. Future work could incorporate dynamic models that account for seasonal variations in diet and isotope turnover.
  • Experimental Scope: While the study focused on three representative species, future research could expand to include a wider range of macroinvertebrates and other trophic levels to build a more comprehensive food web model.
  • Generalizability of D-SIMM: The success of D-SIMM in this study suggests its potential applicability to other complex ecosystems where dietary preferences and source exclusion are important factors. Further validation in different environments would be beneficial.
  • Conservation Implications: The findings directly support the need for robust conservation efforts for seaweed beds to ensure the sustainable utilization of associated shellfish resources.

Summary updated

Abstract

Stable isotope analyses of food webs have been used in previous decades to determine trophic sources and food web structures. The use of stable isotope models to estimate consumption contributions is based on a type of multivariate beta distribution called the Dirichlet distribution. The Dirichlet distribution does not conclude the pi = 0 and pi = 1 situation. Thus, scientists have previously assumed that every potential trophic source contributes to consumption in stable isotope models. However, animals have dietary preferences and some trophic resources may not contribute to consumption. Less is known about the effects of species-specific dietary processes on stable isotope analyses, especially in regard to trophic contribution estimation. In this study, we develop methods to determine consumers’ “real potential trophic sources” and “discrimination factors” using lab-based observations and lab-based discrimination experiments. We describe a dietary process-based stable isotope mixing model (D-SIMM) that integrates lab-based dietary preference observations and the stable isotope mixing model (SIMM) to estimate trophic contributions. Then, we present the application of D-SIMM on three representative macroinvertebrate species in our study area (sea urchin: Anthocidaris crassispina (A. crassispina); gastropod: Turbo cornutus (T. cornutus); and mussel: Septifer virgatus (S. virgatus)) to re-evaluate source-consumer contributions. Thus, we compare the differences between the source contribution estimation results of SIMM and D-SIMM by calculating the standardized convex hull area (TA) of species-specific trophic sources and the consumer standard ellipses area (SEA) of the potential trophic source group. Three examples illustrate significant differences in species-specific dietary preferences between consumers, resulting in systematic difference for TA, SEA and trophic source contribution estimation results between SIMM and D-SIMM. As such, D-SIMM explains pi = 0 of certain trophic sources, which often causes uncertainty and is ignored in previous SIMM research. In addition, species-specific discrimination factors should be noticed during trophic source estimation. For estimation of the trophic contribution of source-consumers, our findings imply that the dietary preferences of consumers should be fully considered before SIMM analysis, and that D-SIMM is a more ecological process and robust measure. Additionally, we found high macroalgae (MAC) coverage in seaweed beds and a high detritus contribution of MAC to sedimentary organic matter (SOM). These findings, combined with the high contributions of MAC and SOM to consumers, suggest that MAC and its debris are the basal trophic sources for gastropods, sea urchins and mussels in seaweed bed habitats. The conservation of seaweed beds should be fully considered to ensure sustainable utilization of shellfish.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2018re,
  author = {Xijie Zhou and Yumeng Liu and Kai Wang and Jing Zhao and Zhao Xu and Shouyu Zhang},
  title = {{Re-Evaluation of the Impacts of Dietary Preferences on Macroinvertebrate Trophic Sources: An Analysis of Seaweed Bed Habitats Using the Integration of Stable Isotope and Observational Data}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10062010},
}

Loading related content...

Figure