Re-Evaluating the Value of Ecosystem Based on Carbon Benefit: A Case Study in Chengdu, China

Mengting Dong, Zeyuan Liu, Xiufeng Ni, Zhulin Qi, Wang Jinnan, Qingyu ZhangLand 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study re-evaluates the value of terrestrial ecosystems for carbon neutrality by incorporating indirect benefits like temperature regulation and air purification, not just CO2 uptake. The findings reveal that these regulating services provide significantly more carbon benefit than carbon sinks alone, highlighting the need for policies that enhance overall ecosystem service capacity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving global carbon neutrality commitments relies heavily on terrestrial ecosystems to absorb CO2. However, current carbon accounting primarily focuses on "carbon sinks" (CO2 uptake through photosynthesis) and largely overlooks the crucial, indirect contributions of ecosystem services. Services like temperature regulation (reducing energy demand for cooling) and air purification (removing pollutants, thus reducing energy-intensive industrial processes) can significantly lower CO2 emissions. This oversight leads to an underestimation of the true value of ecosystems in mitigating climate change. Furthermore, the specific drivers influencing these indirect carbon benefits and how they change spatially and temporally remain unclear, hindering effective urban ecosystem management and policy development.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel "carbon benefit (C benefit)" accounting framework that integrates three key ecosystem services:

  • CO2 Sequestration (Qcs): Quantified using a carbon sequestration mechanism model based on Net Ecosystem Productivity (NEP).
  • Temperature Regulation (QTR): Estimated by calculating the CO2 emission reductions achieved by reducing energy consumption for cooling due to ecosystem-induced temperature moderation. This involved modeling energy consumed via evapotranspiration and its associated emissions.
  • Air Purification (QAP): Assessed by estimating CO2 emission reductions from the indirect effect of air purification services, specifically focusing on particulate matter (PM) removal.

The C benefit was then calculated as the sum of these three components. To understand the influencing factors, they employed:

  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): Used to reduce the dimensionality of 10 potential influencing factors (natural and social) and extract key underlying components.
  • Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost): A machine learning algorithm used to predict C benefits for different ecosystem types based on the identified influencing factors.
  • Shapley Additive Explanation (SHAP): Applied to the XGBoost model to interpret the results and explain the influence of individual input factors on the predicted C benefits, addressing the "black box" nature of machine learning models.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets for its analysis:

  • Meteorological observation data: Obtained from the China Meteorological Data Network.
  • Land-use and land-cover change (LUCC) data: Sourced from the GlobeLand30 dataset.
  • Net Primary Productivity (NPP) data: Acquired from the MODIS17A3 dataset.
  • Precipitation (PRE), temperature (TEM), Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), Gross Domestic Product (GDP), and Population (POP) datasets: Sourced from the Resource and Environment Science Data Center.
  • Digital Elevation Model (DEM) data: Obtained from the Geospatial Data Cloud.
  • Soil property data (topsoil and subsoil organic carbon content, pH): Acquired from the Harmonized World Soil Database Version 1.1.

These datasets were processed to a uniform 1 km × 1 km spatial resolution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ecosystems are more than just carbon sinks: The study powerfully demonstrates that the indirect benefits of ecosystem services, particularly temperature regulation, contribute far more to carbon neutrality than direct CO2 uptake. This shifts the paradigm from solely focusing on planting trees to a more holistic view of ecosystem function.
  • Temperature regulation is a hidden climate hero: The significant contribution of temperature regulation services to reducing CO2 emissions was a major finding. This highlights the critical role of green infrastructure in mitigating the urban heat island effect and its downstream impact on energy consumption.
  • Wetlands pack a punch: Surprisingly, wetlands were found to have a higher carbon-neutral capacity per unit area than forests, primarily due to their strong thermoregulatory capabilities. This suggests a strategic re-evaluation of urban green space planning, prioritizing wetlands in land-scarce urban centers.
  • Intensive management can be detrimental: Over-management of constructed ecosystems (e.g., urban parks, landscaping) through regular pruning and fertilization can significantly reduce their carbon benefits. Allowing vegetation to grow more naturally appears to enhance ecosystem services.
  • GDP is a double-edged sword: While economic development (GDP) is often associated with improved environmental management, this study found that higher GDP had a more negative impact on ecosystem C benefits than population density. This is attributed to the increased investment in highly managed, aesthetically focused constructed ecosystems in affluent areas.

Key Results

  • Significant growth in C benefits: Over the 20-year study period (2000-2020) in Chengdu, C benefits showed an average annual growth rate of 0.91 Tg/a, indicating positive trends in ecological conservation efforts.
  • CO2 emissions reduction dwarfs uptake: The CO2 emissions reduction due to ecosystem regulating services (temperature regulation and air purification) was found to be 22.47 times that of carbon sinks. Specifically, QTR and QAP accounted for 95.07% and 0.67% of the total C benefits, respectively, while Qcs was only 4.25%.
  • Terrestrial ecosystems offset a substantial portion of emissions: In Chengdu, terrestrial ecosystems offset approximately 45.41% of anthropogenic CO2 emissions.
  • XGBoost model performance: The XGBoost model demonstrated excellent prediction performance for forests (R²=0.82), grasslands (R²=0.78), and farmlands (R²=0.86), but showed lower performance for wetlands (R²=0.56), likely due to a smaller sample size.
  • Key drivers identified: NDVI positively influenced C benefits, while GDP and population generally had a negative impact. Elevation also played a complex role, with medium altitudes showing higher benefits for grasslands and forests benefiting from increasing elevation up to a certain point.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited scope of ecosystem services: The current framework only includes three regulating services (carbon sequestration, temperature regulation, and air purification). Future work should incorporate a broader range of services like soil conservation and water purification for a more comprehensive assessment.
  • Simplified driver analysis: While 10 factors were analyzed, social and economic activities are complex. Future studies should expand the selection of driver indicators to capture a more nuanced understanding of human impact on ecosystem carbon benefits.
  • Wetland sample size: The lower performance of the XGBoost model for wetlands suggests a need for more extensive data collection and analysis for this ecosystem type.
  • Policy implications: The study strongly advocates for policies that prioritize enhancing overall ecosystem service capacity, including ecological restoration and the strategic use of wetlands in urban planning, rather than solely focusing on increasing carbon sinks. It also suggests avoiding excessive artificial intervention in constructed ecosystems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite the acknowledged importance of terrestrial ecosystems in achieving carbon neutrality, current carbon accounting predominantly focuses on CO2 uptake, neglecting indirect contributions from ecosystem services, such as temperature regulation and air purification. We established a carbon benefit (C benefit) accounting framework that integrated these services and analyzed the drivers influencing the spatial and temporal changes in the C benefit. It was found that the average annual growth rate of C benefits in Chengdu over the past 20 years was 0.91 Tg/a, and the CO2 emissions reduction due to ecosystem services was 22.47 times that of carbon sinks. Therefore, the contribution of ecosystem regulating services to carbon neutrality cannot be ignored. In addition, the elevation, gross domestic product (GDP), and normalized differential vegetation index (NDVI) are key factors affecting C benefits. It is worth noting that the intensive management of constructed ecosystems can result in significant reductions in ecosystem C benefits. Finally, our findings underline the need for low-carbon policies to not only promote carbon sink projects but also enhance the overall capacity of ecosystem services, which could substantially mitigate global climate change.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2023re,
  author = {Mengting Dong and Zeyuan Liu and Xiufeng Ni and Zhulin Qi and Wang Jinnan and Qingyu Zhang},
  title = {{Re-Evaluating the Value of Ecosystem Based on Carbon Benefit: A Case Study in Chengdu, China}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/land12081605},
}
Figure