TL;DR
This study analyzed gender representation in abstracts submitted to the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) annual meetings in 2020 and 2021. While the proportion of female first authors remained stable, a persistent gender gap was observed in senior authorship, suggesting ongoing challenges for women in advancing to leadership positions within neurology.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The field of neurology, like many academic disciplines, has a well-documented gender gap. Previous research has highlighted disparities in invited speaker panels, editorial boards, practice guidelines, and senior authorship. This paper specifically investigates whether this gender gap is reflected in the abstracts accepted for presentation at the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) annual meetings, a significant venue for disseminating new research and showcasing emerging talent. The study also explores whether the COVID-19 pandemic, which disproportionately affected women in academia, had any short-term impact on this representation.
Methods
This study employed a cross-sectional design to analyze accepted abstracts from the 2020 and 2021 AAN annual meetings. The researchers manually reviewed a total of 3,211 abstracts from 2020 and 2,178 from 2021. For each abstract, they collected data on the gender of the first and senior authors. Authors' gender was determined through publicly available information such as academic profiles and social media. Abstracts where gender could not be verified were excluded. The study also categorized abstracts by subspecialty and the origin of the research (domestic, international, or corporate-affiliated). Statistical analysis, primarily using chi-square tests, was used to compare proportions and assess for significant differences between the two years and across different categories.
Datasets
The study utilized the publicly available accepted abstracts from the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) annual meetings for the years 2020 and 2021. These abstracts represent a comprehensive dataset of research presented at a major neurology conference. No new datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Persistent Senior Author Gap: The most striking finding is the continued underrepresentation of women in senior authorship roles, despite a more equitable representation among first authors. This suggests that while women are entering the field and contributing research, they face greater barriers to advancing to senior positions.
- No Significant Pandemic Impact (Short-Term): Contrary to hypotheses, the study did not find a significant change in the proportion of female first or senior authors between 2020 and 2021, a period heavily influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic. This could be due to factors like the blinding of abstracts to reviewers or the shift to virtual meetings, which might have mitigated some of the pandemic's negative impacts on research productivity for women.
- Corporate Affiliation Disparity: Abstracts originating from corporate affiliations showed the lowest percentages of both female first and senior authors, indicating a potential area for targeted intervention to promote gender equity.
- Positive Mentor Effect: The study observed that abstracts with female senior authors had a higher proportion of female first authors, suggesting a positive influence of female mentors in supporting the career progression of junior female researchers.
Key Results
- In both 2020 and 2021, approximately 46% of first authors were female.
- The proportion of female senior authors remained significantly lower, at around 34% in both years.
- When the senior author was female, the proportion of female first authors was 55.3%, compared to 41.6% when the senior author was male.
- Subspecialties with the lowest percentages of female senior authors included oncology (24.7%), sleep (25.5%), and headache (28.7%) in 2020.
- Corporate-affiliated research had the lowest percentages of female first authors (around 34%) and senior authors (around 22-27%).
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Limited Timeframe: The study only analyzed abstracts from two years, making it difficult to establish long-term trends. Future work should involve analyzing abstracts over a longer period, including years before and after the pandemic.
- Manual Gender Verification: Gender was determined through manual verification, which may not capture non-binary individuals and could be subject to error. Future studies could explore more inclusive methods of gender identification.
- Last Author as Senior Author Assumption: The study assumed the last author was the senior author, which may not always be the case.
- Lack of Data on Trainee Status, Race, Ethnicity, and Socioeconomic Status: These factors, which can influence career progression, were not collected.
Future research should aim to address these limitations by expanding the scope of analysis, incorporating more nuanced demographic data, and investigating the underlying systemic factors contributing to the observed gender disparities in senior authorship. The authors also suggest that interventions at institutional and national levels are crucial for reducing the gender gap in academic and clinical research.
Summary updated