Ratiometric Strategy for Electrochemical Sensing of Carbaryl Residue in Water and Vegetable Samples

Min Zhang, Zeyuan Zhang, Yanjing Yang, Yi Zhang, Yufei Wang, Xinyi Chen2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "ratiometric strategy" for electrochemical sensors to accurately detect carbaryl (CBL) pesticide residue. By using a second, stable "reference probe" alongside the target analyte, the sensor can internally correct for environmental noise and electrode variations, leading to significantly improved accuracy and reproducibility compared to traditional single-signal sensors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate detection of pesticide residues like carbaryl (CBL) is crucial for food safety and environmental protection. Traditional electrochemical sensors (ECS) struggle with accuracy due to various interferences: background noise from the equipment, fluctuating environmental conditions (temperature, pH), variations between individual electrodes, and the complex chemical makeup of real-world samples (like vegetables). These factors often lead to unreliable and inconsistent results, making it difficult to trust the measurements. The paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a more robust and accurate sensing method.

Methods

The core innovation is the ratiometric strategy. Instead of relying on a single signal from the target analyte (CBL), this approach uses two signals: one from the target (CBL) and another from a stable reference probe. The key idea is that both the target and the reference probe will be affected similarly by the environmental interferences. By measuring the ratio of their signals, these common interferences can be effectively canceled out, leading to a more accurate measurement of the target analyte.

For this study, Nile blue a (NB) was chosen as the reference probe. It was selected because it has a well-defined electrochemical peak, its signal is minimally affected by CBL, and it remains stable under the experimental conditions. The authors explored different electrochemical techniques, with Square Wave Voltammetry (SWV) proving to be the most effective for obtaining a clear and strong signal.

To further enhance the sensor's performance and address electrode variability, the researchers experimented with two types of electrodes:

  1. Glassy Carbon Electrode (GCE): A standard, well-characterized electrode used to initially demonstrate the ratiometric strategy's effectiveness in mitigating system noise.
  2. Carbon Cloth (CC) modified with Ionic Liquid (IL): A more novel, disposable, and cost-effective electrode. The CC offers a large surface area, and the IL modification enhances conductivity and electrochemical stability. This combination was used to specifically test the ratiometric strategy's ability to overcome electrode-to-electrode variations and matrix effects in real samples.

A crucial step in the sensing process is the hydrolysis of CBL. CBL itself has a poorly defined electrochemical peak. However, under alkaline conditions, it can be hydrolyzed to 1-naphthol, which then undergoes further deprotonation to form a highly electroactive species (a-CBL) with a well-defined oxidation peak at a lower potential. This derivatization step is essential for sensitive detection.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on developing and validating a sensing methodology using synthesized solutions and real-world samples (tomatoes and cabbages).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Ratios: The fundamental insight is that by comparing two signals that are similarly affected by noise, the noise itself can be effectively eliminated. This "inner correction" is a powerful concept for improving sensor reliability.
  • Nile Blue a as a Reliable Partner: The careful selection and validation of Nile blue a as a reference probe were critical. Its stability and minimal interference with the CBL signal were key to the success of the ratiometric approach.
  • Addressing Electrode Diversity: The ratiometric strategy proved particularly effective when using disposable carbon cloth electrodes, which are prone to batch-to-batch variations. The ratio-based measurement significantly reduced the impact of these differences.
  • Simplifying Sample Preparation: For vegetable samples, a simple dichloromethane extraction followed by a quick pH adjustment was sufficient, demonstrating that the ratiometric sensor can work with relatively straightforward sample preparation, reducing complexity compared to some other methods.

Key Results

  • Improved Accuracy and Reproducibility: The ratiometric sensor demonstrated a significantly better linear correlation coefficient (r > 0.99) and lower relative standard deviation (RSD < 10%) compared to traditional single-signal sensors. For example, on GCE, the ratiometric sensor achieved an RSD of 2.8% for system noise, while the single-signal sensor had 7.2%.
  • Lower Limit of Detection (LOD): The ratiometric sensor achieved an LOD of 1.0 µM on GCE, which is better than the single-signal sensor (LOD of 1.0 µM, but with a lower correlation coefficient). On the IL/CC electrode, the LOD was 1.4 µM.
  • Effective in Real Samples: The sensor showed good recovery rates (80-95%) for CBL in tomato and cabbage samples, comparable to or better than other reported sensors.
  • Robustness: The ratiometric strategy was shown to be effective in mitigating system noise, electrode deviation, and to some extent, matrix effects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Matrix Effect in Complex Samples: While the ratiometric strategy improved accuracy, the paper suggests that for highly complex matrices like vegetable samples, a matrix-matching standard solution method played a more significant role in improving recoveries. The authors propose combining both strategies for even better results.
  • Further Optimization: The paper mentions that the ratiometric strategy could be compatible with various modified electrodes to further improve detection performance. This suggests future work could involve exploring a wider range of electrode materials and modifications.
  • Broader Applicability: While demonstrated for carbaryl, the ratiometric strategy itself is a general approach that could potentially be applied to the detection of other analytes where similar challenges with interferences exist.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhang2020ratiometric,
  author = {Min Zhang and Zeyuan Zhang and Yanjing Yang and Yi Zhang and Yufei Wang and Xinyi Chen},
  title = {{Ratiometric Strategy for Electrochemical Sensing of Carbaryl Residue in Water and Vegetable Samples}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20051524},
}

Loading related content...

Figure