Rare meson decays into very light neutralinos

Herbi K. Dreiner, S. Grab, Daniel Koschade, Michael Krämer, Ben O’Leary, Ulrich LangenfeldPhysical 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the possibility of detecting very light or massless neutralinos, hypothetical particles predicted by supersymmetry, through rare meson decays. While minimal flavor violation in the MSSM leads to suppressed signals, the authors show that non-minimal flavor violation could open up new avenues for discovery and constrain the parameter space of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The search for physics beyond the Standard Model (SM) is a major goal in particle physics. Supersymmetry (SUSY) is a leading candidate, predicting superpartners for known particles. The lightest supersymmetric particle (LSP), often a neutralino, is a potential dark matter candidate. However, direct searches for sparticles have so far yielded no definitive evidence, leading to lower bounds on their masses. This paper investigates whether rare meson decays, which are highly sensitive to new physics, can provide constraints on the mass of very light neutralinos, particularly those with masses close to zero. The challenge is that existing experimental searches and theoretical calculations have not fully explored the parameter space of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM), especially concerning non-minimal flavor violation, which could significantly alter the expected decay rates.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of theoretical calculations and phenomenological analysis. They derive explicit formulas for the tree-level decays of pseudoscalar and vector mesons into a pair of light neutralinos ($M \to \chi_1^0 \chi_1^0$). Crucially, they perform the first complete calculation of loop-induced decays, specifically $K^- \to \pi^- \chi_1^0 \chi_1^0$ and $B^- \to K^- \chi_1^0 \chi_1^0$, within the MSSM. They consider two scenarios:

  1. Minimal Flavor Violation (MFV): This scenario assumes that all flavor-violating transitions are governed by the SM's CKM matrix.
  2. Non-Minimal Flavor Violation (NMFV): This scenario allows for additional sources of flavor violation, such as those arising from the squark mass matrices in the MSSM, and is analyzed using the mass insertion approximation.

They also comment on direct searches for light neutralinos at hadron colliders (Tevatron and LHC) through monojet signatures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on existing experimental data for branching ratios and upper bounds on meson decays, as well as theoretical parameters from established SM and MSSM benchmarks (e.g., Snowmass points).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Massless Neutralinos are Possible: The paper confirms that within the MSSM, it's possible to have a massless neutralino by carefully choosing the gaugino mass parameters $M_1$ and $M_2$.
  • MFV Suppresses Signals: Under the assumption of Minimal Flavor Violation, the branching ratios for rare meson decays into neutralinos are found to be extremely small, several orders of magnitude below SM processes involving neutrinos. This means MFV scenarios provide no significant constraints on the neutralino mass.
  • NMFV is Key for Discovery: The authors highlight that non-minimal flavor violation can significantly enhance the branching ratios for $K$ and $B$ meson decays into neutralinos, potentially making them observable.
  • New Constraints from NMFV: By considering NMFV, the paper derives new constraints on the MSSM parameter space, particularly concerning the mass insertion parameters that govern flavor-violating interactions.
  • Future Experiments are Crucial: While current experiments are not sensitive to these decays, future kaon and $B$ meson experiments, as well as searches at the LHC, hold promise for probing these scenarios.

Key Results

  • Suppressed Branching Ratios (MFV): For MFV scenarios, the calculated branching ratios for decays like $\pi^0 \to \chi_1^0 \chi_1^0$ are extremely small, on the order of $10^{-10}$ to $10^{-17}$, well below experimental sensitivities.
  • Enhanced Branching Ratios (NMFV): With non-minimal flavor violation, branching ratios for $K^- \to \pi^- \chi_1^0 \chi_1^0$ and $B^- \to K^- \chi_1^0 \chi_1^0$ can be significantly enhanced, reaching values that could be probed by future experiments.
  • Constraints on Mass Insertions: The paper provides new constraints on the magnitude of flavor-violating mass insertion parameters in the MSSM, particularly for $s-d$ and $b-s$ transitions, by comparing theoretical predictions with experimental limits. For instance, they can exclude MSSM parameter space where $(d_s)_{LL} \gtrsim 10^{-2}$ or $(d_s)_{RR} \gtrsim 10^{-1}$ for certain squark mass configurations.
  • Monojet Searches: While direct pair production of light neutralinos with a jet at the Tevatron is unlikely to be observed due to SM backgrounds, LHC searches with sufficient luminosity could potentially detect these signals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mass Insertion Approximation: For $B$ decays, the analysis relies on the mass insertion approximation, which might need refinement with higher-order terms for very large mass insertions (up to 0.9). The authors suggest that a more precise analysis might be needed for future $B$ factories.
  • Model Dependence: The constraints derived from NMFV are dependent on the specific MSSM benchmark scenarios and assumptions about squark and gluino masses.
  • Future Experiments: The authors emphasize the need for future experiments, such as those at a super $B$ factory or the LHC, to explore the parameter space and potentially discover light neutralinos through these rare decay processes or direct production. They also suggest that radiative production of neutralinos with an additional photon at the LHC could be a viable search channel.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the bounds on the mass of the lightest neutralino from rare meson decays within the minimal supersymmetric standard model (MSSM) with and without minimal flavor violation. We present explicit formulas for the two-body decays of mesons into light neutralinos and perform the first complete calculation of the loop-induced decays of kaons to pions and light neutralinos and $B$ mesons to kaons and light neutralinos. We find that the supersymmetric branching ratios are strongly suppressed within the MSSM with minimal flavor violation, and that no bounds on the neutralino mass can be inferred from experimental data, i.e., a massless neutralino is allowed. The branching ratios for kaon and $B$ meson decays into light neutralinos may, however, be enhanced when one allows for nonminimal flavor violation. We find new constraints on the MSSM parameter space for such scenarios and discuss prospects for future kaon and $B$ meson experiments. Finally, we comment on the search for light neutralinos in monojet signatures at the Tevatron and at the LHC.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dreiner2009rare,
  author = {Herbi K. Dreiner and S. Grab and Daniel Koschade and Michael Krämer and Ben O’Leary and Ulrich Langenfeld},
  title = {{Rare meson decays into very light neutralinos}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.80.035018},
}
Figure