Abstract
The emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic in March 2020 created unprecedented challenges for scheduled ambulatory cancer care. This study analyzes the rapid transition to video consultations at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) Comprehensive Cancer Center. By comparing data from the 11 weeks before and after the transition, researchers found that video visit volume increased from an average of 208 to 1,177 visits per week. The proportion of video visits rose from under 20% to over 70% without creating disparities based on race, ethnicity, language, or insurance status. These findings demonstrate that large-scale telehealth adoption is feasible in a short timeframe while maintaining access to complex oncologic care.
Introduction
Cancer care is uniquely time-sensitive. Unlike elective procedures, oncologic consultations and treatments cannot be significantly delayed without risking adverse patient outcomes. When the COVID-19 pandemic necessitated strict social distancing in March 2020, healthcare systems were forced to reconcile the need for continuous care with the imperative to protect immunocompromised patients and staff.
The UCSF Comprehensive Cancer Center addressed this by pivoting to a telehealth-first model. This transition was not merely about adopting new software but scaling a virtual workflow across 17 different departments and divisions. This paper examines the feasibility of this rapid scale-up and its impact on healthcare equity.
Methods
Researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of Electronic Health Record (EHR) data from the UCSF Comprehensive Cancer Center, comparing two 11-week periods in 2020:
- Pre-COVID-19: January 1 to March 13.
- Post-COVID-19: March 16 to May 31.
The study utilized a HIPAA-compliant video conferencing platform (Zoom) integrated into existing clinical workflows. To maintain efficiency, Medical Assistants (MAs) performed virtual "check-ins," verifying patient identity and troubleshooting technical issues before clinicians joined the session. Statistical analysis was performed using R (version 3.5.3) to compare patient demographics and visit types across the two periods.
Results
The transition resulted in a dramatic shift in how care was delivered:
- Volume Increase: Total video visits surged from 2,284 in the pre-transition period to 12,946 in the post-transition period. The weekly average rose from 208 (SD 75) to 1,177 (SD 120).
- Proportional Shift: Video visits accounted for only 7–18% of total encounters before the pandemic; this rose to 54–72% in the weeks following the transition.
- Clinical Scope: The shift was not limited to follow-up care. The proportion of new patient "first clinic encounters" conducted via video increased from 18.3% to 24.9%, indicating that even complex initial consultations could be effectively managed remotely.
Equity and the Digital Divide
A primary concern during the rapid transition was the potential to exacerbate healthcare disparities. However, the data suggested that the shift did not leave vulnerable populations behind. There were no significant disparities in telehealth utilization based on race, ethnicity, or payor (insurance) status. Notably, the percentage of Asian patients utilizing video visits rose from 8.6% to 14.7% (p < 0.001), and the proportion of video visits for Black/African American and Hispanic/Latino patients also increased relative to the pre-COVID baseline.
Discussion: Drivers of Success
The ability to compress months of administrative planning into a few days suggests that the primary barriers to telehealth are often policy-oriented rather than technological. Two factors were critical to UCSF's success:
- Pre-existing Infrastructure: UCSF had established a telehealth program in 2015. Crucially, the institution had already decided to grant providers "Work Relative Value Unit" (wRVU) credit for telehealth visits, ensuring that financial incentives were aligned with clinical needs before the crisis began.
- Regulatory Support: Federal and state changes, such as the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) granting reimbursement parity for telehealth, provided the necessary economic framework to sustain the model.
Limitations and Conclusion
While successful, this study is limited by its focus on a single, urban academic center with robust technological infrastructure. Furthermore, the analysis did not capture patient satisfaction or long-term clinical outcomes.
In conclusion, the UCSF Comprehensive Cancer Center successfully scaled telehealth to maintain access to complex care during a global health crisis. The rapid transition demonstrates that with the right infrastructure and regulatory support, telehealth can serve as a primary modality for oncologic care without compromising equity. Future research should focus on the long-term sustainability of this model and its impact on the quality of care over time.
Summary updated