Rapid screening and confirmation of 86 illegally added chemicals in fishery drugs by ultra performance liquid chromatography-quadrupole-time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Qingqing Ke, Shiyan Li, Dingnan Wang, Qin Zhou, Fan Zhou, Yijiang Bei, Xiaohong Chen, Yang WangChinese 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, rapid, and comprehensive analytical method using UPLC-Q-TOF-MS to screen and confirm 86 illegally added chemicals in fishery drugs. This method addresses a critical need for quality control in the fisheries industry, offering high sensitivity and accuracy to ensure the safety of aquatic products.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The sustainable development of fisheries, particularly in China, is significantly hampered by issues related to the quality and safety of fishery products. A major contributor to these problems is the abuse of fishery drugs and the illegal or restricted use of certain chemicals within these drugs. This practice not only leads to potential health risks for consumers but also impacts the export market and the overall health of aquatic ecosystems. Existing analytical methods for detecting these illegal additives are often limited in scope, time-consuming, and may not adequately account for the complex matrices found in fishery drugs. Therefore, there is a pressing need for a rapid, sensitive, and comprehensive method to identify and quantify these potentially hazardous substances.

Methods

The core of this research is the development of an analytical method based on Ultra-Performance Liquid Chromatography-Quadrupole-Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (UPLC-Q-TOF-MS).

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological aspects:

  • Sample Preparation: Fishery drug samples (both antibiotic powders and Chinese herbal medicines) were extracted using an 80% acetonitrile aqueous solution. To mitigate matrix effects (interference from other components in the sample), the extracts were diluted. Specific dilution ratios were optimized: 50-fold for antibiotic powders and 10-fold for Chinese herbal medicines.
  • Chromatographic Separation: A Waters ACQUITY PREMIER HSS T3 column was used for separating the 86 target compounds. Gradient elution was employed using methanol and 0.1% formic acid as mobile phases.
  • Mass Spectrometry Detection: Electrospray ionization (ESI) in positive ion mode was used with the UPLC-Q-TOF-MS system.
  • Database Development: A crucial aspect of the method is the creation of an accurate mass database and a fragment ion library for the 86 target compounds. This database stores information on retention times, exact masses, isotopic patterns, and fragment ions.
  • Qualitative Analysis: Identification of compounds was achieved by comparing their retention times, exact masses, and isotopic abundance with the established database. For confirmation, target MS/MS (tandem mass spectrometry) was used, comparing fragment ions from the sample with those in the library.
  • Quantitative Analysis: Quantification was performed using the external standard method, relying on the peak area of the target analytes.
  • Optimization: The study involved optimizing various parameters, including the chromatographic column, mobile phase composition, and fragmentation voltage, to achieve optimal separation and sensitivity for all 86 compounds.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention the creation or use of large, publicly available datasets for training or evaluation in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, the "dataset" is effectively the database of 86 target compounds that the researchers meticulously built. This database includes:

  • Accurate Mass Database: Containing the exact mass of each compound.
  • Fragment Ion Library: Storing the characteristic fragment ions produced by each compound under specific MS/MS conditions.

This database was populated using commercially available mixed standard solutions of the 86 target compounds. The paper also describes the application of this method to 60 real-world fishery drug samples collected from Zhejiang Province, which served as the evaluation dataset for the method's practical utility.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • UPLC-Q-TOF-MS as a Powerful Tool: The study highlights the UPLC-Q-TOF-MS system's capability for rapid, high-throughput screening and confirmation of a large number of analytes in complex matrices like fishery drugs. Its high mass accuracy and resolution are key to distinguishing between similar compounds and reducing false positives.
  • Importance of a Comprehensive Database: The success of the method hinges on the creation of a robust and accurate mass and fragment ion database. This database acts as the "fingerprint" for each target compound, enabling reliable identification.
  • Matrix Effects are Manageable: The researchers demonstrated that matrix effects, a common challenge in analyzing complex samples like fishery drugs, can be effectively managed through appropriate sample dilution and the use of matrix-matched calibration curves where necessary.
  • Dual Confirmation Strategy: Relying on both accurate mass (first-level confirmation) and fragment ion matching (second-level confirmation) significantly enhances the reliability of the identification, minimizing the risk of false positives.
  • Method Applicability Beyond Specific Drugs: While focused on 86 specific chemicals, the underlying principles and the developed database approach are adaptable for monitoring other types of illegal additives in various fishery drug formulations.

Key Results

  • Method Development: A comprehensive analytical method was successfully developed for the rapid screening and confirmation of 86 illegally added chemicals in fishery drugs.
  • Performance Metrics:
    • Linearity: All 86 target compounds exhibited good linearity with correlation coefficients (r²) of at least 0.99.
  • Recoveries: Recoveries ranged from 76.8% to 112.1%, indicating good accuracy.
  • Relative Standard Deviations (RSDs): RSDs (n=3) were less than 11.7%, demonstrating good precision.
  • Limits of Quantification (LOQ): LOQ ranges were 1-15 mg/kg for Chinese herbal medicines and 5-75 mg/kg for antibiotics.
  • Screening Detection Limits (SDLs): SDL ranges were 1-15 mg/kg for Chinese herbal medicines and 5-50 mg/kg for antibiotics, deemed sufficient for practical screening.
  • Real-World Application: When applied to 60 fishery drug samples from Zhejiang Province, the method identified:
  • Eight Chinese herbal medicine samples containing unspecified ingredients.
  • One antibiotic sample found to be free of active substances (implying potential mislabeling or degradation).
  • Database Effectiveness: The developed database allowed for the identification of compounds with mass errors less than 5×10⁻⁶ and scores greater than 80, confirming the database's reliability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dilution Ratios: While dilution effectively reduced matrix effects, the study notes that higher dilution ratios can decrease analytical sensitivity. The chosen ratios (50x for antibiotics, 10x for herbal medicines) represent a balance between mitigating matrix effects and maintaining sensitivity.
  • Potential for Other Matrices: The paper suggests that the method is adaptable to other fishery drug matrices (e.g., immunomodulators, microbial agents), but acknowledges that screening limits might vary. Future work could involve validating the method across a wider range of fishery drug types.
  • Expanding the Database: The current study focuses on 86 specific chemicals. Future research could expand the database to include a broader spectrum of potentially illegal additives to provide even more comprehensive coverage.
  • Further Method Refinement: While the method is described as rapid and efficient, ongoing research could explore further optimizations for even faster analysis times or improved sensitivity for trace-level detection.

Summary updated

Abstract

<p id="p00005">With the rapid expansion of fisheries, one of the most significant limitations to the sustainable development of fisheries in China is the quality and safety of fishery products owing to the abuse of fishery drugs and the use of illegal and/or restricted chemicals in fishery drugs. A range of chemicals that are potential hazards to fishery drugs were selected for screening in this study. A comprehensive analytical method was developed, based on ultra performance liquid chromatography-quadrupole-time-of-flight mass spectrometry (UPLC-Q-TOF-MS), for the rapid screening of 86 types of illegally added chemicals in fishery drugs. The fishery drug samples were extracted with 80% (v/v) acetonitrile aqueous solution and diluted to reduce matrix effects. The 86 target compounds were separated on an ACQUITY PREMIER HSS T3 column (100 mm×2.1 mm, 1.8 μm), with methanol and 0.1% formic acid as mobile phases, via gradient elution. The extract was directly analyzed by UPLC-Q-TOF-MS using electrospray ionization in the positive mode. The external standard method was used for quantification. In this study, the extraction reagent and purification procedure were selected to develop a simple and effective pre-treatment protocol. The effects of the chromatographic column, mobile phase, and fragmentation voltage on the separation and sensitivity of the 86 substances were evaluated to determine the optimum instrument conditions. An accurate mass database and fragment ion library were created for the rapid qualitative and quantitative analysis of the 86 illegally added chemicals in fishery drugs. The retention time, isotopic abundance and spacing, and precise mass of the principal diagnostic ion for each analyte were used for identification. The information on the fragment ions obtained from the target MS/MS profiles was compared with that from a database to ensure the accuracy of the qualitative results. The chromatographic peak area of each target analyte was used for quantification. The analytical detection was based on the retention time deviation of ±0.35 min, accurate mass deviation of ±10×10<sup>-6</sup>, and major adduct forms, including [M+H]<sup>+</sup>, [M+Na]<sup>+</sup>, and [M+NH<sub>4</sub>]<sup>+</sup>. To evaluate the matrix effects of the 86 target chemicals at varied dilution ratios, two types of antibiotics and four types of Chinese herbal medicines were selected as typical samples. Considering the instrument tolerance as well as sensitivity and accuracy of the procedure, the recommended dilution ratios for antibiotics and Chinese herbal medicines were 50 times and 10 times, respectively. Two different types of calibration curves were prepared; one was the solvent calibration curve for antibiotics and the other was the matrix calibration curve for Chinese herbal medicines. For a given concentration, the calibration curves of the 86 target chemicals were linear with correlation coefficients of at least 0.99. The recoveries ranged from 76.8% to 112.1% with relative standard deviations (RSDs) (<italic>n</italic>=3) of less than 11.7%. The limit of quantification (LOQ) ranges of the compounds in Chinese herbal medicines and antibiotics were 1-15 mg/kg and 5-75 mg/kg, respectively. To evaluate the screening detection limits (SDLs) of each compound, a mixed standard solution was added to a fishery drug sample at varied concentrations. The SDL ranges of the compounds in Chinese herbal medicines and antibiotics were 1-15 and 5-50 mg/kg, respectively. This approach resulted in SDLs that satisfy the actual screening requirements. Because of its rapid nature, simplicity, accuracy, and sensitivity, the method may be used in the high-throughput screening and identification of illegally added chemicals in many types of fishery drugs. This method was applied to a monitoring project for the quality and safety of fishery inputs in Zhejiang Province. Sixty fishery drug samples were evaluated, among which eight Chinese herbal medicine samples were found to contain unspecified ingredients and one antibiotic sample was found to be free of any active substances. Thus, an effective technical method to monitor the quality and safety of fishery drugs was developed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ke2022rapid,
  author = {Qingqing Ke and Shiyan Li and Dingnan Wang and Qin Zhou and Fan Zhou and Yijiang Bei and Xiaohong Chen and Yang Wang},
  title = {{Rapid screening and confirmation of 86 illegally added chemicals in fishery drugs by ultra performance liquid chromatography-quadrupole-time-of-flight mass spectrometry}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3724/sp.j.1123.2021.11023},
}
Figure