Rapid evolution of distinct Helicobacter pylori subpopulations in the Americas

Kaisa Thorell, Koji Yahara, Elvire Berthenet, Daniel J. Lawson, Ikuko Kato, Alfonso Méndez-Tenorio, Federico Canzian, María Mercedes Bravo, Rumiko Suzuki, Yoshio Yamaoka, Javier Torres, Samuel K. Sheppard, Daniel FalushbioRxiv 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

The colonization of the Americas by Helicobacter pylori has led to rapid evolution and the formation of distinct bacterial subpopulations, driven by human migration and genetic exchange. These findings highlight how quickly pathogens can adapt to new environments and host populations, with implications for understanding disease dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Helicobacter pylori is a bacterium that infects a significant portion of the world's population, and its prevalence is linked to gastric cancer. While human migration patterns are known to influence the distribution of H. pylori strains, there have been discrepancies between human and bacterial evolutionary signals, particularly regarding the "out of Africa" dispersal. This study aims to understand how H. pylori evolved in the Americas following European colonization, investigating the interplay between human migration, genetic exchange, and the emergence of new bacterial populations. The researchers want to see if bacterial ancestry mirrors human ancestry and how quickly new subpopulations can form and adapt.

Methods

The study employed a combination of computational and genomic analysis techniques. The core method was chromosome painting using the ChromoPainter/fineSTRUCTURE pipeline. This approach infers the ancestry of bacterial genomes by breaking them down into segments ("chunks") and assigning each segment to a "donor" population from a reference panel.

  • "Old World painting": Used only Old World isolates (European, African, Asian) as donors to determine the origins of New World strains.
  • "Global painting": Used all isolates (Old and New World) as donors to understand relationships among New World strains.
  • Stratified chromosome painting: A novel statistical test was developed to identify specific genomic regions with "unexpected" ancestry components in New World populations, using Old World strains grouped by geographic origin (African, Asian, European) as donors.
  • Phylogenetic analysis: Maximum likelihood phylogenetic trees were constructed for specific genes to investigate their evolutionary history and potential role in adaptation.
  • Accessory genome analysis: Gene presence and absence patterns were analyzed to understand how the accessory genome (genes not essential for basic survival) contributes to population structure and adaptation.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 401 H. pylori isolates. This included:

  • Publicly available whole-genome sequences.
  • Newly sequenced genomes from isolates collected in:
  • Nicaragua (Hospital Escuela Antonio Lenin Fonseca)
    • Colombia (Oncology hospital, INCAN, Bogota)
    • Mexico (Oncology and General Hospital, Mexico City)
  • Publicly available Colombian and North American genomes from previous studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rapid Subpopulation Formation: H. pylori populations in the Americas evolved rapidly after colonization, forming distinct subpopulations within just 500 years. This is much faster than might be expected based solely on human migration patterns.
  • Admixture Driven by Human Movement: The genetic makeup of H. pylori in the Americas largely reflects the admixture patterns of human populations, with European and African origins being dominant. Pre-Columbian (hspAmerind) strains appear to have contributed minimally.
  • Differential Genetic Exchange: The extent of genetic exchange between bacterial populations varies significantly by region. Central and South America show rampant exchange, leading to national gene pools, while North America exhibits less exchange, possibly due to differences in prevalence or host population structure.
  • Adaptive Introgression of Specific Genes: Certain genes, particularly those encoding outer membrane proteins like AlpB and HofC, show evidence of having acquired ancestry from different populations than the rest of the genome. This suggests these genes may have conferred an adaptive advantage in the new American environment or to specific host ethnic groups.
  • African Lineages' Advantage: African lineages of H. pylori appear to have been particularly effective in colonizing the Americas, showing evidence of rapid demographic increases and potential transmission advantages.

Key Results

  • 12 Distinct Populations: The analysis identified 12 distinct H. pylori populations, with 5 being restricted to the New World.
  • European/African Hybrids: Five new subpopulations with mixed European and African ancestry were identified in the Americas.
  • National Gene Pools: In Colombia and Nicaragua, genetic exchange has led to the formation of distinct national gene pools.
  • Asian Ancestry in Outer Membrane Proteins: Four outer membrane proteins, including AlpB, showed atypical levels of Asian ancestry in American strains.
  • HofC Adaptation: Specific amino acid changes in the HofC protein were found to be conserved in South American isolates, suggesting an adaptive advantage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Incomplete Old World Sample: The study acknowledges that its sample of Old World sources is incomplete, meaning more closely related sub-populations might exist in regions not sampled (e.g., Spain).
  • Sampling Limitations: Sampling limitations make it difficult to definitively determine whether extensive admixture between African and European DNA occurred in the Americas or prior to arrival.
  • Detecting African Ancestry: The statistical methods used had less power to detect regions with excess African ancestry, particularly when sample sizes were small.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest further investigation into the function of specific proteins (like HofC) and their role in host-bacterial interactions and pathogenicity differences across regions. They also highlight the need to understand the impact of restriction-modification systems on gene exchange and the potential for novel subpopulations to arise through combinations of genetic drift and admixture.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract For the last 500 years, the Americas have been a melting pot both for genetically diverse humans and for the pathogenic and commensal organisms associated with them. One such organism is the stomach dwelling bacterium Helicobacter pylori , which is highly prevalent in Latin America where it is a major current public health challenge because of its strong association with gastric cancer. By analyzing the genome sequence of H. pylori isolated in North, Central and South America, we found evidence for admixture between H. pylori of European and African origin throughout the Americas, without substantial input from pre-Columbian (hspAmerind) bacteria. In the US, strains of African and European origin have remained genetically distinct, while in Colombia and Nicaragua, bottlenecks and rampant genetic exchange amongst isolates have led to the formation of national gene pools. We found four outer membrane proteins with atypical levels of Asian ancestry in American strains, including the adhesion factor AlpB, suggesting a role for the ethnic makeup of hosts in the colonization of incoming strains. Our results show that new H. pylori subpopulations can rapidly arise, spread and adapt during times of demographic flux, and suggest that differences in transmission ecology between high and low prevalence areas may substantially affect the composition of bacterial populations. Author Summary Helicobacter pylori is one of the best studied examples of an intimate association between bacteria and humans, due to its ability to colonize the stomach for decades and to transmit from generation to generation. A number of studies have sought to link diversity in H. pylori to human migrations but there are some discordant signals such as an “out of Africa” dispersal within the last few thousand years that has left a much stronger signal in bacterial genomes than in human ones. In order to understand how such discrepancies arise, we have investigated the evolution of H. pylori during the recent colonization of the Americas. We find that bacterial populations evolve quickly and can spread rapidly to people of different ethnicities. Distinct new bacterial subpopulations have formed in Colombia from a European source and in Nicaragua and the US from African sources. Genetic exchange between bacterial populations is rampant within Central and South America but is uncommon within North America, which may reflect differences in prevalence. Our results also suggest that adaptation of bacteria to particular human ethnic groups may be confined to a handful of genes involved in interaction with the immune system.
BibTeX
@misc{thorell2016rapid,
  author = {Kaisa Thorell and Koji Yahara and Elvire Berthenet and Daniel J. Lawson and Ikuko Kato and Alfonso Méndez-Tenorio and Federico Canzian and María Mercedes Bravo and Rumiko Suzuki and Yoshio Yamaoka and Javier Torres and Samuel K. Sheppard and Daniel Falush},
  title = {{Rapid evolution of distinct <i>Helicobacter pylori</i> subpopulations in the Americas}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1101/069070},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure