Rapid determination of 22 functional components in cosmetics using ultra-high performance liquid chromatography-linear ion trap/orbitrap high resolution mass spectrometry

Chensihui Xiong, Tianming Ding, Jie Liu, Ou Yi, Xiaoping Ding, Yun XieChinese 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, rapid, and reliable method for simultaneously quantifying 22 functional components in cosmetics using ultra-high performance liquid chromatography coupled with linear ion trap/orbitrap high-resolution mass spectrometry (UHPLC-LTQ/Orbitrap MS). This technique addresses the critical need for accurate detection of both single-molecule active ingredients and plant extracts in cosmetic products, which is currently lacking standardized methods, thereby improving product quality control and consumer safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The cosmetic industry increasingly relies on plant-derived active ingredients for their beneficial properties like skin whitening, moisturizing, and anti-aging. However, a significant challenge exists in accurately quantifying these components in finished products. Current analytical methods are often insufficient, especially for plant extracts present in trace amounts, leading to potential mislabeling and a lack of robust quality control. This gap makes it difficult to verify product claims and ensure consumer safety. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a sensitive and comprehensive method capable of detecting and quantifying a broad range of these functional ingredients.

Methods

The core of this research is the development of a UHPLC-LTQ/Orbitrap MS method. Key steps include:

  • Sample Preparation: Ultrasonic extraction of target compounds using methanol.
  • Chromatographic Separation: Separation of the 22 functional components using a C18 column (100 mm × 2.1 mm, 1.8 µm) with a gradient elution program involving a formic acid aqueous solution and acetonitrile. The flow rate was maintained at 0.3 mL/min with a 5 µL injection volume.
  • Mass Spectrometry Detection:
    • Positive Ionization Mode: Used for detecting the functional components.
  • Accurate Mass Measurement: Precursor ion accurate masses were used for initial detection.
  • High-Energy Collisional Dissociation (HCD): Fragment ions generated through HCD were used for definitive confirmation of the identified components.
  • Full Scan Mode: Employed for comprehensive detection.

This approach leverages the high resolution and mass accuracy of the Orbitrap MS, combined with the speed and efficiency of UHPLC, to achieve simultaneous and accurate quantification.

Datasets

The study utilized 54 batches of cosmetic samples that were labeled with specific functional components or plant extracts. These samples served as the evaluation dataset for the developed method. The authors also referenced the "Beauty Evolution" big data platform to identify commonly used functional components and plant extracts in cosmetics, guiding their selection of target analytes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Trace Amount" Challenge: A significant finding was the frequent absence of labeled functional components from plant extracts in actual cosmetic products, even when the extract itself was listed. This highlights a widespread issue of mislabeling or the use of very low concentrations that are difficult to detect with standard methods.
  • UHPLC-LTQ/Orbitrap MS as a Solution: The developed method demonstrated high sensitivity and accuracy, capable of detecting components at low levels and confirming their identity through fragmentation patterns. This makes it a powerful tool for addressing the aforementioned detection challenges.
  • Matrix Effects: The study identified matrix effects, particularly in emulsion and cream formulations, for certain compounds (e.g., glycyrrhizinic acid, astragaloside A). The authors addressed this by using matrix-matched calibration curves, showcasing the method's adaptability.
  • Need for Standardized Methods: The results underscore the urgent need for standardized analytical methods and reference materials for plant extracts in cosmetics to ensure accurate labeling and quality control.

Key Results

  • Method Performance: The method exhibited excellent linearity (R² > 0.999) for all 22 compounds. Limits of detection (LODs) ranged from 0.003 to 2.01 mg/kg, and limits of quantification (LOQs) ranged from 0.02 to 4.36 mg/kg. Recoveries were within acceptable ranges (63.2%-125.1%), with relative standard deviations (RSDs) between 0.18% and 10.9%.
  • Sample Analysis: Out of 54 tested samples:
  • Monolithic functional components like nicotinamide and caffeine were generally detected as labeled.
  • However, a substantial number of samples labeled with plant extracts (e.g., licorice, <i>Centella asiatica</i>, tea, ginseng, astragalus) did not contain detectable levels of their representative functional components. For instance, 11 out of 21 <i>Centella asiatica</i> extract samples and 8 out of 13 tea extract samples showed no detectable functional components.
  • Method Suitability: The method was deemed simple, rapid, reliable, accurate, and suitable for the determination of the 22 functional components in cosmetics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Matrix Effects: While addressed, matrix effects were noted for specific compounds in certain cosmetic bases, suggesting that further optimization or alternative sample preparation might be beneficial for these cases.
  • Reference Standards: The study highlights the lack of readily available reference standards for many plant extracts, which complicates comprehensive analysis and regulatory control. The authors suggest that developing such standards is crucial for future work.
  • Scope: The study focused on 22 specific functional components. Future work could expand this panel to include a wider array of active ingredients and plant-derived compounds commonly found in cosmetics.
  • Regulatory Impact: The findings strongly advocate for the development of official standards and guidelines for the detection and quantification of functional components in cosmetic products to combat mislabeling and ensure product efficacy and safety.

Summary updated

Abstract

Plant components from extracts of <i>Sophora flavescens</i>, rhodiola, ginseng, <i>Centella asiatica</i>, and tea play important roles in skin whitening, moisturizing, anti-aging, sun protection, anti-inflammation, antiseptic, bacteriostatic, and other effects of cosmetics. At present, no relevant standard methods have been established to detect the addition amounts of plant extracts in cosmetics. In addition, plant extracts listed in product labels may be undetectable due to their addition in trace quantities and the lack of technical support. Therefore, a quantitative method for the simultaneous determination of 22 functional components in cosmetics was established by ultra-high performance liquid chromatography-linear ion trap/orbitrap high resolution mass spectrometry (UHPLC-LTQ/Orbitrap MS). Target compounds were extracted with methanol from samples using ultrasonic extraction, and then separated on a C18 column (100 mm × 2.1 mm, 1.8 μm) with gradient elution of 0.1% (v/v) formic acid aqueous solution (A) and acetonitrile (B). The gradient elution program were as follows: 0-5 min, 5%B-8%B; 5-25 min, 8%B-60%B; 25-35 min, 60%B-80%B; 35-36 min, 80%B-5%B; 36-45 min, 5%B. The flow rate was 0.3 mL/min and the injection volume was 5 μL. Accurate masses of precursor ions were used to detect cosmetic functional components in positive ionization mode. The fragment ions obtained by higher energy collisional dissociation were used for confirmation of the functional components. Each compound showed good linearity. The limits of detection (LODs) were in the range of 0.003-2.01 mg/kg, and the limits of quantification (LOQs) were in the range of 0.02-4.36 mg/kg. Recoveries at three levels were 63.2%-125.1%, and relative standard deviations (RSDs) were 0.18%-10.9%. Fifty-four batches of samples labeled with four monomer functional components and nine plant extracts were tested. In the 17 batches of samples labeled with nicotinamide, 4 batches labeled with caffeine, and 6 batches labeled with <i>Sophora flavescens</i> root extract, the labeled functional components were detected. One out of 11 batches of samples labeled with D-panthenol was not detected. Three of the seven batches of samples labeled with ascorbyl glucoside were not detected. In the 21 batches of samples labeled with licorice extracts, the corresponding functional components were not detected in 9 batches. In the 21 batches of samples labeled with <i>Centella asiatica</i> extract, the corresponding functional components were not detected in 11 batches. In the 13 batches of samples labeled with tea extract, the corresponding functional components were not detected in 8 batches. In 11 of the 12 batches containing ginseng root extract, the corresponding functional components were not detected. In five of the six batches of astragalus membranaceus root extract samples, the corresponding functional components were not detected. In samples labeled with <i>Polygonum cuspidatum</i> root extract, <i>Rehmannia glutinosa</i> root extract, and <i>Ophiopogon japonicus</i> root extract, the corresponding functional components were detected. The method is simple, rapid, reliable, accurate, and suitable for the determination of the 22 functional components in cosmetics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiong2022rapid,
  author = {Chensihui Xiong and Tianming Ding and Jie Liu and Ou Yi and Xiaoping Ding and Yun Xie},
  title = {{Rapid determination of 22 functional components in cosmetics using ultra-high performance liquid chromatography-linear ion trap/orbitrap high resolution mass spectrometry}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3724/sp.j.1123.2022.03037},
}
Figure