Rapid and rhythmic ice sheet fluctuations in western Scandinavia 15-40 Kya–a review

Lars Olsen, Harald Sveian, Klaas van der Borg, Bjørn Bergstram, Maarten A. T. M. BroekmansPolar 2002 · DOI

Abstract

The onshore record of Middle to Late Weichselian sediments and glacial history in Norway indicates a succession of four major ice advances alternating with rapid, considerable ice recessions and interstadial conditions. During all the glacial advances the ice sheet expanded from onshore/inland positions to the shelf areas. The basis for visualizing these variations in glaciation curves constructed along nine transects from inland to shelf, and for interpretation of the palaeoclimatic history, is the regional Quaternary stratigraphy, more than 300 datings, fossil content and some palaeomagnetic data. The rapid and rhythmic ice fluctuations, as reconstructed in our new model, have been fairly synchronous in most parts of Norway. In our glaciation model we suggest that, in addition to precipitation, the mountainous fjord and valley topography, glacial isostasy and relative sea level changes were probably more important for the size of the glacial fluctuations than were air temperature changes.

Introduction

For decades, the prevailing model for the Scandinavian ice sheet between 15,000 and 40,000 years ago (15–40 Kya) was one of relatively stable, continuous ice cover. However, terrestrial and deep-sea proxy records began to tell a different story—one of seasonally open waters and ice-free inland areas. This review addresses the lack of a unified model explaining these rapid, rhythmic fluctuations by reconciling onshore geological evidence with offshore data to create a dynamic "minimum model" of glaciation.

Methodology and Regional Context

The authors utilize a multi-proxy approach to reconstruct the ice sheet's history along nine transects from inland Norway to the continental shelf. A critical component was applying Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS) to sediments with very low organic carbon content, allowing for precise timing of ice-free intervals. Standard geological methods, including clast fabric analysis and grain-size distribution, were used to identify alternating layers of till and waterlain sediments. Additionally, the researchers identified the "Mono Lake/Lake Mungo" magnetic excursion (~28 Kya) in cave sediments as a reliable chronostratigraphic marker.

Map of Scandinavia showing the nine study transects (1-9) and the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) limits.

Results: The Rhythmic Pulse of the Ice Sheet

Instead of a slow-moving monolith, the ice sheet was highly rhythmic. It advanced and retreated in four major cycles, with advances culminating at approximately 40, 30–28, 24–21, and 18–15 $^{14}$C Kya. The study formally describes three major ice-free periods: Hattfjelldal I, Hattfjelldal II, and Trofors. These fluctuations were remarkably synchronous across most of Norway, suggesting a unified regional response to external forcing.

Chronological distribution of dates showing the timing of ice advances and the intervening Hattfjelldal and Trofors interstadials.

Discussion: Non-Climatic Drivers of Instability

A major insight from this review is the suggestion that precipitation, fjord topography, and glacial isostasy were likely more influential on ice sheet size than air temperature alone. Norway’s deeply incised fjords acted as "entry points" for the sea; rising sea levels could destabilize the ice sheet through calving, leading to rapid recession regardless of minor temperature shifts. Furthermore, the weight of the ice depressed the Earth's crust so significantly that during interstadials, the sea flooded far inland into areas like Selbu at elevations 10–15% higher than the post-glacial marine limit.

Conclusion and Future Work

The identification of rapid, rhythmic pulses challenges the "maximum model" of a thick, stable ice sheet. Instead, the evidence supports a thinner, multi-domed ice sheet characterized by extreme instability. Future research is needed to determine if this rhythmic model holds true in eastern Fennoscandia (Sweden and Finland), where the record is currently less well-defined. The paper calls for more advanced 2-D and 3-D reconstructions to better understand the upstream influence of rapidly fluctuating ice streams on land-based glacial dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The onshore record of Middle to Late Weichselian sediments and glacial history in Norway indicates a succession of four major ice advances alternating with rapid, considerable ice recessions and interstadial conditions. During all the glacial advances the ice sheet expanded from onshore/inland positions to the shelf areas. The basis for visualizing these variations in glaciation curves constructed along nine transects from inland to shelf, and for interpretation of the palaeoclimatic history, is the regional Quaternary stratigraphy, more than 300 datings, fossil content and some palaeomagnetic data. The methods applied in recent years for AMS radiocarbon dating of glacial sediments with low organic carbon content have given promising results with respect to accuracy and precision, and the results of such datings were an important tool for our reconstructions and for timing of the ice oscillations. The rapid and rhythmic ice fluctuations, as reconstructed in our new model, have been fairly synchronous in most parts of Norway. Ice advances commenced and culminated at 40, 30-28, 24-21 and 18-15 (14C) Kya. We describe three intervening interstadials from inland sites: Hattfjelldal I, Hattfjelldal II and Trofors. Our stratigraphical record also includes many indications of high, pre-Holocene, relative sea levels, suggesting a considerable glacioisostatic depression of western Scandinavia during the interstadials. In our glaciation model we suggest that, in addition to precipitation, the mountainous fjord and valley topography, glacial isostasy and relative sea level changes were probably more important for the size of the glacial fluctuations than were air temperature changes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{olsen2002rapid,
  author = {Lars Olsen and Harald Sveian and Klaas van der Borg and Bjørn Bergstram and Maarten A. T. M. Broekmans},
  title = {{Rapid and rhythmic ice sheet fluctuations in western Scandinavia 15-40 Kya–a review}},
  booktitle = {Polar},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.3402/polar.v21i2.6483},
}
Figure