Randomized Distributed Mean Estimation: Accuracy vs Communication

Jakub Konecný, Peter RichtárikarXiv 2016 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of estimating the average of vectors distributed across multiple machines under strict communication limits. They introduce a flexible family of randomized algorithms that allow users to precisely tune the trade-off between communication cost and estimation accuracy, offering a spectrum from perfect accuracy with high communication to minimal communication with some error.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many distributed machine learning and optimization tasks, such as federated learning or distributed training of deep neural networks, a common operation is to compute the average of vectors stored across different nodes. This is often a bottleneck because communicating these vectors can be very expensive. The challenge is to accurately estimate this average while minimizing the amount of data sent over the network. Existing methods often make strong assumptions about the data distribution, which may not hold in practice. This paper addresses this by proposing methods that work without such assumptions and explicitly explore the fundamental trade-off between communication cost and estimation error.

Methods

The core contribution is a parametric family of randomized encoding protocols. These protocols allow each node to compress its local vector before sending it to a central server. The key idea is to introduce randomness in the encoding process, enabling a spectrum of communication-accuracy trade-offs.

  • Variable-size support encoding: This protocol uses probabilities $p_{ij}$ for each element $(i, j)$ of a vector. With probability $p_{ij}$, the element is encoded as either its original value or a node-specific center $\mu_i$. With probability $1-p_{ij}$, it's encoded as $\mu_i$. This allows for flexible compression.
  • Fixed-size support encoding: A simpler version where a fixed number of elements ($k$) are encoded, and the rest are implicitly assumed to be $\mu_i$.

These encoding protocols are paired with communication protocols (e.g., naive, varying-length, sparse, binary) that define how the encoded data is transmitted. The paper analyzes the expected communication cost and the mean squared error (MSE) of the estimated average. They also explore optimal encoder parameter selection through alternating minimization, balancing communication budget and MSE.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and uses synthetic data for experimental evaluation in Figure 1.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No Free Lunch: There's an inherent trade-off between communication cost and estimation accuracy. You can't have both perfect accuracy and minimal communication simultaneously.
  • Randomization is Key: Randomized encoding schemes offer a flexible way to navigate this trade-off, allowing for a continuous spectrum of solutions.
  • Beyond Statistical Assumptions: The proposed methods are robust because they don't rely on specific data distributions, making them applicable to a wider range of real-world scenarios.
  • Sparse Communication is Efficient: For low communication budgets, sparse communication protocols (where only non-zero or non-center values are sent) are particularly effective.
  • Optimizing Node Centers Matters: For non-symmetric data distributions, simply averaging node centers might not be optimal; optimizing these centers can further improve performance.

Key Results

  • The paper introduces a family of randomized algorithms that can achieve arbitrarily small communication costs (down to $\epsilon$ bits) at the expense of a corresponding increase in error (up to $\mathcal{O}(1/(\epsilon n))$).
  • In a specific scenario where one bit per coordinate is communicated on average, they achieve an error bound of $\mathcal{O}(r/n)$, where $r$ is the number of bits for a floating-point value. This improves upon prior work by being independent of the vector dimension $d$.
  • They provide a summary table (Table 1) illustrating the achievable communication cost and MSE for various choices of parameters, showcasing concrete trade-offs. For instance, with $p=1/r$ (1-bit communication), they achieve an MSE of $\mathcal{O}(R/n)$.
  • Experimental results (Figure 1) demonstrate that optimizing encoder parameters and node centers leads to significant improvements in the accuracy-communication trade-off, especially for non-symmetric data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the paper presents theoretical results, some optimization steps (finding optimal probabilities and node centers) require numerical methods, and closed-form solutions are not always available.
  • Generalization of Encoders: The paper explores binary and ternary encoders but suggests further research into k-ary encoders for potentially better trade-offs.
  • Random Rotations: The paper briefly touches upon using random rotations as a preprocessing step to potentially reduce MSE, but this is left as a direction for future work.
  • Practical Implementation: While the theoretical framework is strong, practical considerations for implementing these randomized protocols in large-scale distributed systems could be further explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of estimating the arithmetic average of a finite collection of real vectors stored in a distributed fashion across several compute nodes subject to a communication budget constraint. Our analysis does not rely on any statistical assumptions about the source of the vectors. This problem arises as a subproblem in many applications, including reduce-all operations within algorithms for distributed and federated optimization and learning. We propose a flexible family of randomized algorithms exploring the trade-off between expected communication cost and estimation error. Our family contains the full-communication and zero-error method on one extreme, and an $\epsilon$-bit communication and ${\cal O}\left(1/(\epsilon n)\right)$ error method on the opposite extreme. In the special case where we communicate, in expectation, a single bit per coordinate of each vector, we improve upon existing results by obtaining $\mathcal{O}(r/n)$ error, where $r$ is the number of bits used to represent a floating point value.
BibTeX
@misc{konecny2016randomized,
  author = {Jakub Konecný and Peter Richtárik},
  title = {{Randomized Distributed Mean Estimation: Accuracy vs Communication}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1611.07555},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1611.07555},
}
Figure