Random-Field-like Criticality in Glass-Forming Liquids

Giulio Biroli, Chiara Cammarota, Gilles Tarjus, Marco TarziaPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel field-theoretic approach to understand the glass transition in liquids by focusing on the "overlap" between different configurations as the key order parameter. They demonstrate that the critical behavior near a specific terminal point in the phase diagram of these liquids maps directly onto the well-understood physics of the Random-Field Ising Model (RFIM), suggesting a universal mechanism for glassy criticality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The glass transition in supercooled liquids is a notoriously complex phenomenon, lacking a universally accepted theoretical framework. A major hurdle is identifying the correct "order parameter" that captures the transition from a liquid to a solid-like glassy state. While the Random First-Order Transition (RFOT) theory suggests the "overlap" (a measure of similarity between equilibrium configurations) is a promising candidate, a complete field-theoretic description, especially one that accounts for fluctuations beyond mean-field theory, has been elusive. This paper tackles this by developing an effective field theory for the overlap field and investigating its critical behavior, particularly at a terminal critical point that can be accessed by introducing a conjugate source to the overlap. This allows them to connect the complex physics of glass formation to a simpler, well-studied disordered system.

Methods

The authors introduce an effective field theory for the overlap field, denoted by $p(x)$, which fluctuates in space. This theory is derived by integrating out the microscopic degrees of freedom of the liquid. A key technical tool is the use of "replicas" – multiple copies of the system – to calculate the cumulants of the overlap field's action. This is a standard technique in the study of disordered systems.

The core of their method involves:

  1. Defining the Overlap Field: They define the overlap $q[r, r']$ between two configurations $r$ and $r'$ as a measure of their similarity, smoothed over short distances.
  2. Constructing an Effective Action: They derive a functional action $S[p|r_0]$ for the overlap field $p(x)$, where $r_0$ is a reference equilibrium configuration. This action effectively describes the statistical mechanics of the overlap field.
  3. Replica Trick for Cumulants: To analyze the fluctuations and correlations of the overlap field, they employ the replica trick. This involves calculating the average of the logarithm of the partition function by considering $n$ identical replicas of the system and then taking the limit $n \to 0$. This allows them to compute the cumulants of the action, $S_l$.
  4. Mapping to RFIM: They show that the derived field theory, particularly near the terminal critical point, exhibits the same universality class as the Random-Field Ising Model (RFIM). This mapping is achieved by identifying the relevant terms in the effective action and comparing their scaling behavior to that of the RFIM.
  5. Saddle-Point Approximation: For calculating the overlap field's behavior, they use saddle-point approximations to solve the equations of motion for auxiliary fields (related to the overlap between replicas).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study is theoretical and relies on model Hamiltonians for glass-forming liquids, not experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Overlap as the Universal Critical Field: The paper strongly suggests that the overlap field is not just an order parameter for glass transitions, but a universal critical field, meaning its fluctuations dictate the critical behavior across different glass-forming systems.
  • Direct Mapping to RFIM: The most significant insight is the direct mapping of the glass transition's critical physics (at a specific terminal point) to the Random-Field Ising Model. This is a powerful result because the RFIM is a well-understood model with known critical exponents and scaling behavior. It implies that the complex dynamics of supercooled liquids might be governed by a simpler, underlying disordered system.
  • Quenched Disorder from Reference Configuration: The "quenched disorder" in the RFIM analogy arises naturally from the choice of a single reference equilibrium configuration. This provides a physical origin for the disorder in the context of glass formation.
  • Terminal Critical Point as a Key to Universality: The focus on the terminal critical point (where a first-order transition line ends and becomes continuous) is crucial. These points are often where universal scaling behavior emerges, making them ideal for identifying connections to known critical phenomena.

Key Results

  • The effective field theory for the overlap field near the terminal critical point is shown to be in the same universality class as the Random-Field Ising Model (RFIM).
  • The quenched disorder in this mapping originates from the choice of a reference equilibrium configuration.
  • The study provides a theoretical framework for understanding the nature of the disorder in supercooled liquids, potentially resolving debates about whether glass transitions are related to random-field, random-bond, or spin-glass physics.
  • They present quantitative results for the coefficients of the effective action and compare the strength of the disorder to the surface tension for different model systems (Landau-like functional and a 3-spin model), suggesting that a transition is expected for the former but not the latter in 3D.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability to the Entire Supercooled Regime: While the mapping to RFIM is established near the terminal critical point, the paper acknowledges that its generality for the entire supercooled liquid regime, especially near the ideal glass transition (without the conjugate source), is not fully demonstrated and is a focus for future work.
  • Extension to Finite Dimensions: The RFOT theory is often formulated in mean-field, and extending the RFIM mapping to finite dimensions for the ideal glass transition remains a challenge.
  • Microscopic Details: The authors note that the Landau-like functional used as an initial input is a "crude approximation." Deriving a more accurate starting point that fully incorporates microscopic details of glass-formers is a crucial next step.
  • Experimental Verification: While the paper suggests experimental tests by measuring correlation functions, direct experimental verification of the RFIM universality class for glass transitions is still an open question.
  • Comparison with Other Approaches: The paper mentions that other groups are also addressing similar problems, and a comparison of their different approaches would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce an approach to derive an effective scalar field theory for the glass transition; the fluctuating field is the overlap between equilibrium configurations. We apply it to the case of constrained liquids for which the introduction of a conjugate source to the overlap field was predicted to lead to an equilibrium critical point. We show that the long-distance physics in the vicinity of this critical point is in the same universality class as that of a paradigmatic disordered model: the random-field Ising model. The quenched disorder is provided here by a reference equilibrium liquid configuration. We discuss to what extent this field-theoretical description and the mapping to the random field Ising model hold in the whole supercooled liquid regime, in particular, near the glass transition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{biroli2014random,
  author = {Giulio Biroli and Chiara Cammarota and Gilles Tarjus and Marco Tarzia},
  title = {{Random-Field-like Criticality in Glass-Forming Liquids}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.112.175701},
}
Figure