Raman Tensor of Layered Black Phosphorous

Yanming Zhu, Wei Zheng, Weiliang Wang, Siqi Zhu, Linxuan Li, Cheng Lü, Mingge Jin, Ying Ding, Feng HuangResearch 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Black phosphorus (BP) has emerged as a significant material in the 2D semiconductor landscape due to its unique "puckered" orthorhombic structure. This geometry results in highly anisotropic electrical, thermal, and optical properties, making it a candidate for specialized transistors and sensors. Central to understanding these properties is the Raman tensor, a mathematical representation of how light interacts with the material's lattice vibrations (phonons). While previous research has focused on the basal plane (top-down view), the cross plane (side view) has been largely neglected, leaving the full 3D Raman tensor incomplete.

Experimental and Theoretical Methodology

To map the complete Raman tensor, researchers employed a dual approach combining experimental measurement with theoretical modeling:

  1. Angle-Resolved Polarized Raman (APR) Spectroscopy: Using a 488 nm laser, the team performed measurements on a single-crystal BP sample. By rotating the sample in 10° increments and aligning incident and scattered light polarizations, they tracked intensity variations across both the basal (010) and cross (100) planes.
  2. First-Principles Calculations: Density Functional Theory (DFT) was used to calculate relative permittivity and its changes during vibrations. This provided a theoretical benchmark for the Raman tensor elements and allowed for the prediction of differential polarizability.
Crystal structure of black phosphorus and the experimental geometry for basal and cross-plane Raman scattering.

Key Findings: Anisotropy and Plane Discrimination

The investigation revealed that specific phonon modes act as "plane discriminators." The $B_{2g}$ mode is forbidden in the cross plane, whereas the $B_{3g}$ mode is invisible in the basal plane. This provides a definitive method for identifying crystal orientation using non-destructive optical techniques.

The study also uncovered extreme Raman anisotropy. For the $A_g^1$ mode, the intensity ratio along the different crystal axes ($x:y:z$) reached a staggering 256:1:23. This is attributed to the significantly higher differential polarizability along the $a$-axis (zigzag direction) compared to the others. The calculated Raman tensor amplitudes for $A_g^1$ ($a_1 : c_1 : b_1$) were found to be approximately $16 : 4.8 : 1$.

The Role of Birefringence in Opaque Materials

A critical insight of this work is the impact of birefringence in opaque materials. Traditionally, birefringence—where the speed of light depends on its polarization—is considered primarily for transparent crystals. However, the authors demonstrated that even in BP, which is opaque at 488 nm, birefringence significantly modulates the phase difference between Raman tensor elements. By introducing a birefringence phase factor ($\phi$), the researchers successfully reconciled the experimental phase difference for the $A_g^2$ mode (79°) with a corrected theoretical value (83°), whereas uncorrected theory predicted a value near 0°.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work provides the first "integral" Raman tensor for black phosphorus, offering a complete 3D picture of its light-matter interactions. While this study focused on bulk-like single crystals at 488 nm, future research may explore how these tensors evolve with different excitation energies or as the material is thinned to a single atomic layer (phosphorene), where quantum confinement effects become dominant.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Black phosphorous is an orthorhombic with a strong Raman anisotropy in the basal and cross plane. However, up to now, almost all the studies on anisotropy of black phosphorous have focused on basal plane but neglected cross plane. Here, we performed a systematic angle-resolved polarized Raman scattering on the basal and cross plane of black phosphorous and obtained its integral Raman tensors. In addition, we discovered that Raman intensity ratio ( I xx :I yy :I zz ) of A_1^g mode is 256:1:5 when the polarization direction of incident light is along different crystal axes. According to first-principle calculated results, we confirmed that the strong Raman anisotropy is due to larger differential polarizability of A_1^g mode along a-axis. This phenomenon is also observed in the A_2^g mode.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2020raman,
  author = {Yanming Zhu and Wei Zheng and Weiliang Wang and Siqi Zhu and Linxuan Li and Cheng Lü and Mingge Jin and Ying Ding and Feng Huang},
  title = {{Raman Tensor of Layered Black Phosphorous}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-20864/v1},
}
Figure