Rainfall Runoff and Nitrogen Loss Characteristics on the Miyun Reservoir Slope

Na Wang, Lei Wang, Jin Liang, Jiajun Wu, Min Pang, Dan Wei, Yan Li, Junqiang Wang, Ting Xu, Zhixin Yang, Jianzhi XieWater 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how rainfall intensity and slope gradient affect runoff and nitrogen loss on Miyun Reservoir slopes using simulated rainfall experiments. The findings reveal that while surface runoff is primarily driven by rainfall intensity, subsurface runoff is more significantly influenced by slope gradient, highlighting the complex interplay of factors impacting water quality in this critical watershed.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soil erosion and nutrient loss are significant environmental challenges globally, particularly in regions like China where human activities have accelerated these processes. The Miyun Reservoir, a vital water source for Beijing, faces risks of eutrophication due to nutrient runoff from its surrounding slopes. While rainfall intensity and slope gradient are known drivers of erosion, their specific impacts on both surface and subsurface runoff, and crucially, on nitrogen loss pathways within the Miyun Reservoir watershed, have not been fully elucidated. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by quantifying these relationships and understanding the mechanisms behind nitrogen migration under varying rainfall and slope conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed artificial indoor simulated rainfall experiments to mimic natural conditions. They utilized a specialized rainfall simulator (QYJY-502) to control rainfall intensity and a variable slope steel box to adjust slope gradients. Soil samples were collected from the Miyun Reservoir area and prepared to mimic natural soil conditions. Experiments were conducted under nine different combinations of rainfall intensities (40, 60, and 80 mm/h) and slope gradients (5°, 10°, and 15°), with each treatment replicated three times. Surface and subsurface runoff were collected separately, and their volumes and total nitrogen (TN) concentrations were measured. Data analysis involved statistical methods, including the least significant difference (LSD) test for significance and the calculation of factor contribution rates (PF) to understand the relative influence of different variables.

Datasets

The study used soil collected from Taishitun Town in the Miyun District, Beijing. The basic physiochemical properties of this soil (pH, organic matter, TN, available potassium and phosphorus, sand, silt, and clay content) were analyzed and presented in Table 1. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the focus was on experimental data generated under controlled conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Pathways of Nitrogen Loss: The study highlights that nitrogen loss occurs through both surface and subsurface runoff, with subsurface runoff being the dominant pathway for nitrogen loss (over 51.14%) despite surface runoff being the primary contributor to total runoff volume (over 62.57%). This is a critical insight for understanding where mitigation efforts should be focused.
  • Conflicting Drivers: Rainfall intensity is the primary driver of surface runoff volume, but slope gradient plays a more significant role in nitrogen loss, particularly from subsurface flow. This suggests that strategies to reduce nitrogen loss might need to consider slope management more heavily than just controlling rainfall intensity.
  • Runoff Generation Dynamics: Subsurface runoff generation consistently lags behind surface runoff, but this lag time decreases with increasing rainfall intensity and slope. This indicates a dynamic system where initial rainfall events prime the soil for deeper water movement.
  • Critical Slope Phenomenon: The study hints at a critical slope gradient (between 5° and 10°) where subsurface runoff rate initially increases and then decreases, suggesting a complex interaction between gravity-driven flow and infiltration capacity.
  • Stabilization of Nitrogen Loss: Nitrogen loss concentration in surface runoff tends to stabilize over time, with lower rainfall intensities leading to earlier stabilization. This implies that the initial flush of easily erodible nitrogen is a key event.

Key Results

  • Runoff Volume: Surface runoff rate significantly increased with both rainfall intensity and slope gradient. For instance, at a 15° slope, runoff rates at 60 and 80 mm/h were 2.38 and 3.60 times higher, respectively, than at 40 mm/h. Subsurface runoff rate generally increased with rainfall intensity but showed a more complex relationship with slope, peaking between 5° and 10°.
  • Nitrogen Loss Concentration: Surface runoff TN concentration initially decreased and then stabilized. Subsurface runoff TN concentration decreased with increasing rainfall intensity (40 > 60 > 80 mm/h).
  • Runoff Coefficients: The surface runoff coefficient was mainly influenced by rainfall intensity, while the subsurface runoff coefficient was primarily affected by slope gradient.
  • Contribution Rates: Rainfall intensity was the dominant factor influencing surface runoff (99.6%), while slope gradient had the largest contribution to total nitrogen loss from surface runoff (66.8%). For subsurface runoff, the interaction between rainfall intensity and slope gradient was most significant (44.1%).
  • Runoff Pathways: Surface runoff accounted for the majority of total runoff volume (62.57% minimum), while subsurface runoff was the primary pathway for nitrogen loss (51.14% minimum).
  • Runoff Modulus: Mixed runoff (simultaneous surface and subsurface) had the highest modulus, followed by surface runoff, and then subsurface runoff.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Slope Length Ignored: The study acknowledges that slope length was not considered, which is a crucial factor in erosion and nutrient transport. Future work should incorporate slope length characteristics.
  • Underground Migration Not Studied: The research did not investigate the migration of nutrients underground, which can be a significant pathway for nitrogen loss, especially in karst regions. This is noted as a limitation, particularly for controlling groundwater pollution.
  • Fertilizer Use and Vegetation Cover: While the study suggests potential mitigation strategies like reducing agricultural fertilizer use and increasing vegetation cover, these were not experimentally tested.
  • Interactions of Factors: While the study analyzed interactions, it suggests that a more comprehensive understanding of how multiple factors influence each other is needed.

The authors propose future research to include slope length and to further explore the complex interactions between influencing factors on slope erosion and nitrogen loss.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rainfall intensity and slope gradient are the main drivers of slope surface runoff and nitrogen loss. To explore the distribution of rainfall runoff and nitrogen loss on the Miyun Reservoir slopes, we used artificial indoor simulated rainfall experiments to determine the distribution characteristics and nitrogen migration paths of surface and subsurface runoff under different rainfall intensities and slope gradients. The initial runoff generation time of subsurface runoff lagged that of surface runoff, and the lag time under different rainfall intensity and slope conditions ranges from 3.97 to 12.62 min. Surface runoff rate increased with increasing rainfall intensity and slope gradient; compared with a rainfall intensity of 40 mm/h, at a slope of 15°, average surface runoff rate at 60 and 80 mm/h increased by 2.38 and 3.60 times, respectively. Meanwhile, the subsurface runoff rate trended upwards with increasing rainfall intensity, in the order 5 > 15 > 10°. It initially increased and then decreased with increasing slope gradient, in the order 5 > 10 > 15°. Total nitrogen (TN) loss concentration of surface runoff shows a decrease followed by a stabilization trend; the concentration of TN loss decreases with decreasing rainfall intensity, and the stabilization time becomes earlier and is most obvious in 5° slope conditions. TN loss concentration in subsurface runoff decreased with increasing rainfall intensity, i.e., 40 > 60 > 80 mm/h. The surface runoff rainfall coefficient was mainly affected by rainfall intensity, a correlation between αs and slope gradients S was not obvious, and the fitting effect was poor. The subsurface runoff rainfall coefficient was mainly affected by slope gradient, the R2 of all rainfall intensities was <0.60, and the fitting effect was poor. The main runoff loss pathway from the Miyun Reservoir slopes was surface runoff, which was more than 62.57%. At the same time, nitrogen loss was subsurface runoff, more than 51.14%. The proportion of surface runoff to total runoff increases with the increase of rainfall intensity and slope, with a minimum of 62.57%, and the proportion of nitrogen loss from subsurface runoff also decreases with increasing rainfall intensity but does not change with slope gradient. The order of different runoff modulus types was mixed runoff (surface and subsurface runoff occur simultaneously) > surface runoff > subsurface runoff. The surface and mixed runoff modulus increased significantly with increasing rain intensity under different rain intensities and slope gradients. Overall, rainfall intensity significantly affected slope surface runoff, and slope gradient significantly affected nitrogen loss.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024rainfall,
  author = {Na Wang and Lei Wang and Jin Liang and Jiajun Wu and Min Pang and Dan Wei and Yan Li and Junqiang Wang and Ting Xu and Zhixin Yang and Jianzhi Xie},
  title = {{Rainfall Runoff and Nitrogen Loss Characteristics on the Miyun Reservoir Slope}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/w16050786},
}
Figure