Rain-Use-Efficiency: What it Tells us about the Conflicting Sahel Greening and Sahelian Paradox

Cécile Dardel, Laurent Kergoat, Pierre Hiernaux, Manuela Grippa, É. Mougin, Philippe Ciais, Cam-Chi NguyenRemote 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the "Sahelian paradox" – the apparent contradiction between observed "greening" and signs of land degradation. By combining field data and satellite imagery, the study finds that while the overall Sahel region shows resilience (stable Rain Use Efficiency), localized degradation on shallow soils contributes to increased runoff, highlighting the importance of scale in ecological assessments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Sahel region has seen conflicting reports regarding land degradation. Some studies, using Rain Use Efficiency (RUE) – a measure of how effectively vegetation converts rainfall into biomass – suggest a "greening" trend, indicating ecosystem resilience. However, other indicators, like increased runoff, point towards land degradation. This discrepancy, termed the "second Sahelian paradox," is fueled by methodological challenges in using satellite data to estimate biomass and differing ecological interpretations. This paper aims to reconcile these conflicting signals by examining RUE and ANPP residuals (biomass not explained by rainfall) over a long period in the Gourma region of Mali.

Methods

The study employs two primary methods to assess vegetation dynamics and land degradation:

  • Rain Use Efficiency (RUE): Calculated as Aboveground Net Primary Production (ANPP) divided by annual rainfall.
  • ANPP Residuals: Derived from the difference between observed ANPP and ANPP predicted by a linear regression against rainfall. This method aims to isolate changes in vegetation production not directly attributable to rainfall variations.

Both field-derived and satellite-derived ANPP data were used to calculate RUE and ANPP residuals. The study also investigated the linearity of the ANPP/rainfall relationship and its impact on interpretations.

Datasets

  • Field Observations: 27 years of aboveground herbaceous vegetation mass data (1984-2010) collected from 21 sites in the Gourma region, Mali.
  • Remote Sensing Data:
    • GIMMS-3g NDVI: Normalized Difference Vegetation Index data from the AVHRR sensor, providing a long-term (1981-2012) global record at 1/12° spatial resolution.
  • MODIS NDVI: Used for comparison during the 2000-2010 period.
  • Rainfall Data: Daily rainfall data from a research network of rain gauges in the Gourma region (1984-2010), spatially averaged.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scale Matters: The study strongly emphasizes that ecological assessments must consider the scale of observation. While the broader Gourma region shows resilience, localized degradation on specific soil types can have significant hydrological impacts.
  • Reconciling Paradoxes: The "second Sahelian paradox" can be explained by the interplay of resilient, productive deep sandy soils and localized degradation on shallow soils. The dominant signal from sandy soils masks the subtle degradation occurring elsewhere.
  • RUE and Residuals as Complementary Tools: The study demonstrates that both RUE and ANPP residuals, when applied consistently, provide comparable results and can be used to monitor long-term trends, even with satellite data.
  • Shallow Soils as Hotspots: Shallow soil areas, often characterized by bedrock or iron pan outcrops, are identified as more susceptible to degradation and contribute significantly to increased runoff.

Key Results

  • Overall Resilience: Aggregated at the Gourma region scale, both RUE and ANPP residuals showed no significant trends over the 1984-2010 period, indicating ecosystem resilience.
  • ANPP-Rainfall Correlation: Both field and satellite-derived ANPP were strongly correlated with annual rainfall (explaining 76-77% of variance), supporting the use of satellite data for long-term monitoring.
  • Increased Runoff: Despite stable RUE, a significant increase in the runoff coefficient was observed across the Gourma region, pointing to land degradation.
  • Soil Type Differences: Deep sandy soils exhibited high resilience, mirroring the regional trend. In contrast, shallow soils showed varied responses, with some sites displaying signs of degradation (decreasing vegetation cover and increasing runoff).
  • Localized Degradation Impact: Degradation on a small fraction of shallow soils was sufficient to drive a significant increase in runoff at the regional scale.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Resolution: The GIMMS-3g NDVI resolution (1/12°) limited direct comparison with small, specific field sites, particularly for shallow soil areas.
  • Undetected Degradation: The study acknowledges that a significant decrease in ANPP (30-40%) might be needed to be detected with current time series lengths, and degradation occurring at the beginning or end of the time series might be missed.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation using high-resolution imagery (e.g., Landsat, airborne) to better assess eco-hydrological changes, especially in shallow soil areas across the Sahel. They also propose extending this analysis to similar soil types continent-wide to understand the broader implications of these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rain Use Efficiency (RUE), defined as Aboveground Net Primary Production (ANPP) divided by rainfall, is increasingly used to diagnose land degradation. Yet, the outcome of RUE monitoring has been much debated since opposite results were found about land degradation in the Sahel region. The debate is fueled by methodological issues, especially when using satellite remote sensing data to estimate ANPP, and by differences in the ecological interpretation. An alternative method which solves part of these issues relies on the residuals of ANPP regressed against rainfall (“ANPP residuals”). In this paper, we use long-term field observations of herbaceous vegetation mass collected in the Gourma region in Mali together with remote sensing data (GIMMS-3g Normalized Difference Vegetation Index) to estimate ANPP, RUE, and the ANPP residuals, over the period 1984–2010. The residuals as well as RUE do not reveal any trend over time over the Gourma region, implying that vegetation is resilient over that period, when data are aggregated at the Gourma scale. We find no conflict between field-derived and satellite-derived results in terms of trends. The nature (linearity) of the ANPP/rainfall relationship is investigated and is found to have no impact on the RUE and residuals interpretation. However, at odds with a stable RUE, an increased run-off coefficient has been observed in the area over the same period, pointing towards land degradation. The divergence of these two indicators of ecosystem resilience (stable RUE) and land degradation (increasing run-off coefficient) is referred to as the “second Sahelian paradox”. When shallow soils and deep soils are examined separately, high resilience is diagnosed on the deep soil sites. However, some of the shallow soils show signs of degradation, being characterized by decreasing vegetation cover and increasing run-off coefficient. Such results show that contrasted changes may co-exist within a region where a strong overall re-greening pattern is observed, highlighting that both the scale of observations and the scale of the processes have to be considered when performing assessments of vegetation changes and land degradation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dardel2014rain,
  author = {Cécile Dardel and Laurent Kergoat and Pierre Hiernaux and Manuela Grippa and É. Mougin and Philippe Ciais and Cam-Chi Nguyen},
  title = {{Rain-Use-Efficiency: What it Tells us about the Conflicting Sahel Greening and Sahelian Paradox}},
  booktitle = {Remote},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3390/rs6043446},
}
Figure