Rain Evaporation, Snow Melt, and Entrainment at the Heart of Water Vapor Isotopic Variations in the Tropical Troposphere, According to Large‐Eddy Simulations and a Two‐Column Model

Camille Risi, Caroline Müller, Peter N. BlosseyJournal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study develops a simplified two-column model to explain the "amount effect" – the observed decrease in water vapor and precipitation isotopic composition with increasing precipitation in the tropics. The model, validated against high-resolution simulations, reveals that higher tropospheric humidity, driven by large-scale ascent, is the primary driver for more depleted water vapor, primarily through reduced snow sublimation and rain evaporation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the isotopic composition of water vapor (specifically its deuterium content, δD) is crucial for reconstructing past climates from paleoclimate archives. However, the factors controlling these isotopic variations in the tropical troposphere, particularly the "amount effect" (where more precipitation means more isotopically depleted water), are complex and not fully understood. Previous studies have pointed to various processes like rain evaporation, snow melt, and atmospheric mixing, but a unifying framework, especially for disorganized tropical convection, was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by developing a simple, interpretable model to explain these variations and their link to precipitation.

Methods

The authors employ a two-pronged approach:

  1. Large-Eddy Simulations (LES): They use the System for Atmospheric Modeling (SAM) with water isotopes enabled to simulate disorganized convection in radiative-convective equilibrium. These simulations are run under different large-scale vertical velocity profiles (LowPrec, ctrl, HighPrec) to represent varying precipitation rates. The LES data provides detailed, high-resolution meteorological and isotopic fields.
  2. Two-Column Model: Based on the insights from the LES, they develop a simplified analytical model. This model consists of two columns: one representing cloudy regions (updrafts and downdrafts) and the other representing the environment (subsiding air and precipitating downdrafts). This model aims to capture the essential processes of entrainment, detrainment, condensation, evaporation, and large-scale forcing to predict humidity and isotopic profiles.

Datasets

The study uses output from their own Large-Eddy Simulations (LES) as the primary dataset. They also compare their simulated results to daily in situ isotopic observations of near-surface vapor and precipitation collected during cruises across the Pacific Ocean (Kurita, 2013). Precipitation data for colocation was obtained from the TRMM (Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Humidity is King: The study strongly emphasizes that tropospheric relative humidity is the central player in the "vapor amount effect." Higher humidity, often driven by large-scale ascent, leads to more depleted water vapor.
  • Snow Melt Matters: In moister conditions (high precipitation), less snow sublimates before melting. This "snow melt" process imbues the resulting rain with a more depleted isotopic signature, which then influences subsequent rain evaporation.
  • Rain Evaporation's Dual Role: While rain evaporation generally enriches vapor, in moister conditions, the smaller evaporated fraction and more depleted rain lead to a more depleted evaporation flux, contributing to the overall depletion.
  • Entrainment as a Diluter: Entrainment of dry air into clouds acts to reduce the vertical isotopic gradient. In drier conditions (low precipitation), this dilution effect becomes more dominant, leading to less depletion.
  • SCL as a Memory: The isotopic composition of the subcloud layer (SCL) acts as a crucial "memory" of processes occurring higher in the troposphere, influencing the entire vertical profile.

Key Results

  • The LES simulations successfully reproduce the "amount effect," showing a decrease in water vapor and precipitation δD with increasing precipitation.
  • The two-column model, when constrained by LES parameters, captures the order of magnitude and shape of the vertical profiles of humidity and δD, as well as the differences between the HighPrec and LowPrec simulations.
  • Decomposition analysis reveals that in high precipitation scenarios (HighPrec), the more depleted rain evaporation (due to snow melt and smaller evaporated fraction) is the dominant driver of the SCL δD difference, followed by the large-scale ascent (moistening effect).
  • In low precipitation scenarios (LowPrec), the dilution effect from entrainment of drier air is the main contributor to the more enriched vapor.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Disorganized Convection: The study focuses on disorganized convection, which may not fully represent organized systems like squall lines or tropical cyclones. These organized systems can exhibit larger horizontal variations in humidity and isotopes, potentially altering the results.
  • Horizontal Gradients Neglected: The model and simulations largely neglect large-scale horizontal gradients in humidity and isotopes, which can dampen isotopic variations in reality.
  • Model Simplifications: The two-column model, while effective, simplifies complex atmospheric processes and may underestimate certain effects, particularly rain evaporation.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to investigate water vapor isotopic profiles in LES with different convective organizations (squall lines, tropical cyclones) and explore the role of microphysical and subgrid-scale turbulence parameterizations in GCMs. They also suggest investigating the added value of isotopic diagnostics in GCMs.

Summary updated

Abstract

We aim at developing a simple model as an interpretative framework for the water vapor isotopic variations in the tropical troposphere over the ocean. We use large-eddy simulations of disorganized convection in radiative-convective equilibrium to justify the underlying assumptions of this simple model, to constrain its input parameters and to evaluate its results. We also aim at interpreting the depletion of the water vapor isotopic composition in the lower and midtroposphere as precipitation increases, which is a salient feature in tropical oceanic observations. This feature constitutes a stringent test on the relevance of our interpretative framework. Previous studies, based on observations or on models with parameterized convection, have highlighted the roles of deep convective and mesoscale downdrafts, rain evaporation, rain-vapor diffusive exchanges, and mixing processes. The interpretative framework that we develop, valid in case of disorganized convection, is a two-column model representing the net ascent in clouds and the net descent in the environment. We show that the mechanisms for depleting the troposphere as the precipitation rate increases all stem from the higher tropospheric relative humidity. First, when the relative humidity is larger, less snow sublimates before melting and a smaller fraction of rain evaporates. Both effects lead to more depleted rain evaporation and eventually more depleted water vapor. This mechanism dominates in regimes of large-scale ascent. Second, the entrainment of dry air into clouds reduces the vertical isotopic gradient and limits the depletion of tropospheric water vapor. This mechanism dominates in regimes of large-scale descent.
BibTeX
@article{risi2021rain,
  author = {Camille Risi and Caroline Müller and Peter N. Blossey},
  title = {{Rain Evaporation, Snow Melt, and Entrainment at the Heart of Water Vapor Isotopic Variations in the Tropical Troposphere, According to Large‐Eddy Simulations and a Two‐Column Model}},
  journal = {Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1029/2020ms002381},
}
Figure