Railway track settlement patterns and control measures for multi-tunnel construction underneath a station track group: a case study

Pinpin Li, Feng Lu, Haiyun Huang, Wenge QiuScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This case study investigates the complex geomechanical interactions that occur when a group of three tunnels is excavated beneath a dense cluster of active railway tracks at Chongqing West Station. By combining 3D numerical simulations with theoretical load models, the researchers identified a distinct "uplift-then-settle" pattern in the tracks and demonstrated that a combination of double-side drift excavation and dual-layer grouting can keep ground deformation well within strict safety limits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As urban infrastructure densifies, engineers increasingly face "proximity engineering" challenges—specifically, building new tunnels directly underneath existing, high-traffic railway hubs. These "station track groups" are operational bottlenecks where even minor ground settlement can lead to track misalignment, increased maintenance costs, or catastrophic derailments.

While previous research has looked at single tunnels passing under single tracks, there is a lack of data on multi-tunnel construction (where tunnels disturb the soil repeatedly) underneath track groups (where multiple parallel train loads create complex stress distributions). This paper uses the Baishiyi tunnel project in Chongqing, China, to establish a blueprint for predicting and controlling these interactions.

Methods

The authors employed a hybrid approach to analyze the "tunnel–strata–tracks" system:

  • Numerical Modeling: A high-fidelity 3D model was built using FLAC3D (finite difference software). The model simulated a 60m x 135m x 170m block of earth, incorporating the specific geological layers of the site (sandstone and mudstone) using a modified Mohr–Coulomb constitutive model.
  • Train Load Simulation: Instead of a simple static weight, the researchers used a continuous beam model with elastic point support. This allowed them to simulate the dynamic "superposition" effect, where loads from multiple wheels and adjacent tracks combine to stress the soil.
  • Excavation Strategy: The study analyzed the double-side drift method with core soil. This involves excavating small "guide pits" on the sides first to provide stability before removing the center, which is a standard but highly controlled technique for large-span tunnels in poor soil.

Datasets

As this is a civil engineering case study rather than a machine learning paper, it does not use training datasets. Instead, it utilizes:

  • Site-Specific Geotechnical Data: Mechanical parameters (density, elastic modulus, Poisson’s ratio, cohesion) for the Shaximiao and Xintiangou geological groups.
  • Standardized Rail Parameters: Technical specifications for Chinese 43#, 50#, and 60# rail types (cross-sectional area, moments of inertia) to model track stiffness accurately.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "W" Pattern: The excavation of three parallel tunnels creates a lateral settlement trough shaped like a "W." The most significant impact occurs directly above the left tunnel, which was the first to be excavated in the sequence.
  • Uplift Before Settlement: Interestingly, the tracks don't just sink. As the tunnel face approaches, the tracks undergo a slight initial uplift before the inevitable settlement and eventual stabilization.
  • Stiffness as a Shield: The stiffness of the rail itself plays a massive role in safety. Heavier rails (like the 60# type) distribute loads more effectively across the "ballast," resulting in significantly less settlement (5.13mm) compared to lighter 43# rails (6.85mm).
  • The 90% Rule: The simulation revealed that 90% of the total settlement occurs within just 10 meters of the tunnel vault excavation. This highlights a critical "window" where primary support must be installed immediately to prevent runaway deformation.

Key Results

  • Settlement Limits: The maximum ground settlement was 7.8 mm, and the maximum track settlement was 6.8 mm. Both were well within the project's safety threshold.
  • Impact Range: The "settlement trough" created by the three tunnels has a longitudinal impact range of 25–145 meters.
  • Differential Settlement: The height difference between two rails on the same track (a major safety metric) gradually increased as the tunnel face moved from 35m to 75m, after which it converged and stabilized.
  • Horizontal Deviation: The maximum horizontal displacement was only 2.18 mm, significantly lower than the 4 mm safety limit stipulated by Chinese Railway Repair Rules.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study is highly specific to the geology of the Chongqing region (sandstone and mudstone). In "soft soil" areas (like silt or clay), the deformation would likely take much longer to stabilize, requiring different monitoring durations.

Future work could involve integrating real-time IoT sensor data from the tracks back into the numerical model to create a "digital twin" that can predict settlement in real-time during the excavation of even more complex, multi-level tunnel intersections.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper is based on the proximity engineering project of the Baishiyi tunnel group passing under the Chongqing West Station track group. Considering the train load and the spatial relationship of the tunnel and track groups, the settlement patterns, horizontal displacement, and differential settlement of the tunnel-strata-tracks system during the excavation process are studied through theoretical calculations and numerical simulation methods. The results indicate that the tunnel vault, strata, and track settlement deformation patterns are similar. Throughout the tunnel construction process, the tracks underwent uplift, settlement, and eventually stabilized. The settlement trough formed by the excavation of the three tunnels below the track group has an impact range of 25-145 m. Between 35 and 75 m, the differential settlement of the double track gradually increases with excavation. As the tunnel face reaches 75 m, the track differential settlement gradually converges and tends to stabilize. To minimize the impact of underpass tunnel construction on track groups, it is recommended to use a combination of full-section hole grouting and surface reinforcement grouting for ground reinforcement. Additionally, optimizing the construction parameters, including the step length and primary support closure time, and strengthening the locking anchor can further reduce the impact.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2024railway,
  author = {Pinpin Li and Feng Lu and Haiyun Huang and Wenge Qiu},
  title = {{Railway track settlement patterns and control measures for multi-tunnel construction underneath a station track group: a case study}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-64916-6},
}
Figure