Radio forensics could unmask nearby off-axis gamma-ray bursts

I. Bartos, K. H. Lee, A. Corsi, Z. Márka, Szabolcs MárkaMonthly 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The multi-messenger observation of gamma-ray burst (GRB) 170817A from the nearby binary neutron-star merger GW170817 demonstrated that low-energy $\gamma$-ray emission can be observed at relatively large angles from GRB jet axes. If such structured emission is typical, then the currently known sample of short GRBs with no distance measurements may contain multiple nearby off-axis events whose delayed afterglows could have gone undetected. These nearby neutron star mergers may produce telltale radio flares peaking years after the prompt GRB emission that could still be observable. Here, we show that several short GRBs observed by the Burst Alert Telescope (BAT) on the Neil Gehrels Swift satellite, with no identified afterglow and no distance measurement, could potentially be associated with radio flares detectable by sensitive cm-wavelength radio facilities such as the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array. We also examine optical follow-up observations that have been carried out for these events, and find that a nearby GW170817-like kilonova is ruled out for only a third of them.

Introduction: Unmasking the Local Population

Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are among the most energetic events in the universe. Short GRBs (sGRBs), lasting less than two seconds, are primarily associated with the merger of binary neutron stars. Traditionally, these events are detected when their relativistic jets are pointed directly at Earth. However, the landmark discovery of GW170817/GRB 170817A proved that "off-axis" bursts—where the jet is tilted away from our line of sight—can be detected if they occur in the local universe.

Because off-axis bursts appear much fainter in gamma-rays and lack the immediate, bright multi-wavelength afterglow of on-axis events, many may have been recorded by the Swift satellite but dismissed as distant or unremarkable. This paper proposes a "radio forensics" approach to identify these missed local mergers by searching for their delayed radio signatures.

Methodology

The researchers utilized a three-pronged strategy to identify candidates:

  1. Candidate Selection: Filtering the Swift/BAT catalog for sGRBs lacking both an identified afterglow and a distance measurement.
  2. Theoretical Modeling: Using structured jet models (calibrated by GW170817) to simulate the evolution of radio flares at 6 GHz.
  3. Spatial Correlation: Cross-referencing GRB positions with the GLADE galaxy catalog to find potential hosts within 200 Mpc.

The "Late Bloomer" Effect

A critical insight of this work is the temporal behavior of off-axis afterglows. Unlike standard GRBs, where the afterglow peaks and fades within days, off-axis radio flares can take years to reach their maximum brightness.

Simulated 6 GHz radio light curves for an off-axis GRB at 200 Mpc, showing how peak flux occurs years after the initial event depending on ISM density.

As shown in the figure above, the peak time and intensity are highly dependent on the interstellar medium (ISM) density ($n$). In denser environments ($n \sim 1 \text{ cm}^{-3}$), the flare peaks earlier and brighter, while in low-density environments, the signal is significantly delayed and attenuated. This "late bloomer" effect means that GRBs detected over a decade ago might only now be reaching their peak radio visibility.

Key Results and Candidate Identification

The study identified approximately 20 sGRBs as prime candidates for radio follow-up. Two events, GRB 050906 and GRB 070810B, are particularly noteworthy due to their spatial coincidence with known galaxies within 200 Mpc.

Table of short GRB candidates identified for radio forensic follow-up, including kilonova exclusion status.

Analysis of historical data revealed that for two-thirds of these candidates, existing optical follow-up was insufficient to rule out a nearby GW170817-like kilonova. Only about 33% of the sample (marked with checkmarks in the table) have been definitively excluded as nearby mergers based on optical constraints.

Discussion and Future Outlook

The feasibility of detecting these flares using the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) is high, provided the ISM density is $n \gtrsim 0.1 \text{ cm}^{-3}$. The primary limitations remain the uncertainty of local gas densities and the incompleteness of current galaxy catalogs.

A dedicated radio survey of these "failed" GRBs could confirm a hidden population of local neutron star mergers. Such a discovery would refine our understanding of merger rates and provide a wealth of data for multi-messenger astrophysics, potentially identifying targets for future gravitational wave observing runs.

Summary updated

Abstract

The multi-messenger observation of gamma-ray burst (GRB)\,170817A from the nearby binary neutron-star merger GW170817 demonstrated that low-energy $\gamma$-ray emission can be observed at relatively large angles from GRB jet axes. If such structured emission is typical, then the currently known sample of short GRBs with no distance measurements may contain multiple nearby off-axis events whose delayed afterglows could have gone undetected. These nearby neutron star mergers may produce telltale radio flares peaking years after the prompt GRB emission that could still be observable. Here, we show that several short GRBs observed by the Burst Alert Telescope (BAT) on the Neil Gehrels \textit{Swift} satellite, with no identified afterglow and no distance measurement, could potentially be associated with radio flares detectable by sensitive cm-wavelength radio facilities such as the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array. We also examine optical follow-up observations that have been carried out for these events, and find that a nearby GW170817-like kilonova is ruled out for only a third of them.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bartos2019radio,
  author = {I. Bartos and K. H. Lee and A. Corsi and Z. Márka and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Radio forensics could unmask nearby off-axis gamma-ray bursts}},
  booktitle = {Monthly},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1093/mnras/stz719},
}
Figure