Radio Constraints on r-process Nucleosynthesis by Collapsars

K. H. Lee, I. Bartos, Avery Eddins, A. Corsi, Z. Márka, George C. Privon, S. MárkaThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates collapsars (massive star core-collapse events leading to black holes) as a potential source of heavy r-process elements. By analyzing radio observations of nearby gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), the authors place constraints on the amount of r-process material ejected by collapsars, finding that they are unlikely to be the dominant source of these elements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The origin of the heaviest elements in the universe, forged through the rapid neutron capture (r-process) of atomic nuclei, remains a significant puzzle. While neutron star mergers, notably GW170817, have been confirmed as an r-process site, their contribution might not fully explain the observed abundance of these elements. Collapsars, the explosive deaths of massive, rapidly rotating stars that form black holes, have also been proposed as a major r-process factory. However, directly observing the r-process ejecta from collapsars is challenging due to optical emission being outshone by accompanying supernovae and the difficulty of distinguishing their signals from other astrophysical phenomena. This paper aims to provide observational constraints on the r-process nucleosynthesis from collapsars by looking for their unique radio signatures.

Methods

The authors hypothesize that the "collapsar wind ejecta" – outflows from the accretion disk around the newly formed black hole – are responsible for forging r-process elements. This ejecta, if it interacts with the surrounding interstellar medium (ISM), should produce a distinct, slowly evolving radio flare. To probe this, the researchers analyzed radio observations of a sample of 11 nearby (within 2 Gpc) long GRBs detected by the Swift/BAT telescope. They used radio data from surveys like FIRST and VLASS, as well as a dedicated VLA follow-up observation for GRB 111225A.

They modeled the expected radio emission from collapsar wind ejecta interacting with the ISM. Two models for the ejecta velocity profile were considered: one based on GRMHD simulations of black hole accretion disks and another a power-law distribution. They also considered different scenarios for the density of the surrounding medium, ranging from uniform density to a wind-like density profile. The observed radio flux limits were then used to constrain the mass of the collapsar wind ejecta.

Datasets

The study utilized radio observations from:

  • FIRST survey: Conducted from 2009-2011.
  • VLASS survey: Two observing epochs.
  • VLA follow-up observation: For GRB 111225A in 2017.

The sample of GRBs was selected from the Swift/BAT catalog, specifically focusing on long GRBs within 2 Gpc that were observable by the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Radio flares as a probe for collapsar r-process: The paper proposes that late-time radio emission from the interaction of collapsar wind ejecta with the ISM can serve as a unique signature of r-process nucleosynthesis by collapsars, offering a way to bypass the challenges of optical observations.
  • Collapsars are likely not the dominant r-process source: The lack of detected radio counterparts (beyond the GRB afterglow) for most of the observed GRBs leads to stringent upper limits on the mass of r-process ejecta from collapsars. This suggests that while collapsars might contribute, they are unlikely to be the primary producers of the universe's heavy elements compared to neutron star mergers.
  • Model dependence of constraints: The study highlights that the derived constraints on collapsar ejecta mass are highly dependent on the assumed models for the ejecta velocity profile and the density of the surrounding interstellar medium. This underscores the need for improved theoretical modeling.

Key Results

  • For GRB 060505 and GRB 05826, under their fiducial model (uniform ISM density, p=2.5), the authors place a constraint that the collapsar ejecta mass is less than approximately 0.2 M☉.
  • For GRB 171205A, using a wind-like density profile for the circum-burst medium, they derived a stricter constraint of ≤ 0.5 M☉ (or ≤ 0.05 M☉ depending on the assumed shock termination radius).
  • No radio counterpart was identified for the studied GRBs that could be definitively attributed to collapsar wind ejecta beyond the expected GRB afterglow.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Uncertainty in ISM density: The density of the circum-burst medium is not precisely known for most GRBs, leading to significant uncertainties in the derived constraints.
  • Model uncertainties: The ejecta mass and velocity profile of collapsar winds are not yet well-modeled, and the parameters governing the radio emission (e.g., electron Lorentz factor power law index, energy fractions in electrons and magnetic fields) also carry uncertainties.
  • Potential interference from supernovae: Supernova ejecta from the same event could potentially complicate the interpretation of radio signals.

Future work should focus on:

  • Improved theoretical modeling: Developing more robust models for collapsar wind ejecta and their interaction with the ISM.
  • More precise measurements: Obtaining better constraints on the density of the circum-burst medium and the emission parameters.
  • Broader observational campaigns: Conducting more extensive and sensitive radio follow-up observations of GRBs to detect fainter signals or to further refine upper limits. This could help to definitively establish or rule out collapsars as significant r-process nucleosynthesis sites.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The heaviest elements in the universe are synthesized through rapid neutron capture ( r -process) in extremely neutron-rich outflows. Neutron star mergers were established as an important r -process source through the multimessenger observation of GW170817. Collapsars were also proposed as a potentially major source of heavy elements; however, this is difficult to probe through optical observations due to contamination by other emission mechanisms. Here we present observational constraints on r -process nucleosynthesis by collapsars based on radio follow-up observations of nearby long gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). We make the hypothesis that late-time radio emission arises from the collapsar wind ejecta responsible for forging r -process elements, and consider the constraints that can be set on this scenario using radio observations of a sample of Swift/Burst Alert Telescope GRBs located within 2 Gpc. No radio counterpart was identified in excess of the radio afterglow of the GRBs in our sample. This gives the strictest limit to the collapsar r -process contribution of ≲0.2 M ⊙ for GRB 060505 and GRB 05826, under the models we considered. Our results additionally constrain energy injection by a long-lived neutron star remnant in some of the considered GRBs. While our results are in tension with collapsars being the majority of r -process production sites, the ejecta mass and velocity profile of collapsar winds, and the emission parameters, are not yet well modeled. As such, our results are currently subject to large uncertainties, but further theoretical work could greatly improve them.
BibTeX
@article{lee2022radio,
  author = {K. H. Lee and I. Bartos and Avery Eddins and A. Corsi and Z. Márka and George C. Privon and S. Márka},
  title = {{Radio Constraints on r-process Nucleosynthesis by Collapsars}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/ac7ff0},
}
Figure