Radically Tunable n-Type Organic Semiconductor via Polymorph Control

Daniel W. Davies, Sang Kyu Park, Prapti Kafle, Hyun‐Joong Chung, Dafei Yuan, Joseph Strzalka, Stefan C. B. Mannsfeld, SuYin Grass Wang, Yu‐Sheng Chen, Danielle L. Gray, Xiaozhang Zhu, Ying DiaoChemistry 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the fascinating world of polymorphism in a specific n-type organic semiconductor, 2DQTT-o-B, uncovering five distinct crystal structures. By controlling these polymorphs, the researchers achieved an astonishing five-order-of-magnitude tuning of electron mobility and significant changes in optical properties, demonstrating a powerful strategy for designing advanced organic electronic materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organic semiconductors (OSCs) are a hot area for next-generation electronics, but their performance is highly sensitive to how the molecules pack in the solid state. This phenomenon, known as polymorphism, can drastically alter electronic and optical properties. While much research has focused on p-type OSCs, n-type OSCs (which transport electrons) have lagged behind, partly due to their inherent instability. This paper tackles the challenge of understanding and controlling polymorphism in n-type OSCs, specifically focusing on the quinoidal terthiophene derivative 2DQTT-o-B, to unlock its full potential. The authors aim to systematically map the polymorphic landscape of this molecule and correlate structural differences with electronic and optical performance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to characterize the polymorphs and their transitions:

  • Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC): Used to identify solid-solid phase transitions and their thermal behavior (exothermic/endothermic), providing clues about the thermodynamic relationships between polymorphs.
  • In Situ Cross-Polarized Optical Microscopy (CPOM): Allowed real-time observation of phase transitions in thin films as they were heated, revealing changes in birefringence and color, which correlate with structural and optical property changes.
  • In Situ Grazing Incidence X-ray Diffraction (GIXD): A key technique for determining the unit cell structures of the polymorphs, providing detailed information about molecular packing. This was crucial for understanding the structural basis of the observed property changes.
  • Single Crystal X-ray Diffraction (SCXRD): Used to obtain the definitive crystal structure of one of the polymorphs (polymorph I), serving as a reference for GIXD analysis.
  • UV-Vis Absorption Spectroscopy: Employed to probe the electronic structure and optical properties of the different polymorphs, observing shifts in optical band gaps and spectral features.
  • Field-Effect Transistor (FET) Fabrication and Measurements: Standard techniques were used to fabricate devices and measure electron mobility and threshold voltage, allowing for the direct assessment of electronic performance.

The novelty lies in the in situ nature of some of these measurements (CPOM, GIXD, UV-Vis) combined with systematic exploration of printing parameters and thermal annealing to map out the polymorphic phase space and transition pathways.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental characterization of a synthesized material rather than training or evaluating models on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Prolific Polymorphism in n-Type OSCs: The discovery of five distinct polymorphs (three previously unreported) for 2DQTT-o-B highlights that quinoidal n-type semiconductors can exhibit rich polymorphic behavior, similar to their p-type counterparts.
  • Structure-Property Correlation is Key: The study provides compelling evidence that subtle changes in molecular packing (polymorphism) can lead to dramatic, orders-of-magnitude changes in electronic properties like electron mobility.
  • Tuning Mobility Across 5 Orders of Magnitude: The ability to tune electron mobility from 5.63 x 10⁻⁵ cm²V⁻¹s⁻¹ to 0.22 cm²V⁻¹s⁻¹ simply by controlling the crystal structure is a remarkable achievement and a powerful demonstration of polymorphism as a design tool.
  • Quinoidal to Aromatic Transition: The observed changes in optical and electronic properties are suggested to be linked to a unique quinoidal-to-aromatic transition within the molecule, which is a characteristic of this class of compounds.
  • Biradical Character and Self-Doping: The authors propose that temperature-induced biradical formation might play a role in the observed electronic behavior, particularly the negative shift in threshold voltage, suggesting a self-doping mechanism.
  • Trigonal Polymorph III: An Enigma: Polymorph III exhibits a highly symmetric trigonal crystal structure but surprisingly shows extremely low conductivity, posing an interesting puzzle for future investigation.

Key Results

  • Five Polymorphs Identified: Polymorphs I', I'', I, II, and III were characterized. Polymorph I is the stable room-temperature form, while I' and I'' are metastable.
  • Mobility Modulation: Electron mobility was tuned over 5 orders of magnitude (from 10⁻⁵ to 10⁻¹ cm²V⁻¹s⁻¹).
  • Optical Band Gap Shifts: Optical band gaps varied from 1.18 eV to 1.40 eV.
  • Structural Diversity: Polymorphs ranged from highly disordered (I') to highly crystalline (I'') and featured different crystal systems, including monoclinic (I, II) and trigonal (III).
  • Transition Behavior: Polymorphs I' and I'' irreversibly transition to I upon heating. Polymorphs I, II, and III exhibit reversible, enantiotropic transitions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Disordered Polymorphs: Polymorphs I' and I'' exhibited poor current modulation and low mobility, likely due to their disordered nature and lack of long-range π-stacking.
  • Polymorph III's Low Conductivity: The extremely low conductivity of the trigonal polymorph III, despite its high symmetry, remains an enigma. The authors suggest that the trigonal packing might hinder efficient charge transfer pathways.
  • Biradical Formation Mechanism: While a connection between biradical formation and self-doping is proposed, the exact mechanism and its precise impact on polymorphism require further investigation.
  • Kinetic vs. Thermodynamic Transitions: Discrepancies between transition temperatures observed in situ (POM/GIXD) and DSC suggest kinetic factors and potential confinement effects play a role.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the displacive nature of the I-II transition, the role of biradical formation in self-doping, and the unique properties of polymorph III. They also highlight the potential for using this understanding to dynamically modulate electronic device properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

Polymorphism has emerged as an important design consideration in organic semiconductors (OSCs). Previously, in many OSCs, even small changes in molecular stacking can cause drastic changes to the optical and electronic properties. However, investigation into n-type semiconductors has significantly lagged behind their p-type counterparts. In this work, we present the prolific polymorphism of 2-dimensional quinoidal terthiophene (2DQTT-o-B) and systematically investigate each of 5 polymorphs, 3 of which have been previously unreported. Grazing incidence X-ray diffraction provided a key method to understanding the structure of each polymorph. Via the polymorphic transitions mapped, we tuned the electron mobility by 5 orders of magnitude, from 5.63 × 10–5 to 0.22 cm2 V−1 s–1. These were accompanied by modifications to the optical properties, namely we observed substantial differences in the refractive index noted by intensity differences under polarized optical microscopy and a large shift in optical band gap from 1.18 eV up to 1.40 eV. Finally, we suggest that changes to these properties may be related to the unique quinoidal to aromatic transition observed in quinoidal molecules.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{davies2021radically,
  author = {Daniel W. Davies and Sang Kyu Park and Prapti Kafle and Hyun‐Joong Chung and Dafei Yuan and Joseph Strzalka and Stefan C. B. Mannsfeld and SuYin Grass Wang and Yu‐Sheng Chen and Danielle L. Gray and Xiaozhang Zhu and Ying Diao},
  title = {{Radically Tunable n-Type Organic Semiconductor via Polymorph Control}},
  booktitle = {Chemistry},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.chemmater.0c04678},
}
Figure