RADIATIVE CORRECTION SCHEMES IN DEEP INELASTIC MUON SCATTERING

B. Badełek, D.y. Bardin, K. Kurek, Christoph Scholz1994

TL;DR

This paper compares two established methods for calculating radiative corrections in deep inelastic muon scattering: the Mo-Tsai (MT) scheme and the Dubna (D) scheme. The authors find that both upgraded versions of these schemes agree remarkably well, within 2%, in the kinematic regions where these corrections are most significant, suggesting a high degree of consistency in analyzing experimental data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In deep inelastic scattering experiments, like muon-proton scattering, the measured cross-section includes not only the desired signal from one-photon exchange but also contributions from other electroweak processes and real photon emissions (radiative corrections). To accurately extract information about the nucleon's internal structure, these unwanted contributions must be precisely accounted for. This paper addresses the need for a thorough understanding and comparison of the two primary theoretical frameworks used for these calculations: the Mo-Tsai (MT) scheme and the Dubna (D) scheme. Understanding their similarities and differences is crucial for ensuring the consistency of results from different experiments.

Methods

The paper provides a detailed theoretical comparison of the Mo-Tsai (MT) and Dubna (D) radiative correction schemes. The MT scheme is described as model-independent and non-covariant, relying on an "infrared cut-off" parameter ($\Delta$). The Dubna scheme, on the other hand, is formulated covariantly and employs a mixed approach, using model-independent calculations for leptonic current corrections and the quark-parton model (QPM) for hadron current corrections. The authors present the mathematical formulations of both schemes, highlighting their key differences, such as the D scheme's explicit independence from the infrared cut-off parameter due to a special mathematical procedure. They also discuss the inclusion of various higher-order corrections and interference terms in the upgraded versions of these schemes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical comparisons and numerical calculations based on established experimental conditions and parameters from previous experiments (e.g., NMC, BCDMS).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Agreement in Crucial Regions: Despite differences in their theoretical formulation (e.g., covariance, infrared cut-off parameter), the upgraded MT and D schemes show excellent agreement (better than 2%) in the kinematic regions where radiative corrections are largest (low $x$, high $y$). This is a significant finding for experimental data analysis.
  • Covariant vs. Non-Covariant Formulations: The Dubna scheme's covariant formulation is highlighted as a key advantage, leading to explicit independence from the infrared cut-off parameter $\Delta$, which is present in the MT scheme.
  • Impact of Higher-Order Corrections: The inclusion of $\tau$-lepton and quark loops in vacuum polarization and the photon-Z$^0$ boson interference terms in the upgraded MT scheme (FERRAD35) significantly impacts the total radiative correction, changing it by about 2% in the measured region.
  • Model Dependence: The D scheme's reliance on the quark-parton model for hadron current corrections allows for a more comprehensive treatment of these effects compared to the MT scheme, which does not include them in its inelastic calculations.
  • Numerical Challenges: The integration of radiative tails presents a significant numerical challenge, requiring high-accuracy routines or careful subdivision of integration intervals.

Key Results

The paper presents a detailed comparison of the Mo-Tsai (MT) and Dubna (D) radiative correction schemes. Numerical comparisons were made in the kinematic region of the NMC high-energy deep inelastic electroproduction experiment (0.003 < $x$ < 0.9, 0.1 < $y$ < 0.9 at 280 GeV). The key quantitative result is that the overall radiative correction factor $\eta$ reaches up to 50% at low $x$ and high $y$. In this region, the agreement between the FERRAD35 (upgraded MT) and TERAD86 (D) results is better than 2%. Differences between the schemes are generally insignificant over most of the phase space relevant to fixed-target DIS experiments and are of the order of other systematic errors in data analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Proton Resonance Neglect: The numerical calculations for the comparison neglected proton resonances.
  • Multi-photon Exchange: Neither scheme includes contributions from multi-photon exchange processes to the elastic radiative tail, which could be important for heavy nuclear targets. The paper notes that quantitative estimates for these processes are discussed in a separate paper.
  • MT Scheme Dependence on $\Delta$: While the MT scheme is formally $\Delta$-independent, calculations show a weak dependence on $\Delta$ for non-trivial values. For very small $\Delta$, this dependence becomes stronger, requiring separate calculation for each kinematic point.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further refinement of radiative correction calculations is ongoing, as evidenced by the comparison of upgraded versions of existing schemes. The mention of separate papers for specific aspects (like multi-photon exchange) indicates ongoing research in this area.

Summary updated

Abstract

A description and a detailed comparison of the Mo and Tsai and the Dubna radiative correction schemes is presented. Numerical comparisons made in the kinematical region of the NMC high energy deep inelastic electroproduction experiment are discussed. An overall agreement between the two approaches in the region of low x and high y, where the radiative corrections are largest, is better than 2%. 1
BibTeX
@misc{badeek1994radiative,
  author = {B. Badełek and D.Y. Bardin and K. Kurek and Christoph Scholz},
  title = {{RADIATIVE CORRECTION SCHEMES IN DEEP INELASTIC MUON SCATTERING}},
  year = {1994},
}
Figure