Radiation Environment in the Large Hadron Collider During the 2022 Restart and Related RHA Implications

Kacper Biłko, Rubén García Alía, Ygor Quadros de Aguiar, Salvatore Danzeca, Diego Di Francesca, S. Gilardoni, Sylvain Girard, Daniel Ricci, Marc Sebban, Sławosz UznańskiIEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive "health check" of the Large Hadron Collider’s (LHC) radiation environment during its 2022 restart following a three-year shutdown. By comparing new data against 2018 benchmarks and demonstrating the success of novel distributed fiber-optic sensors, the authors show that while radiation levels have shifted—decreasing in some areas but tripling in others—the move toward radiation-hardened designs is successfully keeping the accelerator running with fewer interruptions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The LHC is a 27-km ring of extreme conditions. To operate, it relies on millions of electronic components that must survive intense radiation. Radiation causes two main types of problems: Total Ionizing Dose (TID), which wears components down over time, and Single-Event Effects (SEEs), which are random "glitches" (like a bit-flip in memory) that can trigger an immediate, costly "beam dump" (emergency shutdown).

After the "Long Shutdown 2" (2019–2021), the LHC returned with higher beam energies and new hardware. The challenge for the Radiation to Electronics (R2E) team was to determine how these changes altered the radiation landscape. If radiation levels in specific alcoves rose unexpectedly, existing electronics might fail prematurely, threatening the goal of high "availability"—keeping the beams colliding for as long as possible.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-layered monitoring strategy:

  • Standard Monitors: They utilized ~3,500 Beam Loss Monitors (BLMs) for TID and ~235 "RadMons" to measure high-energy hadron and neutron fluences.
  • Distributed Optical Fibre Radiation Sensing (DOFRS): A novel technique using P-doped silica fibers. As radiation hits the fiber, it causes "Radiation-Induced Attenuation," allowing for a continuous, meter-by-meter map of radiation levels over hundreds of meters—a significant upgrade over discrete sensors.
  • SRAMs as Sensors: They repurposed the 90nm SRAM memories inside hundreds of "FGClite" power converter controllers. By counting how many Single Event Upsets (SEUs) occurred in these memories daily, they turned the accelerator's own control hardware into a massive, distributed radiation sensor network.
  • FLUKA Simulations: These Monte Carlo simulations were used to correlate physical measurements with the underlying causes, such as residual gas density in the vacuum chamber.

Datasets

The study draws on operational data from the LHC's 2018 and 2022 runs, including:

  • LHC Operation Statistics: Integrated luminosity, beam intensities, and beam dump counts.
  • Monitor Data: Time-series and spatial data from BLMs, RadMons, and the new DOFRS system.
  • Component Data: SEU counts from 752 arc-based power converters and 256 units in shielded alcoves.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Collimator Trade-off: To protect the machine at higher energies, engineers tightened the "aperture" of specific collimators (TCL6). This had a dramatic dual effect: radiation levels in the Dispersion Suppressor (DS) regions dropped by over two orders of magnitude (a win for electronics there), but radiation in nearby shielded alcoves (RRs) increased by a factor of ~3.3.
  • Vacuum "Memory": Radiation in the long arc sections of the tunnel increased by 3–5x compared to 2018. This wasn't due to the beam itself, but rather the "worse" vacuum quality (more residual gas molecules) following the long shutdown. The machine essentially needs time to "scrub" its vacuum chamber clean through operation.
  • Distributed Intelligence: The success of using FGClite SRAMs to map SEUs proved that system-level hardware can provide high-fidelity radiation data that matches dedicated monitors within 70% accuracy.

Key Results

  • Improved Reliability: Despite higher energies, the rate of radiation-induced beam dumps in 2022 was $\le 0.2$ per inverse femtobarn (fb⁻¹), nearing the ambitious High-Luminosity LHC target of $< 0.1$ fb⁻¹.
  • Spatial Mapping: The DOFRS system successfully provided the first continuous TID profiles in the Dispersion Suppressors, confirming that radiation peaks are highly localized.
  • RHA Success: The transition to the radiation-tolerant FGClite controllers prevented what would have been a 3x higher failure rate in the shielded alcoves compared to the previous generation of hardware.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors note that 2022 was a "recommissioning" year. As the LHC ramps up to full luminosity in 2023 and beyond, radiation levels will continue to evolve. While the current RHA (Radiation Hardness Assurance) approach is working, the localized increase in radiation in the RR alcoves means that some systems there are currently being targeted for further radiation-hardening upgrades. Future work will also focus on expanding the DOFRS coverage to provide even more granular data across the 27-km ring.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work we present the radiation environment of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), focusing on the year 2022, the first after the Long Shutdown 2 (2019-2021). We highlight the most prominent radiation level changes with respect to the 2018 operation, commenting on the related Radiation Hardness Assurance implications. In addition to presented data from well-established radiation monitors, such as Beam Loss Monitors and RadMons, we demonstrated the excellent capabilities of the recently deployed Distributed Optical Fibre Radiation Sensing covering selected regions of the LHC. Profiting from the SRAMs deployed along the accelerator and its shielded alcoves, we demonstrated their capabilities for distributed SEUs monitoring.
BibTeX
@article{biko2023radiation,
  author = {Kacper Biłko and Rubén García Alía and Ygor Quadros de Aguiar and Salvatore Danzeca and Diego Di Francesca and S. Gilardoni and Sylvain Girard and Daniel Ricci and Marc Sebban and Sławosz Uznański},
  title = {{Radiation Environment in the Large Hadron Collider During the 2022 Restart and Related RHA Implications}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/tns.2023.3328145},
}
Figure