R2D2 at SemEval-2022 Task 6: Are language models sarcastic enough? Finetuning pre-trained language models to identify sarcasm

Mayukh Sharma, Ilanthenral Kandasamy, Vasantha W BNAACL 2022

TL;DR

This paper explores the effectiveness of pre-trained language models (PLMs) for identifying sarcasm across three subtasks of SemEval-2022 Task 6. The authors found that while PLMs perform reasonably well, sarcasm detection remains a challenging task, especially for identifying specific types of irony. They introduced a Siamese network architecture for a subtask requiring distinguishing sarcastic text from its non-sarcastic rephrase, achieving a respectable 8th rank.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sarcasm, a pervasive form of figurative language used for humor, mockery, or expressing contempt, poses a significant challenge for sentiment analysis systems. Its inherent irony, where the intended meaning is the opposite of the literal one, makes it difficult for machines to detect. This difficulty is amplified by the socio-cultural nuances that influence sarcasm perception. Traditional sarcasm detection methods often rely on predefined criteria or human annotation, which can introduce noise and fail to capture the author's intended sarcasm. SemEval-2022 Task 6: iSarcasmEval specifically addresses this by using a dataset of intended sarcasm, aiming to improve the robustness of sarcasm detection models. The paper investigates how well current PLMs, which have revolutionized NLP, can handle this nuanced task.

Methods

The authors employed a two-pronged approach:

  • Finetuning PLMs for Classification (Subtasks A & B): For identifying sarcasm (Subtask A) and classifying different types of irony (Subtask B), they used standard finetuning techniques. This involves taking a pre-trained language model (like BERT, RoBERTa, MPNet, or ELECTRA) and further training it on the specific sarcasm detection dataset. This leverages the general linguistic knowledge already embedded in the PLMs.
  • Siamese Network for Sarcasm vs. Rephrase (Subtask C): To distinguish between a sarcastic statement and its non-sarcastic rephrase (Subtask C), they proposed a Siamese network architecture. This architecture uses two identical PLM "twins" that process the sarcastic text and its rephrase separately. These twins share weights, ensuring they learn to represent both inputs in the same feature space. The features are then fed into two branches:
  • Classification Branch: This branch uses standard classification heads to predict whether the input is sarcastic or not.
  • Similarity Branch: This branch employs a distance maximization loss function. The goal is to maximize the distance between the learned features of the sarcastic text and its rephrase, encouraging the model to learn distinct representations for each.

Datasets

The study utilized datasets for SemEval-2022 Task 6: iSarcasmEval, focusing on the English portions of the task. The paper notes that the datasets for Subtask A and Subtask B exhibit class imbalance, which they addressed by computing class weights. Subtask C's dataset, consisting of sarcastic texts and their non-sarcastic counterparts, did not have this imbalance issue.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PLMs are good, but not perfect for sarcasm: While PLMs show promise, their performance on sarcasm detection, especially for nuanced irony types, is still limited. This suggests that understanding figurative language requires more than just grasping semantic and syntactic features from large text corpora.
  • "Intended Sarcasm" is a crucial distinction: The use of a dataset focused on intended sarcasm is a significant step towards building more reliable sarcasm detection systems, mitigating noise from ambiguous annotations.
  • Siamese networks offer a novel approach for rephrase detection: The Siamese network architecture, particularly with its distance maximization loss, proved effective in distinguishing between sarcastic and non-sarcastic versions of the same underlying meaning. This highlights the potential of learning feature space separations for fine-grained text comparison.
  • Class imbalance is a real challenge: The authors explicitly mention class imbalance in Subtask B, underscoring its impact on model performance and the need for specific strategies to address it.

Key Results

  • The proposed system achieved a 7th rank in Subtask B (English) with a macro F1 score of 0.076.
  • The Siamese network for Subtask C (English) attained an accuracy of 75% and secured an 8th rank on the leaderboard.
  • For Subtask A (English), the PLMs showed similar performance, indicating a general capability but also room for improvement.
  • In Subtask B, identifying sarcasm and satire was easier than other irony types, which had very low performance metrics.
  • Models performed significantly better on Subtask C compared to Subtasks A and B, suggesting that distinguishing between a sarcastic text and its non-sarcastic rephrase is a more tractable problem for current models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Figurative Language is Hard: The authors acknowledge that PLMs, trained on general text, struggle to fully grasp the figurative nature of sarcasm. This suggests a need for models that can better understand context, cultural nuances, and implicit meanings.
  • Scope for Improvement: Despite decent performance, there's significant room for improvement in all subtasks, particularly in identifying specific irony types and in the overall accuracy of sarcasm detection.
  • Future Work: The authors express their intention to explore further improvements in future work, implying ongoing research into more sophisticated models and techniques for sarcasm detection.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sharma2022r,
  author = {Mayukh Sharma and Ilanthenral Kandasamy and Vasantha W B},
  title = {{R2D2 at SemEval-2022 Task 6: Are language models sarcastic enough? Finetuning pre-trained language models to identify sarcasm}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2022},
}
Figure