R-charges, Chiral Rings and RG Flows in Supersymmetric Chern-Simons-Matter Theories

Vasilis Niarchos2012

TL;DR

This paper explores the complex dynamics of three-dimensional supersymmetric gauge theories, specifically N=2 Chern-Simons-Matter (CSM) theories. The authors use insights from Seiberg duality and supersymmetry breaking to understand the behavior of R-charges and map out renormalization group (RG) flows, revealing surprising connections to four-dimensional gauge theories and hinting at a rich structure of interacting fixed points.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Three-dimensional gauge theories, particularly those with Chern-Simons (CS) interactions, present a challenge due to their tendency to become strongly coupled in the infrared (IR). While CS interactions help tame this, adding matter fields leads to complex non-perturbative phenomena. A key aspect of these theories is the U(1)R symmetry, whose behavior (specifically, the scaling dimensions of operators it governs) is crucial for understanding the theory's dynamics. However, determining this symmetry exactly in the strongly coupled regime is difficult. This paper aims to shed light on the non-perturbative behavior of U(1)R symmetries and the resulting RG flows in N=2 CSM theories, drawing parallels with better-understood four-dimensional N=1 SQCD theories.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of theoretical tools:

  • String Theory (Brane Configurations): They leverage configurations of D-branes and NS5-branes in Type IIB string theory to engineer specific CSM theories. These configurations provide a powerful way to understand supersymmetry breaking and Seiberg duality.
  • Seiberg Duality: This is a crucial tool, relating a strongly coupled gauge theory to a weakly coupled one (or vice versa) with a different gauge group and matter content. The paper postulates new examples of Seiberg duality in N=2 and N=3 CSM theories.
  • Supersymmetry Breaking: The conditions under which supersymmetry is spontaneously broken in these theories provide constraints on the R-charges and RG flows.
  • Chiral Rings: The structure of gauge-invariant operators (chiral rings) is analyzed, as it provides information about the theory's symmetries and dynamics.
  • Perturbative Calculations: While the focus is on non-perturbative aspects, two-loop perturbative calculations are used to gain insights into R-charge behavior.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Web of RG Flows: The paper reveals a complex network of RG flows connecting various interacting superconformal field theories in three dimensions, driven by superpotential deformations.
  • ADE Classification: A subset of these interacting fixed points exhibits an ADE (simply-laced Lie algebra) classification, mirroring a similar phenomenon observed in four-dimensional gauge theories.
  • New Seiberg Dualities: The authors propose novel examples of Seiberg duality for N=2 and N=3 CSM theories, extending the known landscape of dualities.
  • Three- vs. Four-Dimensional Parallels: Striking similarities are found between the non-perturbative dynamics of three-dimensional N=2 CSM theories and four-dimensional N=1 SQCD theories, particularly concerning chiral rings and Seiberg duality, despite different underlying mechanisms.
  • R-Charge Behavior: The paper provides semi-quantitative insights into how R-charges behave under strong coupling and superpotential deformations, often decreasing and leading to new relevant operators.

Key Results

The paper presents:

  • Constraints on R-charges: Inequalities for R-charges are derived from spontaneous supersymmetry breaking and Seiberg duality.
  • Identification of RG Flows: A detailed analysis of RG flows generated by various superpotential deformations (quadratic, cubic, quartic, sextic) in different classes of CSM theories (CS-SQCD, 1-adjoint CS-SQCD, 2-adjoint CS-SQCD).
  • Postulation of New Dualities: New Seiberg dualities are proposed for N=2 and N=3 CSM theories, including duals for theories with adjoint matter.
  • ADE Classification: Evidence for an ADE classification of some IR fixed points is presented.
  • Qualitative Understanding: A qualitative picture of R-charge behavior and the emergence of new fixed points is developed, particularly for theories with adjoint fields.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exact Analytic Tools: The paper acknowledges the lack of exact analytic tools for determining U(1)R symmetries in interacting three-dimensional theories, similar to the challenge of a-maximization in four dimensions.
  • Precise Parameter Ranges: While RG flows and fixed points are identified, establishing the precise range of parameters for which these phenomena occur and proving that the IR fixed points are indeed superconformal remains an open problem.
  • Holographic Descriptions: The possibility of holographic dual descriptions for some of these N=2 CSM theories is raised, particularly for those with ADE classification, suggesting further investigation into string/M-theory connections.
  • Understanding R-Charge Behavior: Further work is needed to precisely understand the behavior of R-charges, especially in regimes where they decrease significantly and lead to new relevant operators.
  • Generalizing ADE Classification: Exploring deeper connections with other cases where ADE classification occurs and extending results from two-dimensional CFTs to these three-dimensional theories are suggested future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We discuss the non-perturbative behavior of the U(1)R symmetry in N = 2 superconformal Chern-Simons theories coupled to matter in the (anti)fundamental and adjoint representations of the gauge group, which we take to be U(N). Inequalities constraining this behavior are obtained as consequences of spontaneous breaking of supersymmetry and Seiberg duality. This information reveals a web of RG flows connecting different interacting superconformal field theories in three dimensions. We observe that a subclass of these theories admits an ADE classification. In addition, we postulate new examples of Seiberg duality in N = 2 and N = 3 Chern-Simons-matter theories and point out interesting parallels with familiar non-perturbative properties in N = 1 (adjoint) SQCD theories in four dimensions where the
BibTeX
@misc{niarchos2012r,
  author = {Vasilis Niarchos},
  title = {{R-charges, Chiral Rings and RG Flows in Supersymmetric Chern-Simons-Matter Theories}},
  year = {2012},
}

Loading related content...

Figure