Quiver Varieties and Hilbert Schemes

Andrey KuznetsovMoscow 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper establishes a deep connection between two seemingly different mathematical objects: Nakajima's quiver varieties and Hilbert schemes. It shows that certain Hilbert schemes, which parameterize points on a space, can be explicitly described as specific quiver varieties, which arise from representation theory. This connection provides a new geometric perspective on these objects and leads to a surprising combinatorial identity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the problem of understanding the geometric structure of Nakajima's quiver varieties and their relationship to Hilbert schemes. Quiver varieties are powerful tools in algebraic geometry and representation theory, offering rich examples of hyperkähler manifolds. Hilbert schemes, on the other hand, are fundamental in algebraic geometry for studying families of geometric objects, like points on a surface. The authors aim to provide an explicit geometric description of certain quiver varieties by identifying them with specific Hilbert schemes, particularly those related to the resolution of singularities of a quotient space $X/\Gamma$, where $X = \mathbb{C}^2$ and $\Gamma$ is a finite subgroup of $SL(2, \mathbb{C})$. This connection is facilitated by the McKay correspondence, which links finite subgroups to affine Dynkin graphs, the underlying structures of these quiver varieties.

Methods

The paper employs a combination of techniques from representation theory, algebraic geometry, and symplectic geometry. Key methods include:

  • McKay Correspondence: This fundamental tool is used to associate an affine Dynkin graph to a finite subgroup $\Gamma \subset SL(2, \mathbb{C})$. This graph then defines the structure of the relevant quiver varieties.
  • Quiver Varieties as Moduli Spaces: The authors leverage the interpretation of quiver varieties as moduli spaces of representations of quivers, a framework developed by Crawley-Boevey. This allows for algebraic descriptions and manipulations.
  • Symplectic Reduction: Quiver varieties are often constructed via symplectic reduction. The paper utilizes this to relate quiver varieties to moduli spaces of representations of quivers with relations.
  • Derived Equivalences: The paper establishes derived equivalences between categories of coherent sheaves on different spaces, which are crucial for relating the geometric objects.
  • Fixed-Point Analysis: For specific cases (e.g., when $\Gamma = \mathbb{Z}/d\mathbb{Z}$), the authors analyze the fixed points of torus actions on Hilbert schemes. This combinatorial approach is key to deriving the combinatorial identity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper deals with theoretical constructions and isomorphisms, not empirical data analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unification of Quiver Varieties and Hilbert Schemes: The central insight is the explicit identification of certain $\Gamma$-equivariant Hilbert schemes and Hilbert schemes of points with specific Nakajima quiver varieties. This bridges two important areas of mathematics.
  • McKay Correspondence as a Bridge: The McKay correspondence is shown to be a crucial link, translating the structure of finite subgroups into the combinatorial data needed for quiver varieties, which then correspond to geometric objects like Hilbert schemes.
  • Combinatorial Identity from Geometric Objects: A surprising outcome is the derivation of a combinatorial identity relating the number of uniformly colored Young diagrams to collections of Young diagrams. This identity arises from counting fixed points of torus actions on Hilbert schemes, which are shown to be isomorphic to quiver varieties.
  • Genericity Conditions: The paper highlights the importance of "generic" parameters for ensuring smoothness and establishing isomorphisms, a common theme in the study of moduli spaces.

Key Results

  • Isomorphism of Quiver Varieties and Hilbert Schemes: The main result is the isomorphism between specific quiver varieties $M_{\zeta, \zeta_R}(nv^\circ, w^\circ)$ and $\Gamma$-equivariant Hilbert schemes $X_\Gamma^{[n]}$ and Hilbert schemes $X_\Gamma^{[n]}$ for certain parameters and dimension vectors.
  • Diffeomorphism of Hilbert Schemes: It is shown that the varieties $X_\Gamma^{[n]}$ and $X_\Gamma^{[n]}$ are diffeomorphic.
  • Combinatorial Identity: For $\Gamma = \mathbb{Z}/d\mathbb{Z}$, the paper proves the identity $UCY(n, d) = CY(n, d)$, where $UCY(n, d)$ is the number of uniformly colored Young diagrams and $CY(n, d)$ is the number of collections of $d$ Young diagrams with a total of $n$ boxes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Genericity Assumptions: The results often rely on parameters being "generic." Understanding the behavior when parameters are not generic, especially when crossing walls in parameter space, is a direction for future work.
  • Specific Cases: While the paper focuses on $X = \mathbb{C}^2$ and finite subgroups $\Gamma \subset SL(2, \mathbb{C})$, generalizations to higher dimensions or more general singularities could be explored.
  • Further Connections: The paper hints at connections to Calogero-Moser spaces and other moduli spaces. Further investigation into these relationships could yield deeper insights.
  • Explicit Constructions: While isomorphisms are established, the explicit nature of these maps and their implications for understanding the geometry of these spaces could be further explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this note we give an explicit geometric description of some of the Nakajima's quiver varieties.More precisely, we show that the Γ-equivariant Hilbert scheme X Γ [n] and the Hilbert scheme X[n] Γ (where X = C 2 , Γ ⊂ SL(C 2 ) is a finite subgroup, and X Γ is a minimal resolution of X/Γ) are quiver varieties for the affine Dynkin graph, corresponding to Γ via the McKay correspondence, the same dimension vectors, but different parameters ζ (for earlier results in this direction see [4,12,13]).In particular, it follows that the varieties X Γ [n] and X [n] Γ are diffeomorphic.Computing their cohomology (in the case Γ = Z/dZ) via the fixed points of (C * × C * )-action we deduce the following combinatorial identity: the number U CY (n, d) of uniformly coloured in d colours Young diagrams consisting of nd boxes coincides with the number CY (n, d) of collections of d Young diagrams with the total number of boxes equal to n.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kuznetsov2007quiver,
  author = {Andrey Kuznetsov},
  title = {{Quiver Varieties and Hilbert Schemes}},
  booktitle = {Moscow},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.17323/1609-4514-2007-7-4-673-697},
}
Figure