TL;DR
This paper investigates the production of J/ψ mesons in muon-nucleus interactions, revealing that J/ψ mesons are absorbed within nuclear matter. By comparing J/ψ production in tin and carbon, the researchers provide an independent measurement of the J/ψ-nucleon interaction cross-section and find that the suppression of J/ψ production in nuclei is consistent with color transparency models, particularly at higher energies.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding how particles interact within the complex environment of atomic nuclei is a fundamental challenge in nuclear physics. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of how J/ψ mesons, which are composed of a charm and anti-charm quark pair, behave when produced inside a nucleus. Previous theoretical models, like the Vector Meson Dominance (VMD) model, suggested that J/ψ mesons might interact with nucleons within the nucleus, leading to a reduced production rate compared to what would be expected from simple scaling with the number of nucleons. This paper aims to experimentally measure this suppression and compare it to predictions from various theoretical frameworks, including color transparency models, which propose that the interaction probability of a particle within a nucleus depends on its "formation time" and how "visible" it is to the nuclear constituents.
Methods
The New Muon Collaboration (NMC) utilized a modified EMC forward spectrometer and the M2 muon beam line at CERN to study J/ψ muoproduction. They collected data from muon interactions with hydrogen, deuterium, carbon, and tin targets at incident energies of 200 and 280 GeV.
The core of their analysis involved:
- Invariant Mass Reconstruction: Identifying J/ψ mesons by reconstructing the invariant mass of their decay into muon pairs (μ⁺μ⁻).
- Quasielastic Event Selection: Applying specific kinematic cuts (on variables like energy transfer
νand transverse momentum squaredp²) to isolate events where the J/ψ is produced without significant nuclear breakup. - Vector Meson Dominance (VMD) Model: Using the VMD model to relate the observed J/ψ production to the interaction of a virtual photon with the nucleus. This model allows for the extraction of J/ψ and ρ⁰ meson radii and their total cross-sections with nucleons.
- Glauber Approach: For nuclear targets (carbon and tin), they employed the Glauber model to analyze the absorption of J/ψ mesons within the nucleus. This approach relates the suppression of J/ψ production to the J/ψ-nucleon cross-section.
- Color Transparency (CT) Models: Comparing the measured nuclear suppression to predictions from various CT models, which consider the finite formation time of the J/ψ and its interaction with the nuclear medium.
Datasets
The experiment used data collected by the New Muon Collaboration (NMC) from muon interactions with:
- Hydrogen (H)
- Deuterium (D)
- Carbon (C)
- Tin (Sn)
These datasets were collected at incident muon energies of 200 GeV and 280 GeV. The paper also references and compares results with previously published data on ρ⁰ production and elastic pion-nucleon scattering.
Key Insights and Ideas
- J/ψ Absorption in Nuclei: The most significant finding is that the production rate of J/ψ mesons in tin and carbon nuclei is suppressed compared to what would be expected if the production scaled linearly with the number of nucleons. This suppression is attributed to the absorption of the J/ψ as it propagates through the nuclear medium.
- Independent Determination of J/ψ-Nucleon Cross-Section: By analyzing the nuclear suppression within the framework of the Glauber model, the researchers were able to derive an independent measurement of the total J/ψ-nucleon cross-section.
- Color Transparency as a Key Factor: The observed energy dependence of the J/ψ nuclear suppression is found to be qualitatively consistent with predictions from color transparency models, particularly those that incorporate a finite formation time for the J/ψ. This suggests that the "visibility" of the J/ψ to the nuclear constituents plays a crucial role.
- Comparison with ρ⁰ Production: The study also compares the transverse momentum distributions of J/ψ and ρ⁰ mesons, finding that ρ⁰ production is steeper, implying a smaller radius for ρ⁰ compared to J/ψ.
Key Results
- The ratio of quasielastic J/ψ production cross-sections per nucleon for tin to carbon, Rge(Sn/C), was found to be less than unity: 0.94 ± 0.14 at 200 GeV and 0.73 ± 0.07 at 280 GeV.
- An independent determination of the total J/ψ-N cross-section was obtained: 0.8 ± 1.9 mb at 200 GeV and 3.6 ± 0.9 mb at 280 GeV.
- The measured energy dependence of Rge(Sn/C) showed better agreement with color transparency models that predict increasing suppression at higher energies (Refs. [5,9]) compared to models predicting decreasing suppression (Refs. [3,4]).
- The radii of J/ψ and ρ⁰ mesons were estimated using the VMD model, with the J/ψ radius being larger than that of the ρ⁰.
Limitations and Future Work
- Statistical Limitations: The authors acknowledge that due to limited statistics, it was not possible to definitively distinguish between the VMD model and models that include color transparency effects.
- Model Dependence: The interpretation of the results relies on the assumptions of the VMD and Glauber models, as well as the specific color transparency models used for comparison.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that further measurements with higher statistics would be beneficial to more precisely probe the color transparency effects and to better understand the propagation of J/ψ mesons in nuclear matter. The study of the energy dependence of the nuclear suppression is highlighted as a key avenue for future research.
Summary updated