Quasi-probabilities in conditioned quantum measurement and a geometric/statistical interpretation of Aharonov’s weak value

Jaeha Lee, Izumi TsutsuiProgress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics 2016

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new mathematical framework for describing the joint behavior of quantum observables, even when they don't commute. This framework, called "quasi-joint-probability distributions" (QJPs), provides a novel geometric and statistical interpretation of Aharonov's weak value, connecting it to orthogonal projections and conditional averages.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In quantum mechanics, measuring the values of multiple observables simultaneously can be problematic, especially if they don't commute (like position and momentum). Standard probability theory, which works beautifully for classical systems, struggles to describe these situations. This paper tackles the challenge of developing a robust mathematical framework to handle the joint behavior of such non-commuting quantum observables. A key motivation is to provide a solid foundation for understanding Aharonov's weak value, a concept that has gained traction for its potential in quantum metrology and understanding quantum phenomena, but whose physical interpretation has remained somewhat elusive.

Methods

The authors employ a two-pronged approach:

  1. Bottom-up (Operational Construction): They analyze the mathematical framework of "conditioned measurement schemes." This involves measuring one observable while using the outcome of another observable to "condition" the result. This operational approach helps build the QJP distributions from the ground up.
  2. Top-down (Spectral Theorem and Fourier Transforms): They leverage the spectral theorem for operators and its Fourier transform properties. This provides a more abstract, mathematical foundation for constructing and understanding QJPs.

A key novelty is the introduction of "quasi-joint-probability" (QJP) distributions as extensions of standard probabilities. They also develop a new inner product on the space of operators, which allows for geometric interpretations of "conditionings" and "correlations."

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • QJPs for Non-Commuting Observables: The paper establishes that QJPs can describe the joint behavior of non-commuting observables, unlike standard probability distributions.
  • Ambiguity in QJPs: For non-commuting observables, there isn't a single unique QJP distribution; instead, there's a family of candidates, reflecting the inherent indefiniteness in describing their joint behavior.
  • Geometric Interpretation of Quantum Concepts: QJP distributions induce geometric structures on the space of observables. Orthogonal projections and inner products gain statistical interpretations as "conditionings" and "correlations," respectively.
  • Weak Value as Projection/Conditioning: Aharonov's weak value is reinterpreted as either an orthogonal projection of one observable onto a subspace defined by another, or as a conditioning of one observable given another. This provides a concrete geometric and statistical meaning to the weak value.
  • Unified Framework: The work aims to provide a unified mathematical framework for understanding quantum measurement, QJPs, and the weak value.

Key Results

  • A general prescription for constructing QJP distributions for arbitrary pairs of quantum observables is presented.
  • For commuting observables, the QJP distribution reduces to the standard joint probability distribution.
  • For non-commuting observables, a family of QJP distributions is shown to exist, reflecting an inherent ambiguity.
  • A novel inner product is introduced on the space of operators, leading to geometric interpretations of conditioning and correlations.
  • A geometric and statistical interpretation of Aharonov's weak value is provided, linking it to orthogonal projections and conditional averages.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their treatment, while aiming for mathematical rigor, relies on concepts from measure and integration theory, and generalized functions. They mention that a full treatment of generalized functions is beyond the scope of this paper, leading to some compromises in generality and transparency. They suggest that further exploration of these mathematical tools could lead to a more complete understanding. The paper also highlights the inherent ambiguity in defining QJPs for non-commuting observables, suggesting that further work is needed to fully characterize and utilize this family of distributions. The authors also point to potential applications in developing novel uncertainty relations for approximation and estimation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that the joint behavior of an arbitrary pair of (generally noncommuting) quantum observables can be described by quasi-probabilities, which are an extended version of the standard probabilities used for describing the outcome of measurement for a single observable. The physical situations that require these quasi-probabilities arise when one considers quantum measurement of an observable conditioned by some other variable, with the notable example being the weak measurement employed to obtain Aharonov’s weak value. Specifically, we present a general prescription for the construction of quasi-joint probability (QJP) distributions associated with a given combination of observables. These QJP distributions are introduced in two complementary approaches: one from a bottom-up, strictly operational construction realized by examining the mathematical framework of the conditioned measurement scheme, and the other from a top-down viewpoint realized by applying the results of the spectral theorem for normal operators and their Fourier transforms. It is then revealed that, for a pair of simultaneously measurable observables, the QJP distribution reduces to the unique standard joint probability distribution of the pair, whereas for a noncommuting pair there exists an inherent indefiniteness in the choice of such QJP distributions, admitting a multitude of candidates that may equally be used for describing the joint behavior of the pair. In the course of our argument, we find that the QJP distributions furnish the space of operators in the underlying Hilbert space with their characteristic geometric structures such that the orthogonal projections and inner products of observables can be given statistical interpretations as, respectively, “conditionings” and “correlations”. The weak value $A_{w}$ for an observable $A$ is then given a geometric/statistical interpretation as either the orthogonal projection of $A$ onto the subspace generated by another observable $B$, or equivalently, as the conditioning of $A$ given $B$ with respect to the QJP distribution under consideration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2016quasi,
  author = {Jaeha Lee and Izumi Tsutsui},
  title = {{Quasi-probabilities in conditioned quantum measurement and a geometric/statistical interpretation of Aharonov’s weak value}},
  booktitle = {Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure