Quantum simulation of particle pair creation near the event horizon

Yao Wang, Chong Sheng, Yong‐Heng Lu, Jun Gao, Yi‐Jun Chang, Xiao-Ling Pang, Tian-Huai Yang, Shining Zhu, Hui Liu, Xian‐Min JinNational 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully simulated particle pair creation near an artificial black hole using a photonic chip. This breakthrough allows for the experimental observation of phenomena like Hawking radiation, which are otherwise inaccessible, paving the way for future investigations into quantum gravity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Unifying general relativity (GR) and quantum mechanics (QM) remains one of the biggest challenges in physics. While quantum field theory in curved spacetime predicts fascinating phenomena like Hawking radiation (particle creation near black holes), directly observing these effects is experimentally impossible with current technology. This paper addresses this gap by proposing and demonstrating an analog system – an artificial black hole on a photonic chip – that can simulate these GR-driven quantum effects in a controlled laboratory setting.

Methods

The core of this research lies in creating an "artificial black hole" using a photonic chip. This is achieved by leveraging the concept of transformation optics, which maps the behavior of light in inhomogeneous optical media to the propagation of particles in curved spacetime.

Specifically, the researchers used femtosecond laser direct writing to fabricate intricate waveguide lattices in borosilicate glass. These lattices are designed to mimic the spacetime metric of a Schwarzschild black hole near its event horizon.

  1. Mimicking Spacetime Curvature: The inhomogeneous coupling coefficients between waveguides in the lattice are precisely controlled to replicate the effective refractive index required by GR. This allows a single-photon wave packet to experience an "event horizon" where its propagation is dramatically altered.
  2. Simulating Boson Evolution: For simulating the behavior of bosons (like photons) near the black hole, a single-layer waveguide lattice was used. The researchers observed that a photon wave packet near the artificial event horizon exhibits an exponential acceleration, a behavior directly linked to the simulated spacetime curvature.
  3. Simulating Fermion Pair Creation: To study the more complex phenomenon of particle pair creation (analogous to Hawking radiation), a bi-layer waveguide lattice was employed. This design allows for the simulation of the Dirac equation, which governs fermions. The researchers successfully demonstrated the creation and subsequent separation of a "fermion pair" – a single photon wave packet that splits into two components representing positive and negative energy states. The positive energy component escapes the artificial black hole, while the negative energy component is "captured."

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments rely on fabricated photonic chips and direct measurements of photon behavior.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Photonic Chips as Analog Black Holes: The research demonstrates that carefully engineered photonic structures can effectively mimic the extreme gravitational conditions near a black hole's event horizon, allowing for the study of quantum phenomena predicted by GR.
  • Exponential Acceleration of Photons: The observed exponential acceleration of single-photon wave packets near the artificial event horizon provides direct experimental evidence for the influence of simulated spacetime curvature on quantum particle dynamics.
  • Quantum Simulation of Hawking Radiation: The successful creation and separation of a "fermion pair" (positive and negative energy photon components) is a significant achievement, directly analogizing the particle creation process near a black hole's event horizon, a key prediction of Hawking radiation.
  • Built-in Hanbury-Brown-Twiss Interferometer: The experiment reveals that the quantum evolution of the fermion pair itself acts as a Hanbury-Brown-Twiss interferometer, allowing for the observation of nonclassical correlations, a crucial aspect for verifying quantum phenomena.
  • Beyond Classical Analogues: Unlike previous simulations that were limited to classical regimes or flat space, this work focuses on the quantum evolution of single photons, providing a more rigorous approach to simulating quantum gravity effects.

Key Results

  • Boson Evolution: Experimental observation of exponential acceleration for single-photon wave packets near the artificial event horizon, with the acceleration index directly dependent on the simulated black hole's curvature.
  • Fermion Pair Creation: Demonstration of a single-photon wave packet splitting into two components representing positive and negative energy states. The positive energy component escapes, while the negative energy component is captured, mimicking Hawking radiation.
  • Nonclassicality Preservation: The experiment maintained a high degree of nonclassicality in the simulated quantum states, with measured second-order correlation functions ($g^{(2)}$) as low as 0.062±0.005.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Static Metric: The current simulation mimics a static Schwarzschild black hole. The authors suggest future work could involve emulating dynamic metrics, such as those describing cosmic expansion (FRW metric) or gravitational waves, by incorporating additional dimensions or control mechanisms.
  • Higher Dimensions: The current platform is primarily two-dimensional. The researchers propose extending the concept to emulate higher-dimensional spacetimes using more complex waveguide arrangements or synthetic dimensions.
  • Direct Observation of Negative Energy Particles: While the simulation demonstrates the behavior of negative energy components, direct observation of particles falling into a black hole is impossible in both real and analog scenarios. The focus remains on observing the escaping positive energy particle and the correlated behavior.

The paper highlights the potential of this photonic platform for future investigations into quantum gravity, offering a unique experimental avenue to probe phenomena that are otherwise beyond our observational reach.

Summary updated

Abstract

Though it is still a big challenge to unify general relativity and quantum mechanics in modern physics, the theory of quantum field related with the gravitational effect has been well developed and some striking phenomena are predicted, such as Hawking radiation. However, the direct measurement of these quantum effects under general relativity is far beyond present experiment techniques. Fortunately, the emulation of general relativity phenomena in the laboratory has become accessible in recent years. However, up to now, these simulations are limited either in classical regime or in flat space whereas quantum simulation related with general relativity is rarely involved. Here we propose and experimentally demonstrate a quantum evolution of fermions in close proximity to an artificial black hole on a photonic chip. We successfully observe the acceleration behavior, quantum creation, and evolution of a fermion pair near the event horizon: a single-photon wave packet with positive energy escapes from the black hole while negative energy is captured. Our extensible platform not only provides a route to access quantum effects related with general relativity, but also has the potentiality to investigate quantum gravity in future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020quantum,
  author = {Yao Wang and Chong Sheng and Yong‐Heng Lu and Jun Gao and Yi‐Jun Chang and Xiao-Ling Pang and Tian-Huai Yang and Shining Zhu and Hui Liu and Xian‐Min Jin},
  title = {{Quantum simulation of particle pair creation near the event horizon}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwaa111},
}
Figure